CaliforniaIncome and franchise tax
Who owes California withholding on a nonresident partner's distributions in a tiered partnership, and can a waiver reach distributions already made?
The short answer
The lower-tier partnership withholds 7 percent on California source distributions to an unregistered upper tier, per the Franchise Tax Board (FTB). Unregistered means no California Secretary of State registration and no staffed California office. Regulation 18662-4 makes a partnership that pays California source income to a nonresident individual a withholding agent, so on the literal text the upper tier has its own duty, and nothing in force lets the lower tier's withholding satisfy it. The FTB's 2024 impact assessment rejected placing the duty on the upper tier, and proposed Regulation 18662-7 (not adopted; December 30, 2022 text) would limit the upper tier's separate duty to income the lower tier did not withhold on. A Form 590 "remains valid until the payee's status changes," and moving out of California changes it, so after an unreported move the agent relies on good faith and reasonable cause, with reversal once the partner files and pays. A Form 588 waiver must be requested before the distribution. No source found lets a waiver reach a distribution already made and remitted, but an agent that withheld and has not remitted must return the amount to the payee once a waiver issues (Publication 1017, FAQ 70).
Working through this on a live matter? Contact the firm
Who is the withholding agent at each tier
The statute delegates the details. Revenue and Taxation Code section 18662(a) provides that the FTB "may, by regulation, require any person, in whatever capacity acting," who has "the control, receipt, custody, disposal, or payment" of the income items listed in subdivision (b) to withhold an amount that the FTB determines "to reasonably represent the amount of tax due." The list in subdivision (b) includes rents and "partnership income or gains." Under subdivision (d), a person that fails to withhold or to remit "is liable for the amount specified in Section 18668."
The rate, the threshold, the payees and the exits sit in the regulations in title 18 of the California Code of Regulations, cited here by section number: the definitions in Regulation 18662-2, the withholding rules in Regulation 18662-4, the remittance and reporting rules in Regulation 18662-8 and the pass-through credit rule in Regulation 19002(b). Regulation 18662-7 is not a source of pass-through rules. Its page is headed "Certificates of Residence. [Repealed]", with a repealer history reading "operative 7-1-2014", and Regulation 18662-4(a)(4) lists it as "18662-7 (Withholding Rules for Domestic (U.S.) Pass-through Entities) [reserved]". The FTB's pending proposal would use that number again, so a reader who meets "18662-7" in FTB materials is reading the proposal and not a rule in force.
The lower tier's agency rests on two definitions that carry no condition. A "withholding agent" is "the person that has the control, receipt, custody, disposal, or payment of an item of income" (Regulation 18662-2(z)). A payee includes a partnership, and the definition also reaches "any person who receives payments or distributions from a pass-through entity, estate, or trust" (Regulation 18662-2(q)). The definition of payer in Regulation 18662-2(r) is conditioned: it includes a person making a payment to an intermediary or pass-through entity "to the extent the intermediary, pass-through, or person provides a Form W-9 or other appropriate information relating to a payee." This article therefore rests the lower tier's duty on the definitions of withholding agent and payee and not on the payer definition.
The working rule is payment by payment. Whoever pays California-source income to a nonresident payee is the agent for that payment, and each agent answers for its own failure. A lower-tier partnership that distributes to an upper-tier partnership is the agent for that distribution. Section 18668(a) states the liability: "Every person required under this article to deduct and withhold any tax is hereby made liable for that tax, to the extent provided by this section."
The lower tier's duty when the upper tier is a partnership
Who is a payee subject to withholding
Withholding is mandatory on payments of California-source income to two groups. Regulation 18662-4(a)(1) provides that withholding of tax at source "is required for payments of California source income made to nonresident individuals and non-California business entities." A non-California business entity "means any business entity that does not meet the requirements of a California business entity as set forth in subsection (b)," the definition of a California business entity. A California business entity is one "incorporated, organized, or formed, and existing under the laws of California," and a business entity that has not qualified to transact intrastate business "will be considered as having a permanent place of business in California only if it maintains an office in California that is permanently staffed by its employees" (Regulation 18662-2(b), (i), (s)). A Delaware limited partnership that is not registered with the California Secretary of State and keeps no California office staffed by its employees is, on those words, a non-California business entity.
Two further texts confirm the placement. Publication 1017, in the answer to FAQ 22, lists among the nonresident entities subject to withholding "Partnerships and LLCs that do not have a permanent place of business in California and are not registered through SOS" (the Secretary of State). The Form 590 exemption reason for a partnership payee in Regulation 18662-4(h)(3)(C) is that the payee "is a partnership or LLC having a permanent place of business in California at the payee address shown on FTB Form 590, or is registered with the SOS." FAQ 108 addresses a partner that is itself a partnership. It asks whether withholding is required when a partnership distributes California-source income to domestic nonresident partners that are partnerships, publicly traded partnerships or master limited partnerships, and answers: "Yes. Unless the partnership receives a waiver (Form 588, Nonresident Withholding waiver request), the partnership is required to withhold on all California source income distributions made to these domestic nonresident partners." So the lower tier withholds on its distributions to an unregistered upper tier, and a waiver for the upper tier as payee is the exit the publication names.
