Skip to main content
Direct +1 949.864.9199 Office +1 714.234.5538 info@gandgsalt.com
G&G State Tax Group

CaliforniaIncome and franchise tax

How does California source carried interest that flows through tiers of partnerships, and what changes when the fee and the carry sit in separate entities?

The short answer

California fixes the character of a fund's gain at the fund, and that character, more than the number of tiers above it, decides how the gain is sourced. For a nonresident individual, the investment partnership exclusion comes first: when the partnership qualifies, its gains on stock are outside California source unless the investment activity is interrelated with a separate California business of the nonresident. Otherwise the fund apportions its business income, and nonbusiness gain on stock follows the holder's residence unless the stock acquired a business situs here. No published decision classifies a private equity fund's gain on a portfolio company, and the Franchise Tax Board's reading points to business income. A corporate holder apportions business income and allocates nonbusiness items to its commercial domicile. California does not apply the federal three-year holding period of Internal Revenue Code section 1061 for carried interest gain. An entity whose income is the management fee cannot qualify as an investment partnership; a carry entity can only if its own assets and income meet the investment partnership tests.

Working through this on a live matter? Contact the firm

The item and the entity that realizes it

A carried interest is a partnership interest, and California applies the federal partnership rules unless it provides otherwise (Rev. and Tax. Code section 17851). Under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) section 702(b), the character of each item a partner receives is set "as if such item were realized directly from the source from which realized by the partnership." The Franchise Tax Board (FTB) said in its December 2020 Chief Counsel Corner that for California income tax purposes, "a carried interest is treated as a partner's distributive share." The sourcing question therefore begins at the partnership that holds the asset, and it asks what kind of item the sale of a portfolio company produced there.

The label on the item does not answer that question. Regulation 25137-1(c) (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18) says that the labels customarily given to partnership income, capital gains among them, are "of no aid in determining whether partnership income is business or nonbusiness income." The Office of Tax Appeals (OTA) described the sequence in Appeal of Smith (2023-OTA-069P, issued December 7, 2022), quoting a court of appeal decision: income from a pass-through entity is "characterized at the [pass-through entity] level as either business or nonbusiness income," the business income is apportioned under the Uniform Division of Income for Tax Purposes Act (UDITPA, the state's apportionment statute), and the nonbusiness income is sourced under Rev. and Tax. Code sections 17951 through 17953 and 17955. The decision OTA quoted is The 2009 Metropoulos Family Trust v. Franchise Tax Board (2022) 79 Cal.App.5th 245, which concerned nonresident trusts that owned shares of a multistate S corporation.

California does not apply the federal three-year recharacterization. IRC section 1061 treats part of the long-term capital gain on a carried interest as short-term gain unless the interest was held for more than three years, and Rev. and Tax. Code section 18045, added in 2025, provides that section 1061 "shall not apply." The federal holding period therefore changes nothing in the California steps below. A separate article in this library covers the carried interest of a partner who changes residency, including this point.

The investment partnership rule comes first for a nonresident individual

Rev. and Tax. Code section 17955 applies notwithstanding the general sourcing sections for nonresidents, which include sections 17951 and 17952. It removes from a nonresident's California-source gross income dividends, interest, and gains and losses from "qualifying investment securities" if one of four cases applies. Case (a)(1) is the individual who holds the securities directly and whose only contact with California, as to those securities, is through a broker, dealer or investment adviser located here. Case (a)(2) is the one that reaches carried interest: for a partner's distributive share of income from qualifying investment securities, the partnership "qualifies as an investment partnership, whether or not the partnership has a usual place of business located in this state." The "only contact" condition belongs to case (a)(1) and is not part of case (a)(2). The remaining cases concern trust beneficiaries and regulated investment company shareholders and do not bear on carry.

An investment partnership is one that meets two tests: at least 90 percent of the cost of its total assets is qualifying investment securities, bank deposits and the office space and equipment reasonably necessary to its activities, and at least 90 percent of its gross income is interest, dividends and gains from the sale or exchange of qualifying investment securities (subdivision (c)(1)). Common stock is a qualifying investment security (subdivision (c)(3)(A)(i)). So if the partnership is an investment partnership and the gain is from the sale of qualifying investment securities, a nonresident individual's distributive share is outside California source unless subdivision (b) removes the exclusion. A fund managed from California does not lose the exclusion for that reason alone, because the statute applies whether or not the partnership has a usual place of business here.

Four limits matter for carry.

