CaliforniaIncome and franchise tax
Is a California S corporation's gain on a minority LLC interest nonbusiness income, and does that position affect the federal net investment income tax exception?
The short answer
A California S corporation's gain on selling a minority LLC interest is nonbusiness only if the interest was not integral to the corporation's operations. LLC means limited liability company, here one taxed as a partnership. No ruling or decision found applies the integral-to-operations test to a minority LLC interest held as an investment. The Franchise Tax Board (FTB) has ruled only on whether minority stock gain is business income, looking to actual operational ties between buyer and issuer. The Office of Tax Appeals (OTA) found the seller and the LLC unitary in both reported LLC cases, through shared individuals. Nonbusiness gain is allocated by the ratio of the LLC's California tangible property to its tangible property everywhere (Revenue and Taxation Code section 25125(d)), not to the seller's commercial domicile, and the sale proceeds stay out of the corporation's sales factor. The federal exception to the net investment income tax for gain on an active business interest (Internal Revenue Code section 1411(c)(4)) turns on each shareholder's participation in the LLC's business, so the California nonbusiness classification does not decide it. A conflict arises only where the facts supporting the federal passive position are the facts denied for the California nonbusiness position.
Working through this on a live matter? Contact the firm
Two separate questions, not one trade
A California S corporation that sells a minority interest in an LLC faces two questions that are often run together. The first is a California question about the corporation: whether the gain is business income, apportioned by the corporation's sales factor, or nonbusiness income, allocated by a separate statute, and how that classification reaches each shareholder. The second is a federal question about each shareholder: whether the shareholder's share of the gain is net investment income subject to the 3.8 percent net investment income tax, or falls within the exception for gain on an interest in an active business.
Neither body of law refers to the other. California defines nonbusiness income as "all income other than business income" (Revenue and Taxation Code section 25120(d)), and the definition looks at the seller's operations. The federal passive activity rules look at one person's involvement: a passive activity is any activity "which involves the conduct of any trade or business" and "in which the taxpayer does not materially participate" (Internal Revenue Code section 469(c)(1)). A premise sometimes carried over from one body of law to the other, that nonbusiness and passive are two names for the same finding, has no support in either. The first inquiry asks about the corporation's relationship to the LLC, and the second asks about an individual shareholder's work in the LLC, so a fact that answers one does not answer the other.
This article takes the case of an S corporation that holds a minority interest in an LLC that is taxed as a partnership and that runs a different business, bought the interest as an investment, and sells all of it. The S corporation is commercially domiciled in California, which means that "the principal place from which the trade or business of the taxpayer is directed or managed" is in this state (Revenue and Taxation Code section 25120(b)). It states what the California tests ask and what no source answers, how the classification changes the corporation's tax and each shareholder's, what the sales factor requires, how the federal exception works, where the state and federal positions press on each other, and a worked example with invented figures.
Business or nonbusiness: what the California tests ask
The statutory definition
Revenue and Taxation Code section 25120(a) defines "business income" as income "arising from transactions and activity in the regular course of the taxpayer's trade or business" and provides that it "includes income from tangible and intangible property if the acquisition, management, and disposition of the property constitute integral parts of the taxpayer's regular trade or business operations." Section 25120(d) defines nonbusiness income as everything else. The first route is the transactional test and the second is the functional test. A one-time sale of an investment rarely meets the transactional test unless the seller regularly buys and sells interests of that kind, so the contest is usually the functional test. California regulations are cited here as Regulation followed by the section number; they are in title 18 of the California Code of Regulations.
What the courts have said
In Hoechst Celanese Corp. v. Franchise Tax Board (2001) 25 Cal.4th 508, the California Supreme Court held "that a separate functional test exists." It stated the test this way: income is business income under the functional test "if the taxpayer's acquisition, control and use of the property contribute materially to the taxpayer's production of business income." The opinion adds that the property then "becomes interwoven into and inseparable from the taxpayer's business operations," and that "the extraordinary nature or infrequency of the income-producing transaction is irrelevant." The opinion also states that only income from assets that "serve an operational rather than an investment function" is apportionable to a state, and that a business purpose alone is not enough.
In Jim Beam Brands Co. v. Franchise Tax Board (2005) 133 Cal.App.4th 514 (No. A107209, filed October 17, 2005), the Court of Appeal held that a parent's gain on the stock of a subsidiary was business income within section 25120(a). The court wrote that the Hoechst analysis does "not focus on the use of the proceeds of the disposition or on the reasons behind the sale." That statement concerns the sale. It does not say that the reason the owner acquired the interest, such as appreciation, is irrelevant, and the FTB's own ruling (below) says an owner's intent is relevant but not controlling.
