MultistateIncome and franchise tax
Is a partnership's state payment withholding, composite tax or an entity-level tax, and why does the label change the credit, an overpayment and what each partner files?
The short answer
The statutory character of a partnership's state payment decides who claims the credit, how an overpayment is handled and which returns partners file. Withholding is a payment on the partner's account: the partner claims the credit, Illinois's regulation bars the paying entity from claiming an overpayment, and California allows no refund of tax withheld from payments to a pass-through entity. Composite tax is the partner's tax paid on the entity's return. Alabama lets the entity credit forward or refund an overpayment until the extended due date, and then the member claims the overpayment. Louisiana pays an overpayment shown on the composite return to the partnership and a partner included in it may elect a refund or credit for the excess over its tax. A Louisiana partner included in the composite return with no other Louisiana income need not file a return; an Alabama partner with other Alabama income must file one. An entity-level tax is the entity's own liability, and a partner receives only the credit the statute names, if any. Alabama requires a lower tier that has not elected the entity-level tax to pay composite tax for a partner that is itself a partnership; Louisiana does not allow one.
Working through this on a live matter? Contact the firm
The three instruments
A partnership's workpaper may carry every payment it makes to a state for its nonresident partners as withholding. The states do not treat the payments alike. The statute or rule under which the payment is made makes it one of three instruments, and each instrument answers differently who may claim the credit, whether an overpayment is credited forward, refunded or left for the partner to claim, and what the partner's own return must show. The article covers Alabama, Louisiana, Illinois, Connecticut, New York and California, with a short note on Georgia and Pennsylvania. It describes tiers by function: the lower-tier partnership earns the income, and the upper-tier partnership holds an interest in it.
Withholding is a payment on the partner's account. California's statute lets the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) require withholding by a person "having the control, receipt, custody, disposal, or payment of items of income specified in subdivision (b)," and the listed items include "partnership income or gains." The amount withheld "shall be allowed to the recipient of the income as a credit," so the recipient of the income, not the payer, takes the credit. Illinois requires every partnership to withhold from each nonresident partner at "the applicable rates of tax for that partner, shareholder, or beneficiary," and treats the amount withheld and paid as "a payment of the estimated tax liability or of the liability for withholding under this Section of the partner, shareholder, or beneficiary to whom the income is distributable." New York words its rule as estimated tax: an entity with nonresident individual or C corporation owners "shall pay estimated tax on such income on behalf of such partners, members or shareholders," and the payment "shall be deemed to be a payment of estimated tax by the partner, member or shareholder." In each state the partner is the taxpayer, the payment is the partner's, and the credit lands on the partner's return.
Composite tax is also the partner's tax, but it is paid on a return that the entity files for its partners. Alabama requires a pass-through entity to file "a composite income tax return on behalf of its nonresident members" and to pay tax "at the highest applicable marginal rate provided in Section 40-18-5," and the Alabama Department of Revenue's instructions apply 5 percent to each nonresident member's share. The Department's frequently asked questions page answers the question whether a nonresident can opt out of composite filing with a no: a partnership "is required to file a composite return and make composite payments on behalf of its nonresident owners or members" if there are one or more of them at any time during the year. Louisiana makes the composite return the default: a partnership engaged in activities in the state "shall file composite returns and make composite payment of tax on behalf of any or all of its nonresident partners or members who do not agree to file an individual return." The payment is "a payment by the nonresident partner or member on account of the income tax imposed on the nonresident partner or member for the taxable period."
California and New York have group returns, an elective counterpart. California's statute lets the FTB, "in lieu of electing nonresident partners filing a return," provide for "a group return for one or more electing nonresident partners" filed by a partnership "doing business in, or deriving income from, sources in California." New York's instructions for Form IT-203-GR allow a group return for a partnership that "has 11 or more qualified nonresident partners or members" who elect, and the regulation says the partnership "may be granted approval by the Department of Taxation and Finance" to file it. Illinois no longer has a partner composite return for current years. Section 502(f) of the Illinois Income Tax Act (IITA) gave the Department authority to permit composite returns for nonresident individual partners only "for taxable years ending prior to December 31, 2014," so the article treats the composite clause that remains in section 709.5(a), which excludes a partner "who is included on a composite return filed by the partnership or Subchapter S corporation," as dormant for current years and does not list a composite return as a live Illinois exemption.
The word composite is not uniform across states. The FTB's instructions for the other state tax credit refer to a "group nonresident tax return" and, in the part read, do not use the word composite, and New York's instructions for Form IT-112-R write "group (composite) return." The label to check is the one in the state's own statute or form.