  1. The exclusion reaches only a nonresident individual. Section 17015 defines a nonresident as every individual other than a resident, and a California resident is taxed on entire taxable income wherever it is sourced (section 17041(a)(1)).
  2. An interest in a partnership is a qualifying investment security only if that partnership "is itself an investment partnership" (subdivision (c)(3)(B)). A fund that holds its portfolio positions through operating partnerships or LLCs (limited liability companies) taxed as partnerships may therefore fail its own asset test.
  3. Subdivision (b) withdraws the exclusion for investment activity interrelated with a trade or business of the nonresident, or of an entity in which the nonresident owns an interest in California, whose primary activities are separate and distinct from acquiring, managing or disposing of the securities. It also withdraws the exclusion where the securities were acquired with working capital of a California business in which the nonresident owns an interest.
  4. A corporation is treated differently. Section 23040.1 gives a corporate partner a parallel exclusion only if the partnership's income is the corporation's only California-source income, and it withdraws the exclusion for a corporation that participates in managing the partnership's investment activities or is engaged in a unitary business with one that does (subdivision (b)(1)). Section 17955 states no management limit and no only-income limit; the limit it states is subdivision (b).

The same December 2020 piece states the same ordering. With the exception of the investment partnership statute, it says, income from a partnership that carries on a trade or business is "generally sourced under" Regulation 17951-4.

The fund's business income is apportioned at the fund

If section 17955 does not apply and the gain is business income of the fund, Regulation 17951-4(d)(1) provides that "the total business income of the partnership shall be apportioned at the partnership level" under UDITPA. The nonresident's California-source share is the fund's California percentage applied to the nonresident's share of that income, and the holder's residence plays no part. For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2013, the percentage is the sales factor alone, except for a business that section 25128(b) describes (Rev. and Tax. Code section 25128.7), and a separate article in this library covers that exception. The fund's gross receipts from the sale are assigned under Regulation 25136-2, which other articles in this library cover. California amended that regulation for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2026, as those articles describe. This article does not rely on the amended text, and the example's sale year, 2025, uses the earlier text.

Section 17952 does not engage for the share of business income, because the item is the fund's business income passing through, not the holder's own gain on an intangible. Metropoulos reached that result for the shareholders of an S corporation and Smith reached it for a partner. The FTB's 2017 rulemaking notice (published November 3, 2017, with a public hearing and comment deadline of December 18, 2017) said that Regulation 17951-4(d) "is being revised to indicate that RTC section 17952 does not apply with respect to an interest in a partnership that conducts business within and without California." The qualifier confines the statement to subdivision (d) and to a partnership that apportions. Read without it, the sentence would say that section 17952 never applies to a partnership interest, which would contradict the nonbusiness path described below and Appeals of Burch, Carden and Carden.

Burch draws the line from the other side. In that opinion (2026-OTA-527P, issued July 24, 2026), the OTA read Regulation 17951-4(d), "by its plain terms," as applicable only to a nonresident partner's distributive share of unitary partnership income, not to a nonresident partner's sale of a partnership interest. It held that the nonresident individuals did not generate California-source income from sales of partnership interests for amounts attributable to unrealized receivables and inventory items under IRC section 751(a), and it concluded that it "declines to follow FTB Legal Ruling 2022-02." That ruling (July 14, 2022) treats a nonresident's sale of a partnership interest as two transactions: gain tied to section 751 property is sourced as income from a trade or business under Regulation 17951-4, and the remaining gain is sourced under section 17952. The FTB's index of legal rulings, last updated August 20, 2026, shows the ruling without a withdrawn or modified marker.

In Burch the appellants did not sell. An investment LLC in which they held direct membership interests sold part of its interest in an operating partnership, and the gain presumably reached the appellants on a Schedule K-1 as a distributive share. Footnote 2 records that the parties agreed the sourcing analysis should focus on a sale of a partnership interest in the appellants' hands. The OTA's 2026 list showed Burch as pending precedential, a designation that can still change, on November 11, 2026, and a separate article in this library covers a nonresident's sale of a partnership interest. The ruling's two-transaction rule should therefore not be treated as settled. The opinion declines to follow the ruling for stated reasons: the regulation's plain terms and the decision of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit in Rawat v. Commissioner (2024) 108 F.4th 891, which the OTA found persuasive though not binding in California.

Whether the fund's gain is business or nonbusiness income

The classification of the fund's gain decides which sourcing method applies, and the sources point both ways. The reading the FTB can be expected to take, and the contrary language, are these.