The Franchise Tax Board's published positions
The FTB's only published ruling on a minority stake is Legal Ruling 2012-01, which concerns corporate stock. It examines three purchases of minority stock. A stake of about 20 percent bought only as a step toward a takeover that failed, with no operating relationship before or after, produced nonbusiness income. A minority stake bought to obtain technology information and followed by exclusive agreements produced business income, and so did a stake of about 20 percent in the issuer of products the buyer already distributed. The ruling's test is not a percentage. It says the buyer's intent may support a finding that an operational relationship did or did not exist, but "it is the actual operational ties and the significance of such ties that are most important," and it adds that the intention of the buyers in the cases it describes "by itself is not controlling." The ruling sets no ownership threshold, and the terms partnership and limited liability company do not appear in it.
The FTB's audit manual is the only FTB pronouncement found that reaches a partnership interest. Its chapter 4000, section 4040, states that whether a gain on selling a partnership interest is business or nonbusiness "is subject to the transactional and functional tests," and illustrates the point with Appeal of Centennial Equities Corporation (State Board of Equalization, 84-SBE-086, June 27, 1984): a real estate developer and its unitary subsidiaries held interests in 39 partnerships that were also in real estate development and were part of the taxpayer's unitary business, and the State Board of Equalization concluded that the gains on selling those interests were business income. The manual is a staff guide, not a regulation, and its section on stock describes a moment of judgment that the FTB treats as the time of the decision to sell.
The two reported decisions on LLC interests
Two Office of Tax Appeals opinions apply the functional test to a sale of an LLC interest, and both found that the seller and the LLC were unitary.
In Appeal of L. Smith, 2023-OTA-069P (precedential, issued December 7, 2022), a holding company sold "its entire 50.50 percent (direct) membership interest" in an LLC to an unrelated party. The opinion concluded that the two were unitary and the gain was apportionable business income, and it identified the individual who ran both entities day to day as "the unitary bond that held and kept those two entities together." The opinion then applied Regulation 17951-4(d) to source the gain.
In Appeals of Alvaco Trading Company, Inc., 2024-OTA-142 (nonprecedential, issued January 23, 2024), a corporation that had contributed its operating assets to an LLC for a 55 percent membership interest sold most of it and kept a stake of 13.46 percent. The corporation reported the gain as nonbusiness income and allocated it under section 25125(d). The opinion's findings record that the corporation nonetheless filed as if unitary with the LLC and included 55 percent of the LLC's sales, payroll and property factors. The corporation had the right to designate three managers while it held a majority of the units, held veto power through a supermajority requirement, and shared its chief executive and chief operating officers with the LLC. The panel found the two unitary and held that the gain "generated business income under the functional test."
In both opinions the unitary bond was individuals the owner and the LLC shared, and in both the owner held a majority of the LLC. Neither involved a minority interest bought as an investment by an owner with no shared personnel.
What no source answers
No California ruling, regulation or decision found applies the business or nonbusiness test to a minority, uncontrolled LLC interest held as an investment. The article therefore states the standard and the facts that move it, not an outcome.
A seller should expect the FTB to argue that lack of control is not a safe harbor, and the sources lean that way. The FTB's regulation on a taxpayer's share of a partnership's business tests unity "disregarding ownership requirements" (Regulation 25137-1(a)). In Smith, the OTA quoted an earlier State Board of Equalization decision, Appeal of Willamette Industries, Inc., for the points that "that combination is proper even though that ownership interest is less than a majority interest" and that "unitary combination does not require that a partner have control of the partnership that is combined." Alvaco likewise refers to "the traditional unitary tests disregarding ownership requirements." Ownership percentage is disregarded in both directions: a large stake does not make an LLC unitary with its owner, and a small one does not prevent it. What the cases and the ruling make decisive is the operational tie and its significance.
A separate regulation draws a line at 20 percent for the related question of how a nonresident partner or shareholder sources a distributive share. Regulation 17951-4(d)(5) provides that "the business activity of a partnership will not ordinarily be considered part of a unitary business with another business activity of one or more of its partners," and subdivision (d)(6) withdraws that presumption for a partner that owns, directly or indirectly, "a 20 percent or more capital or profits interest." Subdivision (j) refers to a partner, member or shareholder that "owns directly or indirectly a 20 percent or more capital or profits interest in a partnership, limited liability company or S corporation," so the line reaches LLC members. The example's 30 percent interest is above the line, so the presumption would not help the seller even if it reached the question here. Below the line the presumption speaks to a partner's distributive share, and no source found applies it to the character of a gain on selling the interest.
Facts that the sources treat as operational ties or as pointing to unity include a preexisting or continuing business relationship such as distribution or technology dealings (Legal Ruling 2012-01), shared officers and shared managers, and management rights such as board designation and vetoes (Alvaco). A seller with none of these ties that bought the interest for appreciation is closest to the ruling's first situation, where stock produced nonbusiness income, but the ruling does not reach an LLC interest and no source says where the line falls for one.