The amount: 7 percent, and the first $1,500
The rate is stated in Regulation 18662-4(a)(3): "The withholding rate is 7 percent of the gross payment or distribution amount." The first slice of income is optional: "Withholding of tax at source is optional and at the discretion of the withholding agent on the first $1,500 of income paid for the calendar year to each payee" (Regulation 18662-4(a)(2)). Withholding 7 percent of the whole payment and leaving the first $1,500 unwithheld are both within the regulation.
The FTB's own pages word the threshold differently, and this article states the difference without choosing. The 2025 Instructions for Form 592 say "Withholding must begin as soon as the total payments of California source income for the calendar year exceed $1,500." The FTB's page on withholding on nonresidents says agents are required to withhold 7 percent on payments or distributions to nonresident payees "when the total payments or distributions of CA source income exceeds $1,500 for the calendar year." The FTB's Pass-Through Entity Withholding page describes the 7 percent as applying to the part of the gross payment or distribution amount over $1,500 in a calendar year. Publication 1017 FAQ 31 says "Withholding is optional, at the discretion of the withholding agent, on the first $1,500 in payments made during the calendar year," and also where the S corporation shareholder or partner has received a waiver of withholding from the FTB.
What the lower tier files and what the upper tier gets
The lower tier remits on Form 592-Q for the periods set by Regulation 18662-8(c)(1)(B): "Withholding on payments is due on the same dates as required for calendar year federal estimated tax." For 2025 payments the 2025 Instructions for Form 592 give the following dates.
- January 1 through March 31, 2025: April 15, 2025.
- April 1 through May 31, 2025: June 16, 2025.
- June 1 through August 31, 2025: September 15, 2025.
- September 1 through December 31, 2025: January 15, 2026.
The instructions add that "When the due date falls on a weekend or holiday, the deadline to file and pay without penalty is extended to the next business day." June 15, 2025 was a Sunday, which is why the second date is June 16.
A domestic pass-through entity that is the withholding agent files Form 592-Q "with each quarterly withholding remittance," and the annual return is Form 592-PTE, due "no later than January 31st of the year following the year for which such withholding was required to be remitted" (Regulation 18662-8(c)(2)(B)). The instructions for Form 592-PTE call the filer in this position a lower tier PTE (pass-through entity): "A lower tier PTE is an entity with California source income that has a PTE owner." The lower tier also gives the upper tier a Form 592-B, because "a payee statement shall be provided to the payee aggregating all withholding for the tax year by January 31st of the following year" (Regulation 18662-8(c)(2)(E)).
The credit and the bar on a refund to the upper tier
The upper tier cannot recover the lower tier's withholding in cash. Regulation 19002(b) provides that "Tax withheld from payments to pass-through entities must be passed through to the entity's owners and reported on FTB Form 592-B according to their ownership interest in the pass-through entity, except that owners of pass-through entities may authorize the pass-through entity to use some or all of the withholding credit to satisfy the entity-level tax of the pass-through entity due for the taxable year." It continues: "No refund of tax withheld from payments to pass-through entities is allowed." FAQ 99 says the same of a PTE and adds that "any excess withholding must be allocated to the payees." For a partnership, FAQ 95 explains that "Since partnerships have no tax liabilities except for the annual tax paid by limited partnerships, the withholding can only be claimed on Form 565, Partnership Return of Income," so the entity-level use is confined to a limited partnership's annual tax.
Allocation is by ownership interest to every owner, resident or not. FAQ 96 provides that "The withholding must be allocated to all partners, members, S corporation shareholders, or beneficiaries, whether they are residents or nonresidents of California, in proportion to their ownership or beneficial interest." FAQ 98 describes the mechanics: the PTE receives a Form 592-B from the withholding agent, and "To allocate the amount withheld to its payees, it must complete Form 592-PTE, showing each payee's share of the withholding."
The upper tier's own duty, and the FTB's description of a single layer
What the text in force says
On the text in force, the upper tier is an agent for its own distributions to a nonresident individual. Regulation 18662-4(a)(1) makes withholding mandatory on California source income paid to nonresident individuals, and the definitions in Regulation 18662-2 make the person that pays a distribution the agent and the person that receives it from a pass-through entity a payee. The regulation also treats the two flows as separate items on one return. Regulation 18662-4(j) lists what Form 592-PTE contains, and two entries are "Total tax amount withheld from all payees listed by withholding agent" (item 7) and "Amounts withheld by another entity and being distributed to partners or members" (item 11). Regulation 18662-8(c)(2)(B) likewise refers to "total withholding paid by another entity and to be allocated to partners or members," to be reported on Form 592-PTE by January 31. On the literal text, then, no statute, regulation or form instruction in force lets the lower tier's withholding satisfy the upper tier's own duty, and none says it does not.
How the FTB describes the current requirement
The FTB describes the present requirement differently. Three FTB texts bear on the point.