  1. The functional test points to business income for an operating fund. Business income includes income from tangible and intangible property "if the acquisition, management, and disposition of the property constitute integral parts of the taxpayer's regular trade or business operations" (Rev. and Tax. Code section 25120(a)). A private equity fund's regular operations are the acquisition, management and disposition of portfolio companies, so the FTB can be expected to say the gain is the fund's business income and the apportionment route applies. A separate article in this library, on a corporate limited partner in an investment fund, takes the same view of an investment or credit fund. This article adopts that reasoning for an operating fund of the kind in the example and reserves the nonbusiness result for a fund managed as an investment account, in the sense of Bass below. A fund that buys, manages and sells operating companies as its regular activity differs from the partnership in Bass, which held securities for long-term appreciation.
  2. Bass is the closest published support for the nonbusiness result. In Appeal of Bass (State Board of Equalization, January 25, 1989, No. 87A-1552-CB:DB), the partners were Texas residents and the partnership was headquartered in California; substantially all of its income came from dividends, interest and proceeds of sales of securities. The FTB argued that the partnership was doing business in California and that all of its property therefore had a business situs here, relying on its Legal Ruling No. 125, which the opinion describes as reaching that result for a family investment partnership. The State Board of Equalization rejected the argument. It found that the partnership was "simply investing the partners' capital primarily for long-term capital appreciation," with an average holding period of approximately 5.78 years, and held that the income from the partnership's investment securities was not California-source income. The test it applied comes from FTB Legal Ruling No. 179, which the opinion quotes: a fund whose activities are extensive and whose securities are bought and sold with reasonable frequency is conducting a business, and a fund "managed as an investment account" in which the securities are held for capital appreciation and income is not. The opinion also treated directors' fees paid to the general partners as California-source to the extent attributable to services performed here. It was decided long before the FTB's 2017 notice proposing to revise Regulation 17951-4, and the sources read show no carried interest in it, so it informs the classification and does not decide it.
  3. Markus is the counter-reading. In Appeal of Estate of Markus (State Board of Equalization, May 6, 1986, No. 84A-1008-GO), a nonresident partner's share of the income of a fund whose "partnership infrastructure was located in California" was California-source. The opinion rejected the partner's argument that the partnership interest had not acquired a business situs here, and it applied the conduit theory of partnerships: partnerships are conduits through which the taxpaying obligation passes, so the fund's activity, not the partner's, is what counts. It was also decided long before that notice, and the sources read show no carried interest in it.
  4. Regulation 17952(c) and Metropoulos are the FTB's business situs model. Under Regulation 17952(c), intangible personal property of a nonresident has a business situs here if it is "employed as capital in this State" or if its possession and control have been localized in connection with a business, trade or profession here, and the entire income from the property, including gains from its sale, is then income from California sources. Metropoulos held in the alternative that goodwill tied to a California unitary business acquired a business situs here: "we agree the goodwill acquired a business situs here." For a carry vehicle managed from California, the FTB can be expected to argue that the carry is a profits interest localized in the California management business.

The taxpayer's answers are three. Regulation 17952 does not use the words partnership or partner. The FTB's own 2017 notice confines the non-application of section 17952 to a partnership that conducts business within and without California, which leaves an investment-style fund outside that statement. And Regulation 17951-4(d)(4) sources a nonbusiness share "as if the income producing activity were undertaken by the partner in its individual capacity," where the income-producing activity is the fund's holding and sale of the portfolio stock, so the section 17952 question is asked of the stock and not of the carry interest.

The OTA's opinions page, which hosts the prior Franchise and Income Tax opinions of the State Board of Equalization, lists Bass and Markus without a precedential or nonprecedential designation. The OTA's rule on precedential status (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, section 30503) lets it withdraw the precedential status of a State Board of Equalization opinion previously designated as precedential, and the sources read do not show which of those older opinions, if any, hold that status. Neither opinion is called precedential here, and whether either binds is not settled by the sources read.

Nonbusiness items are sourced as if the individual earned them

If the fund's gain is nonbusiness income at the fund, Regulation 17951-4(d)(4) sources the partner's distributive share "as if the income producing activity were undertaken by the partner in its individual capacity." For a nonresident individual, a gain on stock is income from intangible personal property, which section 17952 treats as outside California source unless the property has acquired a business situs here. The statute gives way where a nonresident buys or sells such property in this state, or places orders with brokers in this state, "so regularly, systematically, and continuously as to constitute doing business in this state" (Rev. and Tax. Code section 17952; see also Regulation 17952(b) and (c)).

That is the sense in which the belief that carried interest follows residence holds. It holds for nonbusiness items, and it does not hold for business income that the fund apportions. For a nonbusiness stock gain, the question is whether the portfolio stock acquired a business situs here, and the FTB's counter-reading for a carry vehicle managed from California is described above. No decision read applies the business situs exception to a carried interest. In Burch, the FTB's own position, recorded in Factual Finding 5, was that the partnership interests did not acquire a business situs here. Bass rejected the theory for the securities of a long-term investment partnership.