What the classification does to the S corporation
Nonbusiness gain: allocated by the LLC's tangible property
For a sale of an interest in an LLC taxed as a partnership, nonbusiness gain is not allocated to the seller's commercial domicile. Revenue and Taxation Code section 25125(c) allocates capital gains and losses from sales of intangible personal property to California "if the taxpayer's commercial domicile is in this state," but excludes the sale of a partnership interest, using the words "in the case of the sale of a partnership interest." Subdivision (d) supplies the rule for that exception: gain or loss on the sale of a partnership interest "is allocable to this state in the ratio of the original cost of partnership tangible property in the state to the original cost of partnership tangible property everywhere, determined at the time of the sale." The FTB's audit manual repeats the rule in its chapter 4000, section 4040. A statement that nonbusiness gain on an LLC interest goes to the seller's commercial domicile describes the law before the Legislature added subdivision (d), operative for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 1989. Before then, the State Board of Equalization treated a partnership interest as intangible property allocable to commercial domicile. In Appeal of Holiday Inns, Inc. (86-SBE-074, No. 81A-1438-MW, April 9, 1986), it reversed the FTB's allocation to California of a Tennessee-domiciled partner's gain, reasoning that "a partnership interest is clearly not tangible personal property" and so "must be intangible personal property."
Three features of subdivision (d) matter in practice. The ratio uses original cost, not the property factor that a return reports (an average for a taxable year), and it is measured at the time of the sale. If more than 50 percent of the value of the partnership's assets consists of intangibles, the gain is instead allocated "in accordance with the sales factor of the partnership for its first full tax period immediately preceding the tax period of the partnership during which the partnership interest was sold." And the rule applies to an LLC taxed as a partnership. If the LLC has elected to be taxed as a corporation, its interests are stock, subdivision (c) applies, and a corporation commercially domiciled in California allocates the whole nonbusiness gain to California. In that case the nonbusiness finding costs the seller more than the business finding would, because an apportioned gain is reduced by the sales factor and an allocated one is not. The sale of subsidiary stock is covered in a separate article in this library on apportioning the gain when a parent sells a subsidiary.
No authority found restricts the section 25125(d) allocation when it places only a small share of a gain in California, and no decision found tests the allocation against a constitutional challenge by a seller domiciled in California. A related article in this library on corporate partners covers the question for a seller that is not domiciled here.
Business gain: apportioned by the sales factor
If the gain is business income, it is apportioned. For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2013, "all business income of an apportioning trade or business" other than one described in section 25128(b) "shall be apportioned to this state by multiplying the business income by the sales factor" (Revenue and Taxation Code section 25128.7). The sales factor then depends on how the sale proceeds are treated, which is the subject of a later section.
The tax rate on each branch
An S corporation pays an entity-level tax at 1.5 percent of the net income apportioned or allocated to California (Revenue and Taxation Code section 23802(b)(1)), against 8.84 percent for a C corporation (section 23151(f)(2)). The entity-level tax is therefore small relative to the personal tax on the gain, which falls on the shareholders.
What the classification does to a resident and to a nonresident shareholder
The Court of Appeal described the two branches in The 2009 Metropoulos Family Trust v. Franchise Tax Board (2022) 79 Cal.App.5th 245 (No. D078790, filed May 27, 2022): income of an S corporation "is thus characterized at the S corporation level as either business or nonbusiness income; the business income is apportioned under the Uniform Act, and the nonbusiness income is sourced under sections 17951 through 17953 and 17955." The Uniform Act is the Uniform Division of Income for Tax Purposes Act. The court held that the FTB's Regulation 17951-4, which is specific to a nonresident S corporation shareholder's distributive share, is "to be accorded the same dignity" as a statute and does not give way to section 17952.
A resident shareholder
A resident is taxed on all income (Revenue and Taxation Code section 17041(a)). The corporation's classification of the gain therefore changes only the 1.5 percent entity-level tax on the share of the gain attributed to California. The resident's personal tax on the gain is the same either way. The classification can affect one more item, the credit for tax paid to another state, discussed below.
A nonresident shareholder, business branch
If the gain is business income of a unitary S corporation, the corporation apportions it, and each nonresident shareholder's share of the California-apportioned amount is California-source income (Regulation 17951-4(d) and (f), applied in Metropoulos). The shareholder's California tax is then computed by taking the rate that would apply to the shareholder's entire income as if a resident, and applying it to the California-source amount (Revenue and Taxation Code section 17041(b)(2)).
A nonresident shareholder, nonbusiness branch
If the gain is nonbusiness income, Regulation 17951-4(d)(4) provides that the source of a partner's distributive share of items that are not business income "shall be determined in accordance with the sourcing rules of Sections 17951 through 17955, Revenue and Taxation Code, and the regulations thereunder, as if the income producing activity were undertaken by the partner in its individual capacity." Subdivision (f) applies the same approach to a shareholder of an S corporation that carries on a unitary business within and outside California, and provides that the source of the S corporation's items of nonbusiness income for the entity-level tax "shall have no relevance" in sourcing the same items for a nonresident shareholder. The corporation's allocation under section 25125(d) therefore does not decide the shareholder's California source.