- The FTB's Standardized Regulatory Impact Assessment Summary for the pass-through withholding project (Department of Finance form DF-131, signed August 7, 2024) describes the option of requiring an upper-tier pass-through entity with a nonresident individual owner to withhold on the entity's distributive share of California source income, "rather than the current requirement of lower tier pass-through entity withholding tax on behalf of an upper tier pass-through entity." It then states: "This alternative was rejected because placing the withholding responsibility on the upper-tier pass-through entity that is a non-California business entity with a nonresident individual owner would result in a negation of the effort by the FTB to improve administrative efficiency and reduce the number of nonfilers."
- Proposed Regulation 18662-7, in the proposed amendments that the FTB's regulatory activity page links to its thirty-day notice of December 30, 2022 (proposed, not in force), provides in subsection (d) that "An upper tier pass-through entity that is only allocating withholding paid on its behalf is not required to remit withholding under this subsection unless it has a separate withholding requirement under subsection (g)." Subsection (g)(1) provides that an upper tier with California source income "other than income that has already been withheld upon by a lower tier pass-through entity" "may have a separate withholding requirement with respect to such income." Proposed Example 2 reads: "Assuming C does not have any California source income other than its distributive share from A, C is not required to remit withholding on behalf of D or E with respect to its $50,000 distributive share of A's $100,000 of California source income by the applicable federal estimated tax due date because withholding has already been paid on that income on its behalf by A."
- The current Form 592-PTE instructions and the FTB's Pass-Through Entity Withholding page describe the upper tier that was withheld upon as a filer that is "required to file Form 592-PTE to allocate withholding paid on its behalf." The instructions' tiered example labels the lower-tier entity A and the upper-tier entities C and E. The passages of these two texts read for this article do not address the upper tier's own withholding.
None of these is adopted law that excuses the upper tier. The FTB's description is the department's reading of the present requirement, and it is the ground on which an upper tier that withheld nothing on income already withheld upon below would argue reasonable cause. The regulation does not forbid a single layer, and no source read says the FTB requires the second layer.
A counter-reading on the credit side
Section 18668(a) provides that an amount required to be deducted and paid "shall be considered the tax of that person," and Regulation 19002(b) lets owners authorize the pass-through entity to use the withholding credit "to satisfy the entity-level tax of the pass-through entity due for the taxable year." An upper tier could argue that its own required withholding is the entity-level tax against which its owners may authorize the lower tier's credit. No source read says that. The texts that sit closest to the argument point the other way. Items 7 and 11 of Regulation 18662-4(j) keep the filer's own withholding and the amounts withheld by another entity as separate totals. Form 592-PTE line 5 tells the filer to leave off line 5 the part of the lower tier's withholding that is used against the entity's own tax and to attach a note explaining how much, and Publication 1017 FAQ 95 confines that use, for a partnership, to a limited partnership's annual tax. Form 592-PTE's two lines fit the FTB's single-layer description as well as they fit the two-layer reading.
The route to a single layer that the sources support
A waiver for the upper tier as payee, or a documented decision, is the route the sources support. Publication 1017 FAQ 61 says the FTB "may authorize a waiver of withholding if the payee has California tax returns on file for the two most recent taxable years in which the payee has a filing requirement and is considered current on any outstanding tax obligations." Regulation 18662-4(l)(5) lists the bases for a Form 588 request, and the first two are returns on file for the two most current taxable years and timely estimated tax payments for the current year. FAQ 108, on a partnership's distributions to partners that are partnerships, treats a waiver as the exit. The instructions for Form 588 say the requester checks a box showing that the requester is the withholding agent, the payee or an authorized third party, so either side may ask. Whether a particular upper tier fits a basis is a question of its own filing history.
Project status
The FTB's regulatory activity page for the project, "Domestic Pass-Through Entity Withholding 18662-0 through 18662-8," last updated August 18, 2026, lists interested-parties meetings and notices through the thirty-day notice of December 30, 2022, and no later notice. The FTB's 2026 Rulemaking Calendar for the project states that staff "again received permission to start the formal rulemaking process" from the three-member Franchise Tax Board on December 6, 2023, and that the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking "is anticipated to occur in early 2026." It projects the notice for 03/26, a public hearing for 05/26, adoption for 07/26 and submission to the Office of Administrative Law for 12/26. The impact assessment describes the proposed effective date as a January 1 following the filing of the proposed regulations with the Secretary of State. Nothing read points to an effective date before 2027, and nothing read suggests that the project would reach payments made in 2025 or 2026. The proposal is not adopted, and a reader who meets "18662-7" in FTB materials should check whether the reference is to the proposal or to the repealed section.
The partner who moves
The domestic regime is distribution-based, and what matters here is the status of the payee on the day of each payment. A California resident who receives California source income is not subject to mandatory withholding: Regulation 18662-4(b)(1) provides that "If a California resident receives California source income, withholding is not required." A person who moves and becomes a nonresident is, from then, a payee on whom withholding is mandatory under Regulation 18662-4(a)(1).
Two documents usually stand between an agent and knowledge of the move.