The services-based theory under Regulation 17951-5 does not engage a distributive share on its face. That regulation allocates a nonresident's compensation for personal services by working days, and its text does not use the words partner, partnership or distributive share. A separate article in this library covers that audit theory.

Through tiers

Regulation 17951-4, the regulation for nonresident individuals, has no sentence headed lower tier or tiered, but its text is less silent than that suggests. Each intermediate partnership is itself a partner in the partnership below it, so subdivision (d)(1) operates at the tier that realizes the item and subdivision (d)(4) at each tier above it for nonbusiness items. Subdivision (d)(2) applies Regulation 25137-1(f) by name when the partner is unitary with the partnership, and Regulation 25137-1(a) states that the same principle applies where a taxpayer's partnership "itself owns an interest, directly or indirectly, in one or more other partnerships." The FTB's 2017 notice says the general rules of Regulation 25137-1 "also apply to lower-tier partnerships." Subdivisions (d)(5) and (d)(6)(B)1 count interests held through another partnership and attribute them proportionately, which is a tier rule in terms.

The decisions fill more of the gap. In Smith, the appellant "owned an indirect membership interest in a limited liability company" classified as a partnership, and that holding company's sale of its interest in an operating partnership produced the gain. The appellant did not assert that his indirect interest made Regulation 17951-4(d) inapplicable. The OTA said he "improperly focuses the analysis on the gain at his level" when the gain was generated at the level of the holding company, and that "the apportioned gain retains its character as California source income as it flows up." It also said that unitary combination "does not require that a partner have control of the partnership that is combined." Smith therefore applied subdivision (d) at the tier that realized the gain, for a nonresident two tiers up, on a point the appellant did not contest.

Footnote 2 of Burch treated a lower-tier sale gain that reached nonresident individuals as a distributive share from a nonunitary upper-tier LLC as implicating section 17952, and it cites Regulation 17951-4(d)(4) for the point that section 17952 is implicated when the source of a nonresident partner's distributive share of items does not constitute business income. It is a footnote, it rests on the parties' agreement, and it sits in an opinion that is pending precedential. Neither Smith nor Burch involved a fund's gain passing through a carry vehicle that holds only an interest in the fund. Read together, the sources support three propositions, each with its limit.

  1. Character is fixed where the asset is held and carries up each tier (IRC section 702(b); Smith; Regulation 25137-1(a)). The limit is that no source read decides how an intermediate tier that has its own business is treated.
  2. Business income apportioned by the lower tier carries up with that apportionment, unless the upper tier is unitary with the lower tier, in which case the regulation moves apportionment to the unitary partner under Regulation 25137-1(f) (Regulation 17951-4(d)(2); Smith). The limit is that unity is a question of fact, and control is not required.
  3. Nonbusiness items are sourced at the level of the ultimate individual under subdivision (d)(4) and section 17952, and for a corporation at its own commercial domicile under sections 25125(c) and 25126 (Burch, footnote 2; Regulation 25137-1(b)). The limit is that Regulation 17951-4 does not say in terms whether an intermediate partnership is the "partner" whose individual capacity is imagined.

The presumption in subdivision (d)(5), that the business of one partnership is not ordinarily unitary with another business activity of a partner, and its exception in subdivision (d)(6) for partners who own, directly or indirectly, a 20 percent or more capital or profits interest, bear on carry structures because a carry is a profits interest. Subdivision (d)(6)(B)1 treats an interest owned by or for a partnership as owned proportionately by its partners. The constructive rule decides who crosses 20 percent, and a combination then uses only the share "from interests actually (not constructively) owned." A holder who owns half of a carry vehicle that holds a 20 percent profits interest holds a constructive 10 percent, below the threshold. The vehicle itself holds 20 percent, so the presumption in subdivision (d)(5) is unavailable to it.

A corporate holder

A corporation that holds the carry, directly or through tiers, applies Regulation 25137-1. If the corporation is unitary with the fund, it combines its share of the fund's income and factors with its own, and its share is measured by "its interest in profits of the partnership" (subdivision (f)(4)). If it is not unitary with the fund, its share of the fund's trade or business is "treated as another trade or business" of the corporation, apportioned with the fund's factors (subdivision (g)). The regulation's own example runs the arithmetic as the fund's business income times the apportionment percentage times the interest: "$40,000 ($500,000 x 40% x 20%)."