For a nonresident individual, an LLC interest is intangible personal property, and section 17952 provides that income of nonresidents from intangible personal property "is not income from sources within this state unless the property has acquired a business situs in this state." On those rules, a nonresident's share of a nonbusiness gain on the LLC interest is not California-source income unless the interest had a California business situs. The classification can thus remove the gain from a nonresident shareholder's California return entirely.
The FTB can be expected to argue business situs. Regulation 17952(c) provides that intangible property has a business situs in California if it is "employed as capital in this State" or "the possession and control of the property has been localized in connection with a business, trade or profession in this State so that its substantial use and value attach to and become an asset of the business, trade or profession in this State," and that the entire income from it, including gain from its sale, is then California-source. The reply of a seller whose interest was a passive investment is that it was not employed as capital in California, not pledged, and not used as working capital or security for the California business. No published rule addresses a passive investee interest held by a California-based S corporation, or how much of the gain would be California-source if a situs existed. A separate article in this library covers the business situs rule for a nonresident's sale of a partnership interest, and another covers a nonresident shareholder's share of an S corporation's gain on selling its business.
The credit for another state's tax
A resident shareholder may be taxed by the state where the LLC operates. Revenue and Taxation Code section 18001(a)(1) allows the credit "only for taxes paid to the other state" on "income derived from sources within that state," and subdivision (c) provides that this phrase "shall be determined by applying the nonresident sourcing rules for determining income from sources within this state, as specified in Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 17951), and the regulations thereunder." Under those rules, a resident's gain on an intangible is not sourced to the state where the LLC's assets sit unless the interest had a business situs there. On that reading, in the nonbusiness branch the FTB may deny a resident shareholder a credit for another state's tax on the gain even though that state taxes it. The credit is outside this article and is not analyzed here, and nothing above says that the credit is allowed or denied in any case.
The sales factor and the consistency a return must show
Nonbusiness receipts stay out of the factor
For the factor, "sales" means all gross receipts of the taxpayer not allocated under Sections 25123 to 25127, inclusive, and "gross receipts" means amounts realized "in a transaction that produces business income" (Revenue and Taxation Code section 25120(f)(1) and (f)(2)). A nonbusiness gain that is allocated under section 25125(d) is allocated under one of those sections, and its proceeds are therefore not in the factor. Amounts realized from a business-income sale enter the factor at the amount realized, not reduced by the basis of the property sold. Subdivision (f)(3) adds that excluding an item from "gross receipts" "shall not be determinative of its character as business or nonbusiness income."
Business receipts: in the factor, or excluded as a substantial occasional sale
If the gain is business income, the proceeds go into the sales factor unless the sale is excluded under Regulation 25137(c)(1)(A). That regulation provides that where substantial amounts of gross receipts "arise from an occasional sale of a fixed asset or other property held or used in the regular course of the taxpayer's trade or business, such gross receipts shall be excluded from the sales factor." A sale is substantial "if its exclusion results in a five percent or greater decrease in the sales factor denominator," and occasional "if the transaction is outside of the taxpayer's normal course of business and occurs infrequently." A one-time sale of an LLC interest by a seller that does not trade in such interests can meet both tests. A related article in this library covers the exclusion for a seller that sells businesses every few years. Exclusion removes the receipts from the factor, not the gain from the base, so the gain is still apportioned, using the sales factor as it stands with the receipts removed.
The exclusion is written for property held or used in the regular course of the seller's business. A seller that claims business-income treatment and the exclusion is therefore describing the interest as property held in its regular business. A seller that describes the same interest as an investment unconnected with its business may not fit that language, which is another way the two positions travel together.
If the receipts stay in the factor
If the sale is not substantial or not occasional, the receipts stay in the factor, and the numerator follows Regulation 25136-2(d)(1)(A)1., which assigns the sale of an ownership interest in a pass-through entity by looking through to the entity. As in force for a 2025 sale, the text operative since January 1, 2017 provides:
- If 50 percent or more of the entity's assets, "determined on the date of the sale, and using the original cost basis of those assets," are real or tangible personal property, the sale is assigned "by averaging the payroll and property factors" of the entity in California for the most recent twelve-month taxable year before the sale, using the current year's factors if the sale occurs more than six months into the current taxable year.
- If more than 50 percent of those assets are intangible property, the sale is assigned using the entity's sales factor in California for the same period, with the same six-month rule.
An amendment to the regulation applies to taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2026, and a sale in a later year needs the amended text. This article states the text in force for a 2025 sale.
The asset test in this regulation uses original cost on the date of sale, while the statute that allocates a nonbusiness gain uses the value of the entity's assets to test whether intangibles exceed 50 percent. Because the two tests measure differently, they can be run on the same entity and give different results.