The Form 590
The first is Form 590, on which an individual certifies California residency and agrees to notify the agent if the facts change. The regulation provides that "The certification on FTB Form 590 remains valid until the payee's status changes" (Regulation 18662-4(c)(1)), and Publication 1017 FAQ 44 adds that the certification does not need to be renewed annually. The instructions for Form 590 list the situations that the payee must report, and one is "The individual payee becomes a nonresident." They continue: "If any of these situations occur, then withholding may be required." They also contain a sentence on the agent's side: "The withholding agent is then relieved of the withholding requirements if the agent relies in good faith on a completed and signed Form 590 unless notified by the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) that the form should not be relied upon."
The California street address
The second is a California street address. Regulation 18662-4(b)(1), Example 2, has these sentences: "Withholding agents may rely on a California street address as an indication of a payee's residency status." and "If the payee has a California street address, no withholding is required." On its words, a partner who has moved no longer has a California street address. Publication 1017 FAQ 36 carries a qualifier, that an address needs no Form 590 "unless the withholding agent has reason to believe such address is merely a forwarding address." The regulation adds: "If a change of address occurs, the withholding agent must reevaluate the payee's residency status." FAQ 44 says the agent "should evaluate the need for securing a new Form 590 when any indication of a change in residency status occurs, such as a change of address, etc."
Knowledge standards differ by payee
The regulation's knowledge standards differ by payee type, and they are easy to blend. The phrase "has knowledge of, or has reason to know of" appears in Regulation 18662-4(g), the rule for suspended and forfeited corporations. The "actual knowledge" wording appears in the first example under Regulation 18662-4(b)(2), the rule for business entity payees, where the protection against penalties for failure to withhold runs "unless the withholding agent has actual knowledge that the statement in the exemption certificate, on FTB Form 590, is false." Neither is the rule for an individual. For an individual, the text consists of the validity rule in (c)(1) and the address rule above; the rule in (c)(3), under which an agent "may accept" a completed Form 590 on which an individual certifies residency but shows no California address "unless the withholding agent reasonably believes the exemption certification, on FTB Form 590, is fraudulent"; and the rule in (c)(4), under which an agent "who knowingly accepts a false exemption certificate" is subject to the liabilities and penalties of section 18668 and Regulation 18662-8. The phrase "reasonably believes" in (c)(3) is the regulation's one belief standard for an individual payee.
What the text supports on the facts of a move
The regulation's words point toward this reading: the Form 590 stopped being valid when the partner moved, whatever the agent knew, so withholding was required on later distributions, and the agent's exits are reasonable cause under section 18668(a) and reversal after the payee files and pays. Publication 1017 FAQ 145 describes reasonable cause as existing "where the failure to comply occurs despite the exercise of ordinary business care and prudence." The good-faith sentence in the Form 590 instructions is the agent's argument against that reading. It is not the regulation's rule. No source read states what happens to distributions paid between an unreported move and the agent's discovery of it, and this article states no safe harbor for that interval. An agent with no Form 590 that relied only on an address, and that received a change of address (a mailing-address update on a K-1, a wire to an out-of-state account), has the weaker position, because the duty to reevaluate was triggered.
After the agent learns of the move, the Form 590 is no longer a basis for relief. Later distributions are withholdable unless a waiver, a reduced-withholding approval or a Form 590-P exemption is in hand.
What the agent owes for distributions it missed
The measure
Section 18668(a) fixes the statutory measure. Its second sentence makes an amount required to be deducted and paid "the tax of that person," and it continues: "Unless it is shown that the failure is due to reasonable cause, any person who fails to withhold from any payments any amount required to be withheld under this article or who fails to transmit the withheld amounts to the Franchise Tax Board on or before the due date required by regulations is liable for the amount actually withheld, or the amount of taxes due from the taxpayer to whom the payments are made, whichever is greater, but not in excess of the amount required to be withheld." Publication 1017 FAQ 136 states the same measure.
The regulation restates it with no taxes-due alternative: section 18668(a) "provides that a withholding agent is liable for the amount that was required to be withheld, and applicable penalties and interest, unless it is shown that the failure was due to reasonable cause" (Regulation 18662-8(d)(2)(C)). The restatement suggests that the department will assess the required amount and leave any taxes-due argument to the agent. The practical ceiling is 7 percent of each missed distribution.
Interest and information return penalties
Interest on an amount not paid by its due date is assessed at the rate under section 19521, computed from the due date to the date paid (section 18668(b)), and section 19521 provides that the amount "shall be compounded daily." The regulation calls the interest "not a penalty, but compensation for the use of the funds from the date the withheld funds were due to the date remitted" (Regulation 18662-8(d)(1)). The FTB's rate table shows 8 percent for January 1 through June 30, 2025, and 7 percent for each period from July 1, 2025 through December 31, 2026.
Penalties on the information returns are separate. Section 19183 sets penalties for incorrect information returns and payee statements by reference to the federal penalties, and Regulation 18662-8(d)(2)(A) states that Form 592-B is a payee statement. Publication 1017 states the amount as up to $130 per form for forms filed on or after January 1, 2025, and up to $340 per form for forms filed on or after January 1, 2026, and FAQ 144 says the penalties "may be withdrawn" if the agent shows that the failure to withhold was due to reasonable cause. Section 19183(d)(1) applies the federal waiver, definition and special rules of Internal Revenue Code section 6724 "except as otherwise provided."