Items that are nonbusiness at the fund go to the allocation statutes as the corporation's own nonbusiness income. A gain on the sale of stock is allocable to this state if the corporation's commercial domicile is here (section 25125(c)), and interest and dividends follow the same rule (section 25126). Commercial domicile is "the principal place from which the trade or business of the taxpayer is directed or managed" (section 25120(b)). The classification is made at the partnership level (Regulation 25137-1(c)). The separate article on a corporate limited partner in an investment fund says the same: the classification tiers up through the structure, and the partner does not reclassify at the top. The corporation's result therefore depends on the fund's classification, as version C of the example does.

The corporate investment partnership exclusion in section 23040.1 is available only if the fund's share is the corporation's only California-source income, and only if the corporation does not participate in managing the fund's investment activities and is not unitary with one that does. A carry holder that is part of the management structure therefore rarely qualifies.

The entity split

A management company earns the fee, and a separate entity holds the carry. The consequences for California run through four points.

  1. Different sourcing rules for different income. Fee income is a service receipt, assigned under Regulation 25136-2 and, for asset management services, as the separate articles in this library on asset management fees explain. The FTB addressed a management company in Chief Counsel Ruling 2013-04 (December 30, 2013). A nonresident was a founder and member of an LLC that managed a private equity fund. The ruling states that "All of the trade or business of LLC is conducted in California" and that "LLC is not a qualified investment partnership," and it concludes that the nonresident should treat 100 percent of his allocable share of the LLC's income as California-source under Regulation 17951-4(a), which sources the entire net income of a nonresident's business conducted wholly within California here. The ruling concerns one taxpayer's facts. It treats the management company's income separately from the founder's allocation from the fund, which it describes as operating as a qualified investment partnership, and the part read does not analyze the fund allocation. The statutory ground for a fee entity is section 17955(c)(1)(B): fee income is not interest, dividends or gains from qualifying investment securities. The carry entity's income is its distributive share of the fund's income, to which sections 17955 and 17951-4(d) apply as described above.
  2. The carry entity's own investment partnership test. Section 17955(a)(2) asks whether the partnership of which the nonresident is a partner qualifies. For a nonresident who holds the carry through an entity, that is the carry entity. The carry entity's interest in the fund is a qualifying investment security only if the fund "is itself an investment partnership" (subdivision (c)(3)(B)). The carry entity's own income can be argued to pass the 90 percent income test because, under IRC section 702(b) as adopted by section 17851, its distributive share takes the character of the fund's item, a gain from the sale of stock. The FTB's likely reading is therefore that the tests run at the carry entity the nonresident holds, with subdivision (c)(3)(B) reaching down to the fund, and Chief Counsel Ruling 2013-04 tested the entity the nonresident held. What stays open is whether the FTB would instead look through to the fund alone. If each tier is tested, a carry entity that also receives fee income would fail the 90 percent gross income test once the fees exceed 10 percent of its gross income. That is a reason, from the statute, for the split to matter to the nonresident members.
  3. The LLC fee. An LLC pays the section 17942 fee on its total income from California sources: $900 for $250,000 or more but less than $500,000, $2,500 for $500,000 or more but less than $1,000,000, $6,000 for $1,000,000 or more but less than $5,000,000, and $11,790 for $5,000,000 or more. The exclusion in subdivision (b)(1)(A) covers allocations and distributions to an LLC as a member of, or holder of an economic interest in, another LLC that are attributable to income already subject to the fee. It does not cover an allocation from a limited partnership fund. The Form 568 instructions state that an LLC with an ownership interest in a pass-through entity other than an LLC must report its distributive share, together with the matching cost of goods sold and any deductions, and a separate article in this library on investment managers computes the fee on a carry LLC's share of fund income. So the carry LLC's share of the fund's gain enters its total income. The California-assigned amount follows the rules for assigning sales under sections 25135 and 25136 (subdivision (b)(1)(B)). What stays open is how the fund's stock-sale receipt is assigned under those rules and how the worksheet in the Schedule IW instructions treats a capital gain in a distributive share, which the instructions read for this article do not say. Separate LLCs under common control (the same persons own, directly or indirectly, more than 50 percent of the capital or profits interests) may have their total income aggregated if the FTB determines that they "were formed for the primary purpose of reducing fees." The statute says the total income "may be determined by the Franchise Tax Board" to be that of all the commonly controlled LLC members, so the aggregation is the FTB's determination to make, and each commonly controlled LLC is jointly and severally liable.
  4. Registration and annual tax. An LLC doing business in California pays an annual tax in the amount section 17941(a) takes from section 23153(d), which is $800. The annual tax and the Secretary of State registration differ by entity form, and the separate article on investment manager entity forms covers them. For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2027 and before January 1, 2030, an LLC required to file a return under section 18633.5 pays $400 for its first taxable year instead of the section 23153 amount (section 17941(g)(2)); section 17935(f)(2) carries the same rule for limited partnerships.