The return takes one position, not two
The consistent filing has two parts that move together. Either the gain is nonbusiness income, allocated, and its proceeds are kept out of the factor; or the gain is business income, apportioned, and the receipts are either excluded or sourced. A return that allocates the gain and also counts the proceeds in the denominator, or that allocates the gain while combining the investee's factors, takes both positions at once. In Alvaco the corporation allocated the gain as nonbusiness income and also included 55 percent of the LLC's factors, and the OTA found the two unitary and the gain business income under the functional test. The labels on the return did not decide the result, and the FTB can be expected to examine both halves.
The federal question: the shareholder's participation, not the corporation's unity
The statute
The net investment income tax is "a tax equal to 3.8 percent of the lesser of" a taxpayer's net investment income or the excess of modified adjusted gross income over a threshold, which for a single filer is "$200,000" (Internal Revenue Code section 1411(a)(1) and (b)(3)). Net investment income includes "net gain (to the extent taken into account in computing taxable income) attributable to the disposition of property other than property held in a trade or business not described in paragraph (2)" (section 1411(c)(1)(A)(iii)). Paragraph (2) describes a trade or business that is "a passive activity (within the meaning of section 469) with respect to the taxpayer," or a trade or business of trading in financial instruments or commodities. Gain on property held in a trade or business that is neither stays outside net investment income.
An interest in a partnership or S corporation is not itself property held in a trade or business: the regulations state that "a partnership interest or S corporation stock generally is not property held in a trade or business" (Treasury Regulation section 1.1411-4(d)(4)(i)(B)(1)). Section 1411(c)(4) is the route that reaches through the entity. On a disposition of an interest in a partnership or S corporation, the gain counts as net investment income "only to the extent of the net gain which would be so taken into account by the transferor if all property of the partnership or S corporation were sold for fair market value immediately before the disposition of such interest." The result is that gain attributable to the LLC's assets used in a trade or business that is not passive for the owner drops out, and gain attributable to everything else stays in.
Whose participation counts
The test is passivity "with respect to the taxpayer." A passive activity is an activity that involves a trade or business "in which the taxpayer does not materially participate" (section 469(c)(1)), and a taxpayer materially participates only if involved in the operations of the activity on a basis that is "regular," "continuous," and "substantial" (section 469(h)(1)). The regulations give seven tests, any one of which establishes material participation for the year (Treasury Regulation section 1.469-5T(a)):
- The individual participates in the activity for more than 500 hours during the year.
- The individual's participation constitutes substantially all of the participation of all individuals in the activity, including individuals who do not own interests in it.
- The individual participates for more than 100 hours, and no other individual, owner or not, participates more.
- The activity is a significant participation activity, and the individual's participation in all such activities exceeds 500 hours.
- The individual materially participated in the activity for any five of the ten preceding years.
- The activity is a personal service activity in which the individual materially participated for any three preceding years.
- Based on all the facts and circumstances, the individual participates on a regular, continuous and substantial basis.
The measure is the individual shareholder's involvement in the LLC's own activity. The business that the S corporation itself runs is irrelevant to whether the LLC's business is passive for a shareholder, except through grouping. Treasury Regulation section 1.469-4(c) allows one or more activities to be treated as a single activity "if the activities constitute an appropriate economic unit," a question that "depends upon all the relevant facts and circumstances." Grouping is not available only because both businesses are owned through one corporation, and this article does not analyze it.
The reserved regulation and the proposal taxpayers may rely on
The final regulations reserve the section that would apply section 1411(c)(4). The preamble to Treasury Decision 9644 (78 Federal Register 72394, December 2, 2013) states that "Section 1.1411-7 of the final regulations is reserved for guidance under section 1411(c)(4)," and the same issue of the Federal Register proposed a text for it (REG-130843-13, 78 Federal Register 72451). The proposal states that "taxpayers may rely on these proposed regulations for purposes of compliance with section 1411" until final regulations issue. No final section 1.1411-7 was found as of November 11, 2026, and the proposal is the operative guidance. It is not a final rule.
Under proposed section 1.1411-7, the gain taken into account for a transferor of an interest in a partnership or S corporation described in paragraph (a)(3) is calculated under that section (paragraph (a)(1)). Paragraph (a)(3) covers transfers by individuals, estates and trusts, and, in a separate subparagraph, transfers by pass-through entities. For a gain, paragraph (b)(1)(i) limits the amount included to the lesser of the gain recognized and the transferor's share of net gain from a deemed sale of the entity's assets that are "Section 1411 Property," a term the proposal defines and this article does not analyze. Paragraphs (c)(2) and (c)(3) provide a simplified method with qualifications and exceptions to it. Paragraph (e), headed "Disposition of tiered Passthrough Entities," is marked reserved.
An S corporation that sells the LLC interest
In the example, the S corporation, not a shareholder, sells the LLC interest. The proposal addresses this: a disposition by a pass-through entity of an interest in a subsidiary pass-through entity qualifies for a partner or shareholder of the holder if that person would qualify had the person held the interest in the subsidiary directly. A shareholder who materially participates in the LLC's trade or business can claim the exception to the extent the deemed-sale computation supports it. A shareholder who does not materially participate has no basis for the exception and is left with the net investment income tax, subject to the thresholds.