Two exits
Two exits are in the sources. The first is reasonable cause under section 18668(a). The second is reversal, in the paragraph that follows Regulation 18662-8(d)(2)(C). When the agent pays the liability for required withholding and the information return penalties and interest, and the nonresident payee later files a return and pays the tax, the FTB "may reverse the liability for required withholding upon written request by the withholding agent." The regulation adds that the agent "remains liable for any information return penalties and interest."
One question stays open. No source read says whether tax already covered by a credit that the lower tier's withholding generated for the same partner reduces the "taxes due" measure of section 18668(a). The worked example below shows why that matters.
The partner's side
A partner's late payment penalty is not excused by the partnership's failure to withhold. In the Appeal of Sawdye and Morisano (Office of Tax Appeals Case No. 230613641, nonprecedential, 2024-OTA-569), the panel sustained the FTB's denial of a refund claim for a late payment penalty. The opinion records that one appellant's new partnership "(unbeknownst to appellants) failed to do so," in a discussion of the partnership's withholding for its nonresident partners, and the panel found that the appellants had not established "what efforts, if any, they made to assess whether appellant-wife's new partnership would withhold California taxes for its California nonresident partners to fully cover the partners' California sourced income." The case supports a narrow point: a partner's duty to file and pay for the year of the move does not depend on whether the partnership withheld.
Waiver timing and the distribution already made
The mechanism
The regulation requires that "Requests for waivers, on FTB Form 588, must be submitted before the payment is made so the Franchise Tax Board can issue a determination notice authorizing a waiver before the withholding is required" (Regulation 18662-4(e)(1)). The instructions for Form 588 add the operating numbers.
- "Submit a request for a waiver at least 21 business days before making a payment to allow the FTB time to process the request."
- "Withholding waivers are effective for a maximum term of 24 months and will expire on December 31 of the succeeding calendar year granted."
- For a newly admitted partner (reason code D), "the resulting waiver will expire at the end of the succeeding calendar year from the date the payee was newly admitted."
- "A withholding agent must have received the notice authorizing a waiver of withholding before eliminating withholding on payments made to nonresidents."
Publication 1017 gives the FTB's side. FAQ 65 says the FTB generally responds "within 21 working days." FAQ 66 says a waiver need not be requested for each payment, because "Waivers are generally granted for fixed periods with a maximum expiration date of two years." The segments of the Form 588 instructions read for this article do not state how business days are counted, and the FTB's "working days" in FAQ 65 is not defined in the passages read either.
What Publication 1017 says when withholding has already occurred
FAQ 70 completes the mechanism. It asks what a withholding agent should do if it withheld 7 percent but has not remitted the amount to the FTB and a waiver has been authorized, and the answer is: "The withholding agent must return any amounts withheld." Read together, the instructions and FAQ 70 describe the following sequence.
- Withhold until the determination notice is in hand.
- Once a waiver is authorized, return any amount withheld and not yet remitted.
- Where the notice arrives after a distribution but before the remittance date for its period, the agent has withheld and has not yet remitted, so it returns the amount and the payee is left whole.
The regulation, the Form 588 instructions and Publication 1017 do not say that a waiver reaches back. The only timing language in the regulation is "before the payment is made." The sources read give no route by which a waiver reaches a payment on which nothing was withheld and whose remittance date has passed. That narrow case is the one in which the sources give the agent no help, and it is narrower than a general statement that a late waiver is worthless: where the agent withheld and has not remitted, FAQ 70 returns the money. A separate article in this library, on disregarded-entity payees, covers the basic timing of a waiver on facts in which nothing was withheld and the remittance date had passed.
A Form 588 needs a basis
A waiver request must state a basis. The bases in Regulation 18662-4(l)(5) include returns on file for the two most current taxable years (A), timely estimated tax payments for the current year (B), a newly admitted partner (D), and "Other" (E), for which the request must "attach a specific reason and include substantiation that would justify a waiver". A partner who moves will often still have a California filing history, which is what reason (A) turns on. A partner with neither a filing history nor estimated payments does not qualify on that ground.
Form 589 and Form 590-P are different instruments
Form 589 asks the FTB to reduce, not stop, withholding. Its worksheet limits the total amount of expenses to 50 percent of line 1 ("may not exceed 50% of line 1"), and the form states that the amount "must be verified and approved by the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) prior to the payee receiving payment for services." Publication 1017 FAQ 56 gives at least 10 business days for an online filing and at least 21 business days by mail or fax, and FAQ 60 states the consequence of late approval: the agent withholds 7 percent of the gross payment if it did not receive the approval before the payment. The form and the FAQs are framed around payment for services, and the sources read do not say how a reduction request applies to a distribution of partnership income.