Texas. Texas passive entity status requires a general or limited partnership or a trust, other than a business trust (Tex. Tax Code section 171.0003(a)(1)). An LLC cannot be a passive entity whatever its income. A limited partnership that holds only the carry can meet the 90 percent test, which counts distributive shares of partnership income and gains from the sale of securities among its listed sources. If it also receives fee income, the fee income is not among those listed sources, so a carry partnership whose fee income exceeds 10 percent of its federal gross income fails the test whatever the definition of active trade or business in section 171.0004 says. That section was not read for this article. The Texas Constitution answers the individual's exposure: Article VIII, section 24-a bars the legislature from taxing the net incomes of individuals, including an individual's share of partnership and unincorporated association income. It says nothing about the carry entity's own franchise tax. In the example below, the Texas question is the carry LLC's: as an LLC it cannot be passive, and it is a taxable entity if it does business in Texas. A separate article in this library on Texas passive entities and one on investment manager entity forms cover the combined group point for an LLC carry vehicle.

New York City. Whether the carry entity or the fee entity owes the New York City unincorporated business tax is covered by a separate article in this library on the self-trading exemption. That article holds that a management company's fees are taxable while the fund's own trading gains are within the exemption. Nothing further was researched for this article.

Withholding. The FTB may require withholding on partnership income or gains by regulation, and a person that fails to withhold or remit is liable for the amount section 18668 specifies (Rev. and Tax. Code section 18662). The rules for withholding on distributions to nonresident partners, through tiers and with waivers, are outside this article.

What remains open

No source read for this article answers the following points. Each also appears in the section where it arises.

  1. Whether a private equity fund's gain on a portfolio company is business or nonbusiness income of the fund. Two State Board of Equalization opinions classify a partnership's securities income for nonresident partners on their own facts: Bass (1989), which reached a nonbusiness result for a long-term investment partnership, and Markus (1986), which reached a California-source result for a fund with California infrastructure. Neither involves a private equity fund, a carried interest or an apportioning business. No published decision classifies a private equity fund's gain on a portfolio company.
  2. How the investment partnership test applies through tiers. The statute's words point to testing the partnership the nonresident holds, with subdivision (c)(3)(B) reaching down to the fund, and Chief Counsel Ruling 2013-04 tested the entity the nonresident held, but no source states the rule for a chain. It is open whether the FTB would instead look through to the fund alone.
  3. Whether a carried interest, or the underlying stock, held through an entity managed from California has acquired a business situs. No decision read applies the business situs exception to a carried interest, and the FTB's counter-reading for a carry vehicle managed from California is untested.
  4. Which tier is the partner under Regulation 17951-4(d)(4) for a chain. The regulation's text treats an intermediate partnership as a partner, Smith applied subdivision (d) at the tier that realized the gain on a point the appellant did not contest, and footnote 2 of Burch, by the parties' agreement, treated a lower-tier gain that reached the individuals as a distributive share as implicating section 17952, citing subdivision (d)(4) with a "see also" signal. Open are an intermediate tier that has its own business, and a holding tier's role under subdivision (d)(4) that no decision decides.
  5. How the fund's stock-sale receipt is assigned to California for the carry LLC's section 17942 fee, and how the worksheet in the Schedule IW instructions treats a capital gain that arrives in a distributive share.
  6. The Texas combined group treatment of an LLC carry vehicle, the Comptroller's current rule on passive entity status of a carry partnership, and the definition of active trade or business in Tax Code section 171.0004, none of which was researched here.
  7. Whether Bass and Markus are precedential, and whether the OTA will designate Burch precedential or change its pending status. The OTA's opinions page lists the older opinions without a designation, and the OTA's 2026 list showed Burch as pending precedential.
  8. The subsequent history of Metropoulos, which was not checked, and how the amended Regulation 25136-2 assigns a fund's receipts for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2026.

Worked example

The fund, the owners and the amounts below are invented, and the amounts are round figures chosen for the illustration. The example does not describe a typical or recommended structure.

Facts. A private equity style fund, organized as a limited partnership, sells its stake in an operating company in 2025 and recognizes a $10,000,000 long-term capital gain. A general partner LLC, called Carry LLC below and taxed as a partnership, holds a 20 percent carried interest, meaning it is allocated 20 percent of the fund's profits, with no hurdle, clawback or capital interest. Its only asset is that interest. Two individuals own Carry LLC equally: Ana, a California resident, and Ben, a Texas resident. The fund also has outside investors who are not part of the example. Ben has no other California income. A second LLC, called Manager LLC below and also owned equally by Ana and Ben, earns the management fee.