The mechanics of reporting are not covered by the instructions for Form 8960, the form on which the tax is computed, in the portion read for this article. The 2025 instructions are written for an individual's own disposition of an equity interest in a partnership or S corporation. For an individual who materially participated in a trade or business activity of the entity that is not trading in financial instruments or commodities, line 5c carries an adjustment computed on a worksheet, and the instructions require a statement attached to the return for the year of disposition that names the entity and its taxpayer identification number, the gain or loss on line 5a, and the information the entity provided about the disposition. The portion of the instructions read does not address a sale by an S corporation of its own lower-tier interest. The instructions do not say how the shareholder of an S corporation reports that case.
What remains unsettled is the information problem the preamble describes: an owner of an upper-tier entity may not have access to the lower-tier entity's books, and no published source found says how that owner obtains the valuation the deemed sale requires.
Where the two positions press on each other
The California classification is not an input to the federal net investment income tax computation, and the federal result is not an input to the California classification. Neither return is bound by the other's label, and no authority found requires consistency between a federal passive position and a state nonbusiness position.
The pressure is evidentiary and arises in one combination only. For the federal exception to apply, an individual shareholder must show regular, continuous and substantial involvement in the LLC's own operations. For the state nonbusiness position, the corporation must show that the LLC had no operational tie to its business. A shareholder who works in the LLC's operations while the corporation tells the FTB that it had no operational tie will be asked to reconcile the two statements. The hours and the role that support participation are the kind of "actual operational ties" that Legal Ruling 2012-01 treats as decisive, and a shared individual is the unitary bond in Smith and a feature of the control facts in Alvaco.
Where the shareholders have no role in the LLC, the nonbusiness position and the net investment income result point the same way, and there is no conflict, only a cost the shareholders never had a basis to avoid. That cost can be called a forfeited exception only if the exception was available on the facts, and the exception requires the participation just described. The cross-pressure is therefore real only where the facts needed for one return are the facts denied on the other.
The pressure also has limits on the state side. A shareholder's work in the LLC is not the same as the corporation's operational tie to the LLC: the corporation's personnel, management rights, intercompany dealings and financing are what the sources examine. But an individual who both runs the corporation and works in the LLC supplies the kind of shared individual that Smith and Alvaco treated as the bond, so the two descriptions of that person's role are likely to be read together.
What remains open
No source found answers the following points, each of which is also stated earlier in the article.
- Whether, and how, the business or nonbusiness test applies to a minority, uncontrolled LLC interest held as an investment. No California ruling, regulation or decision found applies it, and the two reported LLC decisions found unity through shared individuals.
- Whether the 20 percent line in Regulation 17951-4(d)(5) and (d)(6), which concerns the sourcing of a nonresident partner's or shareholder's distributive share, bears on the character of a gain on selling a partnership or LLC interest.
- Business situs for a nonresident shareholder's nonbusiness gain. No published rule addresses a passive investee interest held by a California-based S corporation, or how much of the gain would be California-source if a situs existed.
- Other states' taxation of the corporation's and the shareholders' shares of the gain, and the resulting credit under Revenue and Taxation Code section 18001. The credit may be denied in the nonbusiness branch, and it was not researched here.
- How the Form 8960 statement is completed when the S corporation, not the shareholder, sold the LLC interest, and how an upper-tier owner without access to the lower tier's books obtains the valuation the deemed sale requires.
- Whether any final Treasury Regulation section 1.1411-7 has issued. Searches found none, which is not conclusive. The proposal's definition of Section 1411 Property is not analyzed here.
- How the amended text of Regulation 25136-2, which applies to taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2026, operates for a sale of an LLC interest. This article states the text in force for a 2025 sale.
- How section 23802(f)(3), which applies Internal Revenue Code section 469 to an S corporation for the entity-level tax, interacts with a gain on a passive activity.
- The California pass-through entity elective tax and its interaction with the gain.
- The treatment of ordinary-income items inside the LLC, often called hot assets, which the example assumes away. A separate article in this library covers a nonresident's sale of a partnership interest and the FTB's ruling on those items.
- Whether any state or federal authority requires consistent characterization between a federal passive position and a state nonbusiness position. None was located, and no published source states how the FTB uses a taxpayer's statements on one return in examining another.
- The issuance date of Legal Ruling 2012-01. Its first page prints 08.29.12 and its headers are reported to print 08.17.12, and the FTB's pages do not settle the date.
Worked example
The corporation, shareholders and LLC in this example are invented, and all amounts are round figures chosen for the illustration.