Form 590-P is a second exit that does not wait on a waiver. For a distribution of prior-year California source income, FAQ 15 lists as an exception that "The partner has certified that the income was previously reported on the partner's California tax return." FAQ 113 says no withholding is required on a distribution of prior-year California source income if the partner provides a signed Form 590-P, "Nonresident Withholding Exemption Certificate for Previously Reported Income." Under the terms of the form, an agent that relies on it in good faith is relieved of the withholding requirements for the partner's share of that distribution, the form may be completed for each distribution of prior-year income, the agent keeps it for at least five years, and the agent does not send it to the FTB. FAQ 31 limits withholding on prior-year distributions to income "not previously reported." A partner who certifies California residency on Form 590 needs no waiver, and a nonresident cannot truthfully use that route.
The coordination failure
When a lower tier's preparer withholds at the lower tier, the lower tier's Forms 592-Q and 592-PTE and its Form 592-B name the upper tier as payee. That filing covers the lower tier's own distribution only. If the upper tier's team concludes that California withholding has been paid and does nothing, up to three things fail at once, as listed below.
- The upper tier does not withhold on its own distributions. On the literal text that is an agent failure under section 18668(a), and the FTB's single-layer description is the ground on which a reasonable cause answer would rest.
- The upper tier does not file its own Form 592-PTE, so the credit received from below is never allocated. FAQ 99 states that refunds of withholding credits are not allowed for pass-through entities and that any excess "must be allocated to the payees," so credit that no owner can claim is stranded.
- The partners' Forms 592-B are missing or name the wrong party, which is the mismatch that a separate article in this library on withholding credits and K-1 mismatches covers.
A partner's Form 592-B identifies the agent, the payee, the type of income (box D lists distributions to domestic nonresident partners and members) and the amount withheld (Part IV, line 2), and the partner attaches a copy to the California return. The sources read do not say whether the upper tier issues one aggregated Form 592-B for its own withholding and the credit allocated from below, or separate statements. Regulation 18662-8(c)(2)(E) speaks of a statement "aggregating all withholding for the tax year," while Form 592-B says "Do not use Form 592-B to allocate or distribute withholding to each payee, use Form 592, Form 592-PTE, or Form 592-F."
Timing makes the failure worse. FAQ 97 says a pass-through entity that was withheld upon should contact the withholding agent and ask to receive the withholding information early so that it can file by the due date, should file as soon as it gets the information if it still does not receive it in time, and should attach a letter to Form 592 stating the reason for filing late and documenting its attempts to get the information.
The year with no distributions
Withholding attaches to a payment or distribution (Publication 1017 FAQ 31 speaks of withholding "on distributions"). Because withholding is measured by distributions, a partnership that allocates income and distributes nothing owes no domestic withholding for the year, and there is no withholding credit to pass up from one partnership tier to the next. A later distribution of that income is subject to withholding unless the partner has certified on Form 590-P that the income was previously reported on a California return, or holds a waiver or a Form 589 approval. Regulation 19002(c) lets the partnership's owners authorize taxes withheld on payments made after the close of the taxable year to be applied to either the previous or the following year, and Regulation 19002(d)(3) credits withholding payments "on the date such payments are remitted to the Franchise Tax Board." The pending FTB distributive-share project would change that measure, but it is not adopted and nothing read suggests that it reaches payments made in 2025 or 2026.
What remains open
The following points are not answered by any source found. Each point is also noted in the section where it arises.
- Whether a lower tier's withholding reduces or satisfies the upper tier's own duty. The literal text runs both layers, and the FTB's published description runs one.
- What an agent owes for distributions paid between an unreported move and the agent's discovery of it. No source found states a safe harbor, and the text on point is reasonable cause under section 18668(a), the good-faith sentence in the Form 590 instructions and the regulation's statement that a certification "remains valid until the payee's status changes."
- Whether a credit allocated from a lower tier enters the "taxes due from the taxpayer" measure of section 18668(a).
- Whether payments made while a partner was a resident count toward the $1,500 amount after a move. The sources read speak per payee per calendar year and do not address a change of status.
- Whether the upper tier issues one aggregated Form 592-B for its own withholding and the credit allocated from below, or separate statements.
- Whether any FTB practice treats a Form 588 as retroactive in any case. The published text on timing is "before the payment is made," and the one published statement on the reverse side is FAQ 70.
- Whether "business days" in the Form 588 instructions excludes state holidays. Government Code section 6700(a)(6) lists the third Monday in February as a state holiday, and no FTB source read states the count.
- Whether a notice of proposed rulemaking for Regulation 18662-7 has issued since the FTB's regulatory activity page was last updated on August 18, 2026.
- How the FTB computes the daily factor for interest compounded daily. The interest in the worked example uses the annual rate divided by 365 and is an approximation.
Worked example
The partnerships and partners in this example are invented.
Facts. Lower Partnership owns an apartment building in a mid-size California city, and all of its income is California source rent. Upper Partnership, a Delaware limited partnership with no California office and no Secretary of State registration, owns the whole of Lower Partnership's equity. Upper Partnership holds no securities and is not an investment partnership under Revenue and Taxation Code section 17955. It has three equal partners: Partner 1 (Arizona), Partner 2 (Texas) and Partner 3. Partner 3 was a California resident, signed a Form 590 certifying residency in 2023, moved to Nevada on March 15, 2025, and told Upper Partnership on January 21, 2026. Lower Partnership has no waiver for Upper Partnership. Each distribution in 2025 is a current-year distribution of California source rental income. There is no fourth-quarter distribution. Upper Partnership holds a cash reserve of at least $25,200 from earlier years. Lower Partnership's withholding leaves Upper Partnership $8,400 short of the $120,000 it distributes in each round, and the reserve funds the difference.