Step 1: Carry LLC's share. 20 percent of $10,000,000 = $2,000,000. Each owner's share is 50 percent of $2,000,000 = $1,000,000.

Step 2: Ana. A resident is taxed on entire taxable income (section 17041(a)(1)), so her $1,000,000 is taxable in California whatever its source. Section 1061 plays no role in California.

Step 3: Ben, three versions of the fund. Ben's rate is the tax on his entire income as if he were a resident, divided by that income, and it is applied to his California-source income (section 17041(b)(2)); the versions below show only the California-source amount. The question under section 17955 arises here, at the first tier. Ben is a member of Carry LLC, and his distributive share comes from Carry LLC, whose only asset is its interest in the fund. The statute does not say whether the 90 percent tests run at the fund, at the partnership the nonresident holds, or at each tier. The FTB's likely reading is that they run at the entity Ben holds, Carry LLC, with subdivision (c)(3)(B) reaching down to the fund, and that Carry LLC passes the income test because its distributive share takes the character of the fund's stock gain. The fund's California percentage in version B, 12 percent, is an input assumed for the example. In practice it is the fund's own computation and is not derived here.

  • Version A: $0 in California-source income. The fund meets the 90 percent tests and the stock is a qualifying investment security. Either the tests are applied at the fund alone, or Carry LLC also meets them, its only asset being an interest in an investment partnership and its income a distributive share of the fund's gains from stock sales. The gain is also not interrelated under subdivision (b) with a separate California business of Ben's, meaning either that Manager LLC's primary activities are not separate and distinct from managing the fund's securities, or that the carry is not interrelated with the fee business (section 17955(a)(2), (b) and (c)).
  • Version B: $120,000. The fund does not qualify, and the gain is business income apportioned by the fund at 12 percent: $1,000,000 x 12 percent = $120,000 (Regulation 17951-4(d)(1); section 25120(a)).
  • Version C: $0. The fund does not qualify, and the gain is nonbusiness income of the fund, as for a fund managed as an investment account in the sense of Bass. Ben's share is sourced as if he earned the stock gain directly, and the stock had no California business situs (Regulation 17951-4(d)(4); section 17952).

Version A has two stated tensions. First, Step 6 gives Ben an interest in Manager LLC, an entity in which he owns an interest, so the FTB can say the investment activity is interrelated with that entity's business under subdivision (b). The taxpayer's answers are that managing the fund's securities is the activity subdivision (b) describes as not separate and distinct, that the management limit is written for corporations only (section 23040.1(b)(1)), and that the exclusion applies whether or not the partnership has a California place of business. Second, if the tests are applied tier by tier, Carry LLC must meet them itself, and a Carry LLC that also received fee income would not. The $0 stands on the stated premise.

Version B is the result when the fund's gain is business income, the posture this article adopts for an operating fund. Version C depends on the classification of the fund's gain as nonbusiness, for which Bass is the closest published support and for which Markus, the FTB's Legal Ruling No. 125 as the Bass opinion describes it, and the functional test of section 25120(a) are the counter-reading. It also depends on the stock having no California business situs, a question asked of the stock and not of the carry interest. The $0 in version C depends on both, and no source read decides either for a private equity fund.

Step 4: The same carry held through a second intermediate partnership. Carry LLC now holds its interest through Carry Holdings LP, a limited partnership that is the partner in the fund, and Carry LLC owns all of the economic interest in Carry Holdings LP. The $10,000,000 gain arises at the fund. Carry Holdings LP's share is $2,000,000, and it passes to Carry LLC and then to Ana and Ben. Character was fixed at the fund and carries through each tier. Version B is unchanged at $120,000 for Ben, because the apportionment result belongs to the fund and neither intermediate tier has its own business with which to be unitary. The presumption in Regulation 17951-4(d)(5) is unavailable to Carry Holdings LP, which holds 20 percent directly. If either intermediate tier were unitary with the fund, apportionment would move up to that tier under subdivision (d)(2) with the fund's factors flowing up, as in Smith. Ben is constructively a 10 percent holder (0.50 x 0.20), below the 20 percent threshold, and any combination would use only interests owned in fact, not constructively. Version C is unchanged at $0. Version A adds only the second intermediate tier to the question already raised at Step 3: an interest in Carry Holdings LP is a qualifying investment security of Carry LLC only if Carry Holdings LP "is itself an investment partnership," and Carry Holdings LP earns only distributive shares of the fund's gains, which take the character of gains from the sale of stock. The example leaves version A at $0 on the premise that each tier qualifies, and the look-through alternative stays open.