Facts. A software company (the S corporation) is commercially domiciled in California and does business in California and in other states. It has two equal shareholders: Shareholder R, a California resident, and Shareholder N, a Texas resident. In 2025 the S corporation sells its entire 30 percent interest in a trucking LLC based in Arizona, taxed as a partnership, which it bought ten years earlier as an investment. It has no manager seats, shares no officers and does no business with the LLC. Neither shareholder works in the LLC. The amount realized is $6,000,000 and the basis is $2,000,000, so the gain is $4,000,000, a long-term capital gain with no hot assets (ordinary-income items inside the LLC).
The S corporation's sales in 2025, apart from this sale, are $8,000,000 in California out of $20,000,000 everywhere, a 40 percent sales factor. The LLC's tangible property at original cost is $40,000,000 everywhere and $2,000,000 in California, out of total assets at original cost of $50,000,000. Tangible property is therefore 80 percent of its assets at original cost, above the 50 percent line, and the example assumes that less than half of its assets by value are intangible. For the variant in step A.7, the LLC has a property factor of 5 percent and a payroll factor of 3 percent for its most recent twelve-month year before the sale, and the sale falls in the first six months of the S corporation's year, so those prior-year factors apply. The example assumes that the point-in-time original-cost ratio and the year's property factor happen to coincide, and that the S corporation's basis in the LLC interest equals its share of the LLC's basis in its assets, so a deemed sale of the LLC's assets would produce the same gain.
Each shareholder is unmarried and files as single for 2025. Each shareholder's only income is the gain share of $2,000,000, so modified adjusted gross income, which is measured before deductions, is $2,000,000. The entity-level tax is the tax attributable to the gain alone: the S corporation's operating income and each shareholder's other income are ignored, as are deductions, credits and the additional 1 percent tax on taxable income above $1,000,000.
A. If the gain is business income, apportioned.
- Sales factor test for the proceeds. The denominator with the $6,000,000 would be $20,000,000 + $6,000,000 = $26,000,000. Excluding the proceeds reduces the denominator by $6,000,000 / $26,000,000 = 23.08 percent, which is at least 5 percent, so the sale is substantial. This branch assumes that the FTB prevails on the functional test, so the interest is treated as property held in the regular course of the business, and that the sale is a one-time sale outside the normal course, so it is occasional. The S corporation stands alone, so the 5 percent test is computed on its own denominator. The receipts are excluded and the sales factor stays at 40 percent.
- California amount: $4,000,000 x 40 percent = $1,600,000.
- Entity-level tax: $1,600,000 x 1.5 percent = $24,000.
- Shareholder R, a resident, is taxed on $2,000,000 under the 2025 Schedule X rate schedule, the California rate schedule for single filers: $72,219.84 + 12.30 percent x ($2,000,000 less $742,953) = $72,219.84 + 12.30 percent x $1,257,047 = $72,219.84 + $154,616.78 = $226,836.62.
- Shareholder N, a nonresident, has a California-source share of $2,000,000 x 40 percent = $800,000. The tax is the rate on N's entire income as if a resident, times the California-source income: $226,836.62 / $2,000,000 = 11.3418 percent, and 11.3418 percent x $800,000 = $90,734.65.
- Total California tax: $24,000 + $226,836.62 + $90,734.65 = $341,571.27.
- Variant, receipts not excluded. If the sale were not substantial or not occasional, Regulation 25136-2(d)(1)(A)1.a. as in force for 2025 would assign to California the average of the LLC's property factor (5 percent, which is $2,000,000 / $40,000,000) and its assumed payroll factor of 3 percent, which is 4 percent of $6,000,000 = $240,000. The sales factor would then be ($8,000,000 + $240,000) / $26,000,000 = 31.69 percent. This variant is shown only to illustrate that including the proceeds changes the factor for all of the S corporation's business income.
B. If the gain is nonbusiness income, allocated.
- Allocation under section 25125(d): $2,000,000 / $40,000,000 = 5 percent, and $4,000,000 x 5 percent = $200,000 is allocated to California. The proceeds are not in the factor, which stays at 40 percent.
- Entity-level tax: $200,000 x 1.5 percent = $3,000.
- Shareholder R is still taxed on $2,000,000, because a resident is taxed on all income: $226,836.62.
- Shareholder N: Regulation 17951-4(d)(4) sends the gain to section 17952. The LLC interest is an intangible and, on the facts, has no California business situs, so N's California-source share is $0.
- Total: $3,000 + $226,836.62 + $0 = $229,836.62. The difference from branch A is $341,571.27 less $229,836.62 = $111,734.65, of which $21,000 is entity-level tax ($24,000 less $3,000) and $90,734.65 is Shareholder N's tax.
- A C corporation seller on the same facts would pay 8.84 percent: $1,600,000 x 8.84 percent = $141,440 as business income, or $200,000 x 8.84 percent = $17,680 as nonbusiness income. The net investment income tax applies to individuals, estates and trusts, so a C corporation seller owes none of it. If the LLC had elected corporate status, the nonbusiness gain would be allocated to California in full under section 25125(c).