The 2025 distributions run as follows. In each round Lower Partnership distributes $120,000 to Upper Partnership and withholds 7 percent, $8,400, so Upper Partnership receives $111,600 and distributes $120,000 to its partners, $40,000 to each. The reserve funds the $8,400 shortfall.
- March 10: remittance of Lower Partnership's withholding due April 15, 2025.
- June 10: remittance due September 15, 2025.
- September 10: remittance due January 15, 2026.
- December: no distribution.
- Year: $360,000 distributed by Lower Partnership, $25,200 withheld, $334,800 received by Upper Partnership, $360,000 distributed to the partners, $25,200 drawn from the reserve.
Step 1, the lower tier as agent. Seven percent of $120,000 is $8,400 per distribution and $25,200 for the year, remitted with Form 592-Q for the periods shown. Lower Partnership reports the payee on Form 592-PTE and gives Upper Partnership a Form 592-B for $25,200.
Step 2, the upper tier credit. Upper Partnership files its own Form 592-PTE and allocates the $25,200 equally, $8,400 to each partner. How each partner receives the statement of that credit is one of the open points listed above.
Step 3, the upper tier as agent for its own distributions, on the literal text of the regulation. This step shows the result if the upper tier's own duty runs in addition to the lower tier's. The FTB's description of the current requirement answers that result as a reasonable cause ground and not as a rule.
- Partner 1: 7 percent of $40,000 is $2,800 per distribution, $8,400 for three.
- Partner 2: the same, $8,400.
- Partner 3: the March 10 distribution was paid while Partner 3 was a resident with a Form 590 on file, five days before the move on March 15, so no withholding applies. The June 10 and September 10 distributions were paid after the move, $2,800 each. The $5,600 is the section 18668(a) ceiling, the amount that would have been required had the status been known.
- Total on the literal text for Upper Partnership for 2025: $8,400 plus $8,400 plus $5,600, or $22,400.
Step 4, the missed amounts. Upper Partnership withheld for Partners 1 and 2 ($16,800) and relied on the Form 590 for Partner 3, withholding nothing on June 10 and September 10. The remittance for the June 10 distribution fell due September 15, 2025, and for the September 10 distribution, January 15, 2026. The ceiling is $2,800 for each, $5,600. The regulation says that the Form 590 certification "remains valid until the payee's status changes," and Partner 3's status changed on March 15, 2025. The regulation's words therefore point toward a reading under which withholding was required on both distributions whatever Upper Partnership knew, with reasonable cause and reversal as the exits. Upper Partnership's argument is the good-faith sentence in the Form 590 instructions: with a signed Form 590 on file, no address change and no notice, it relied in good faith. That is an argument against the reading of the regulation, and it is not a rule. If Upper Partnership had received an address change in June 2025 and had not reevaluated, the argument is weaker and the $5,600 ceiling is in play, with reasonable cause as the remaining ground.
Step 5, interest if the ceiling applies. Upper Partnership is assumed to remit the $5,600 on Friday, February 27, 2026. Interest at 7 percent, compounded daily on a 365-day basis, is an approximation of the FTB's computation.
- $2,800 from September 15, 2025 to February 27, 2026 (165 days): $2,800 times ((1 + 0.07/365) to the 165th power minus 1), or $90.01.
- $2,800 from January 15, 2026 to February 27, 2026 (43 days): the same formula for 43 days, or $23.18.
- Interest total: $113.19. Simple interest would be $88.60 and $23.09.
Information return penalties for corrected Forms 592-PTE and 592-B are in addition and are not computed here.
Step 6, reversal. Partner 3 files a 2025 California nonresident return by April 15, 2026 and pays any balance. Upper Partnership, having paid the required withholding and the penalties and interest, asks the FTB in writing to reverse the liability for required withholding. The information return penalties and interest remain. Partner 3's own late payment penalty, if any, is not excused by the partnership's failure to withhold. One point stays open. Partner 3 holds $8,400 of credit through Upper Partnership's allocation of Lower Partnership's withholding, which exceeds 7 percent of Partner 3's $80,000 of post-move distributions ($5,600). If that credit counts toward the "taxes due" measure of section 18668(a), the measure could fall below the ceiling. The regulation restates the measure without that alternative.
Step 7, the waiver filed in February 2026. Upper Partnership files Form 588 as the withholding agent for Partner 3 on Tuesday, February 3, 2026, on reason (A), returns on file for the two most current years with a filing requirement (an invented fact). Twenty-one business days after February 3 is Thursday, March 5, 2026, with Monday, February 16, 2026 excluded as a state holiday (Government Code section 6700(a)(6), the third Monday in February), and it is March 4 if no holiday is counted. The example needs only the notice date. The FTB's determination notice is assumed to be dated Thursday, March 12, 2026 and to state an expiration of December 31, 2027. The instructions' "December 31 of the succeeding calendar year" gives 2027 for a waiver granted in 2026, and the notice states the date. The results follow.