Step 5: A corporate holder in place of Ben. A C corporation, called Carry Corp below, holds the whole $2,000,000 in place of Carry LLC. It is commercially domiciled in Nevada, is subject to California tax because it earns California-source income through the fund, and is not unitary with the fund. - In the business income case, it is a separate business and the California portion is $2,000,000 x 12 percent = $240,000 (Regulation 25137-1(g); the regulation's own example runs the same product). - In the nonbusiness case, the stock gain is allocated to commercial domicile under section 25125(c), and the California amount is $0. - If Carry Corp were commercially domiciled in California, the same nonbusiness gain would be allocated here in full, $2,000,000.

The $0 depends on the fund's classification as nonbusiness, as version C does. Section 23040.1 is unavailable if Carry Corp participates in managing the fund's investments.

Step 6: The split, with the fee entity. Manager LLC, owned by Ana and Ben, has $1,200,000 of total income assigned to California in 2025. Its LLC fee is $6,000, because $1,200,000 is at least $1,000,000 and under $5,000,000 (section 17942(a)(3)). Carry LLC's $2,000,000 share of the fund's gain enters its total income. The California-assigned amount follows sections 25135 and 25136 under section 17942(b)(1)(B), and the assignment of the fund's stock-sale receipt under those rules is open. For illustration only, if 12 percent of that share were assigned to California, an assumption for the fee that is separate from the fund's apportionment input in version B, the amount would be 12 percent x $2,000,000 = $240,000. That is under the $250,000 floor, so no fee is due, and the figure would change with any other assignment percentage. If the FTB determined under section 17942(b)(2) that the two LLCs were formed primarily to reduce fees, total income would be treated as $1,200,000 + $240,000 = $1,440,000 on that assumption, with the same $6,000 bracket. The statute makes that determination the FTB's to make, and each commonly controlled LLC is jointly and severally liable.

What the example shows, and what it leaves out. It shows that residence matters only for nonbusiness items and that the fund's apportionment, not the owner's home state, controls business income. It leaves out the derivation of the fund's California percentage, withholding amounts, the nonresident's rate computation, the sale of the carry itself, federal section 1061 and the net investment income tax, and the Texas combined group.

Practice notes

Ask the fund, before the carry holder's return is prepared, for its classification of each item as business or nonbusiness income, the investment partnership designation in item G(2) of its Schedule K-1 (565), and its California percentage with the year of the factors.

Test the investment partnership tests at the entity the nonresident holds as well as at the fund before relying on section 17955 for a nonresident member. Run the carry entity's own 90 percent asset and income tests on its own gross income, with any fee income in the denominator, and check the interrelated-business limit in subdivision (b) against any fee entity the member also owns.

Do not apply section 1061 on the California return, and track the federal recharacterization separately. Check the federal Schedule K-1 reporting instructions for section 1061, which were not researched for this article, before the Schedule K-1 request list is finalized.

For a corporate holder, document commercial domicile, any participation in managing the fund's investments, and any unity with a participant before claiming section 23040.1 or an allocation under section 25126.

For separate LLCs under common control, document the business reasons for the separation. Compute the section 17942 fee for each LLC on its own total income, including the carry LLC's distributive share at its California-assigned amount, with the commonly controlled determination in view.

Treat withholding on carry distributions to a nonresident member as a separate calendar item under section 18662.

Where the fund's classification of its gain as nonbusiness is the basis of a return position, keep the facts that support an investment account alongside the Schedule K-1: holding periods, frequency of trading, and management of the securities as an account. Bass turned on those facts.

G&G State Tax Group advises fund managers, carry holders and their advisers on the California sourcing of carried interest through tiers of partnerships, the investment partnership exclusion, and the choice of entities for the fee and the carry, alongside its state and local tax practice.

This article states the law as of November 11, 2026

Statutes, rates, thresholds, and agency practice change, and a different set of facts can change the answer. Before acting on anything discussed above, contact G&G State Tax Group, or another state and local tax adviser, to confirm what has changed since this was written and how the rules apply to a specific situation.

Contact the firm+1 714.234.5538 · info@gandgsalt.com

This publication is informational in nature and is not, and should not be considered, legal, accounting, tax, or other professional advice for any person or situation. Correct application of tax law depends heavily on the facts and circumstances in each case, and G&G State Tax Group, LLC assumes no liability in connection with the use of this information, and is not obligated to inform any reader of changes in the law or other factors that could affect the information contained herein.