C. Federal net investment income tax, each shareholder.
- Neither shareholder materially participates in the LLC, so the gain is net investment income for each: $2,000,000.
- The threshold for a single filer is $200,000, and a joint return would use $250,000. Modified adjusted gross income of $2,000,000 exceeds the threshold by $1,800,000. The tax is 3.8 percent of the lesser of $2,000,000 and $1,800,000: $1,800,000 x 3.8 percent = $68,400 per shareholder, or $136,800 for both.
- If instead each shareholder had materially participated in the LLC's trade or business, and the deemed sale of the LLC's assets produced no gain on Section 1411 Property, the section 1411(c)(4) amount would be $0, which is the lesser of $2,000,000 and $0 under proposed section 1.1411-7(b)(1)(i). This assumes that the LLC's assets are all held in a trade or business that is not passive for each shareholder.
D. The four combinations.
- State business income, apportioned, and federal net investment income: California tax $341,571.27 + net investment income tax $136,800 = $478,371.27.
- State business income, apportioned, and federal gain excluded under section 1411(c)(4): $341,571.27 + $0 = $341,571.27.
- State nonbusiness income, allocated, and federal net investment income: $229,836.62 + $136,800 = $366,636.62.
- State nonbusiness income, allocated, and federal gain excluded under section 1411(c)(4): $229,836.62 + $0 = $229,836.62.
What the example shows. On the facts stated, in which neither shareholder works in the LLC, the supportable combination is the third: nonbusiness income and net investment income. The nonbusiness position did not forfeit an exception, because the exception was never available. The only combination that requires facts in tension is the fourth, nonbusiness income for the corporation and material participation by the shareholders in the LLC. The state saving there is $111,734.65 against $136,800 of federal tax, but the fourth combination also requires the shareholders to have participated in the LLC, and the example gives no such participation. For a group of resident shareholders only, the state saving shrinks to the $21,000 entity-level tax difference.
What the example leaves out. Arizona's tax on the gain and the credit under section 18001, which may be denied in the nonbusiness branch; the additional 1 percent tax; the treatment of any hot assets in the LLC; the deductibility of entity-level tax; the pass-through entity elective tax; installment treatment; and whether the LLC is a partnership for federal purposes by default, which the example assumes.
Practice notes
Fix the business or nonbusiness characterization of the gain as of the decision to sell, and document the LLC's operational ties on that date: management rights, board designations and vetoes, common officers or managers, purchases and sales between the two businesses, and financing. These are the facts the FTB's ruling on stock and the two LLC decisions turn on.
Obtain the LLC's tangible property at original cost, by state, as of the date of sale, and its asset mix by value, before choosing a return position. The section 25125(d) ratio and the 50 percent intangible test both turn on those figures, and they are measured differently.
Match the return to the characterization. Where the gain is nonbusiness income, keep the proceeds out of the sales factor and do not combine the LLC's factors. Where it is business income, test the substantial occasional sale exclusion at the 5 percent line, and if the receipts stay in the factor, compute the look-through under the text of Regulation 25136-2 in force for the taxable year, using the LLC's assets at original cost and the factors for the year the six-month rule selects.
Test each individual shareholder's material participation in the LLC's own activity under the seven tests, and keep the participation records for the year. Describe each shareholder's role in the LLC the same way on every return and in every record, because the sources the FTB relies on look for any shared individual and disregard ownership percentage in both directions.
Where the exception is claimed, compute the section 1411(c)(4) amount under the proposed regulation, attach the statement that the Form 8960 instructions require for the year of disposition, and consider whether the simplified reporting method applies. Where the S corporation, not the shareholder, sold the LLC interest, identify both entities in the statement and state the reliance on the proposed provision for transfers by pass-through entities, because the instructions do not address that case.
For nonresident shareholders, test business situs under Regulation 17952(c) before reporting a nonbusiness gain as outside California, and document that the interest was held as an investment, not pledged, and not used as working capital or security for the California business.
For resident shareholders in the nonbusiness branch, test whether a credit under section 18001 for another state's tax on the gain is available before relying on it.
G&G State Tax Group advises S corporations and their shareholders on California business and nonbusiness income characterization, allocation of gain on partnership interests, sales factor treatment and the interaction with the federal net investment income tax, alongside its state and local tax practice.
This article states the law as of November 11, 2026
Statutes, rates, thresholds, and agency practice change, and a different set of facts can change the answer. Before acting on anything discussed above, contact G&G State Tax Group, or another state and local tax adviser, to confirm what has changed since this was written and how the rules apply to a specific situation.
This publication is informational in nature and is not, and should not be considered, legal, accounting, tax, or other professional advice for any person or situation. Correct application of tax law depends heavily on the facts and circumstances in each case, and G&G State Tax Group, LLC assumes no liability in connection with the use of this information, and is not obligated to inform any reader of changes in the law or other factors that could affect the information contained herein.