- A $40,000 distribution to Partner 3 on Friday, February 20, 2026 falls before the notice, so Upper Partnership withholds $2,800, because the instructions require withholding until the notice is in hand. The remittance for the January 1 to March 31 period is not due until Wednesday, April 15, 2026 (the federal estimated tax date), and the notice arrives before then. Under Publication 1017 FAQ 70, Upper Partnership returns the $2,800 to Partner 3 and does not remit it.
- Distributions after March 12, 2026 and through the stated expiration need no withholding for Partner 3.
- The June 10 and September 10, 2025 distributions are unaffected. Nothing was withheld on them and their remittance dates (September 15, 2025 and January 15, 2026) passed before the request, so the waiver does not reach them on the sources read.
- A 2026 distribution of 2025 income made after Partner 3 files the 2025 return could be exempted on a Form 590-P without waiting for the waiver.
What the example shows and leaves out. It shows the two layers of agency on the literal text, the credit passing down, the dates for the 2025 remittance periods, the pre-move and post-move distinction and the effect of the waiver's timing. It leaves out Partner 3's own California liability on the part-year allocation, any withholding on Partners 1 and 2 beyond the amounts shown, the $1,500 optional slice and Upper Partnership's other expenses. It treats the $1,500 as spent for Partner 3 by the March 10 payment. If the upper tier had withheld nothing for anyone, on the assumption that the lower tier's withholding covered it, the section 18668(a) ceiling for 2025 on the literal text would be the whole $22,400, before reasonable cause, with $25,200 of credit stranded unless Form 592-PTE is filed. The FTB's description of the current requirement is the ground for that reasonable cause argument, and it is not a ruling that the argument succeeds.
If Upper Partnership distributes only what it receives. Suppose that Upper Partnership has no reserve and distributes only the $111,600 it receives in each round, $37,200 to each partner. The figures then become $2,604 per distribution, $7,812 each for Partners 1 and 2, $5,208 for Partner 3's two post-move distributions and $20,832 in total. Interest on $2,604 for 165 and 43 days is $83.71 and $21.56, or $105.27. Partner 3's credit of $8,400 is then set against $5,208.
Practice notes
Name one person responsible for the withholding agent role at each partnership tier. Assign the lower tier's Forms 592-Q and 592-PTE to the lower tier's preparer, and assign the upper tier's own withholding decision and its own Form 592-PTE to someone on the upper tier. Put the allocation of the withholding credit received from the lower tier on the upper tier's January calendar, ask the lower tier for its withholding information early, and attach a letter if the filing is late, as Publication 1017 FAQ 97 describes.
Decide at the lower tier whether the upper tier takes a waiver as payee or accepts withholding and allocates it, and document whether the upper tier also withholds on its own distributions. The text in force supports a second layer, and the FTB describes one layer as the current requirement. An undocumented choice leaves the upper tier to argue reasonable cause after the fact.
Refresh each individual partner's residency confirmation annually and whenever a K-1 mailing address, a wire instruction or a tax notice changes. The Form 590 itself needs no annual renewal, but the regulation ends its validity when the payee's status changes, and the duty to reevaluate follows the address.
File Form 588 for every nonresident partner that has a basis for one, as the withholding agent if the partnership prefers, at least 21 business days before the first payment it is meant to cover. Calendar the stated expiration (December 31 of the succeeding calendar year at the longest) and the renewal request before the next cycle's first distribution. A waiver needs a stated basis and is not available as a blanket. Withhold until the determination notice is in hand, and return any amount withheld and not yet remitted once the waiver is authorized.
When the partnership learns of a move, stop relying on the Form 590, withhold on the next distribution unless a determination notice or a Form 590-P exemption is in hand, remit prior amounts with interest, document the facts that support reasonable cause, and ask for reversal once the partner has filed and paid. Remind the partner to file and pay for the year of the move on time, because the partnership's failure to withhold does not excuse the partner's late payment penalty.
In a year with no distributions, plan the first distribution against the lead times for a waiver, a Form 589 approval and a Form 590-P. The measure is distribution-based, so a year without distributions has no domestic withholding, and a later distribution of that income is caught unless the partner certifies on Form 590-P that the income was previously reported on a California return.
G&G State Tax Group advises partnerships and their partners on California nonresident withholding, tiered-entity filings, waiver and exemption requests, and reasonable cause and reversal requests, alongside its state and local tax practice.
This article states the law as of November 11, 2026
Statutes, rates, thresholds, and agency practice change, and a different set of facts can change the answer. Before acting on anything discussed above, contact G&G State Tax Group, or another state and local tax adviser, to confirm what has changed since this was written and how the rules apply to a specific situation.
This publication is informational in nature and is not, and should not be considered, legal, accounting, tax, or other professional advice for any person or situation. Correct application of tax law depends heavily on the facts and circumstances in each case, and G&G State Tax Group, LLC assumes no liability in connection with the use of this information, and is not obligated to inform any reader of changes in the law or other factors that could affect the information contained herein.