Entity-level taxes are the entity's own liability, and a partner receives a credit only if a statute or the state's own pronouncement gives one. Illinois imposes a replacement tax "on every corporation (including Subchapter S corporations), partnership and trust," with an additional amount of 1.5 percent of net income for a partnership, trust or S corporation. Illinois separately lets a partnership elect an entity-level tax at 4.95 percent imposed for "the privilege of earning or receiving income in this State." Connecticut lets an affected business entity, meaning a partnership or an S corporation other than a publicly traded partnership, "elect to pay to the commissioner a tax as determined under this section," at 6.99 percent of the tax base. Alabama's electing pass-through entity "shall pay a tax at the highest marginal rate," and the owners "shall not be liable for the tax otherwise imposed by Chapter 16 and this chapter on their pro rata or distributive shares of the electing pass-through entity's income." Louisiana taxes an electing entity at the rate levied on individuals and bars the election for a year in which the entity files a composite return. California's elective tax and New York City's unincorporated business tax (UBT), which falls on the partnership, are also entity-level taxes with a partner credit; the next section describes each credit.
Where the credit lands
For withholding, the credit follows the statement the paying entity files, and an entity that only received the payment does not keep the credit. California passes tax withheld from payments to a pass-through entity up to the entity's owners, and the regulation says the credit "must be claimed by the entity's owners on their respective tax returns." The exception is an entity that files a group return: under section 19002(b) of the California Revenue and Taxation Code, a partnership, limited liability company (LLC) or S corporation "filing a group return as agent" for its electing nonresident partners or shareholders takes the withholding as a credit "attributable to the partnership" or other entity on the group return. Illinois entitles the owner to "a credit equal to that amount against its liability under IITA Section 201." An owner that is itself a pass-through entity "may claim some or all of that amount as a credit against the amount it is required to withhold," and once a return claims it there, the owner "may not claim that amount as a credit against any other liability."
For composite tax, the payment is the partner's, but the credit is claimed in different places. An Alabama member included in the composite return may file its own return and receives credit for the tax paid on its behalf. In Louisiana, the regulation treats amounts the partnership pays for a partner whose only Louisiana income is from the partnership as "a payment of that partner's Louisiana individual income tax liability," and treats amounts paid for a partner with other Louisiana-source income as an advance payment of the liability shown on that partner's individually filed return. The Louisiana statute adds that credits claimed on a composite return are not allowed on any other return submitted by or on behalf of a member or partner for the same tax period.
For an elected entity-level tax, the credit is a statutory credit against the partner's own tax, with a state-specific carryover or refund:
- Illinois. Each partner of an electing partnership is allowed a credit "in an amount equal to 4.95% times the partner or shareholder's distributive share of the net income of the electing partnership or Subchapter S corporation, but not to exceed the partner's or shareholder's share of the tax imposed under paragraph (1) which is actually paid by the partnership or Subchapter S corporation." A credit above the partner's liability "shall be treated as an overpayment for purposes of Section 909." The Illinois Department of Revenue's Publication 129 (R-12/25) states that the credit for the entity-level tax "is considered paid/received on the last day of the pass-through entity's tax year."
- Connecticut. A member subject to the chapter 229 income tax is entitled to a credit "multiplied by eighty-seven and one-half per cent." Any excess is treated as an overpayment and, except as provided in sections 12-739 and 12-742, refunded without interest. The text of subdivision (f)(1) read has no sentence on carrying a credit forward.
- California. The FTB's page on the elective tax states that unused credits "can be carried over for up to 5 years" and that the credit is claimed by filing Form FTB 3804-CR with the return. Section 19916(a) provides that the part governing later years "shall only become operative if the operation of Section 164(b)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to the limitation on individual deductions for taxable years 2018 through 2025, is extended," and the FTB's page states the election is available "for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2021, and before January 1, 2031." Separate articles in this library cover the elective tax.
- Alabama. The Alabama Department of Revenue's page on electing pass-through entities states that owners "shall be entitled to a refundable credit in an amount equal to its pro rata or distributive share" and that a member seeking to claim the credit "will have to file a return." The page is the Department's pronouncement. The article did not locate where the credit is codified.
The Illinois replacement tax carries no partner credit in any statute read. The tax is measured by net income, and the provisions that define that income for a partnership, which include section 203(d) of the Illinois Income Tax Act, could not be read for this article, so the article says no credit to the partner in the statutes read and not that the partner has no relief.
What happens to an overpayment
Whether the payment is withholding, composite tax or an entity-level tax decides who receives an overpayment as cash.
- Withholding. The partner holds the credit for tax withheld from the partner, and the states limit what the entity can recover. Illinois's regulation provides that the pass-through entity "may not claim a refund or credit for any overpayment of withholding," and the remedy is for the owner "to file a timely claim for credit or refund." The Illinois Department of Revenue's Publication 129 reads differently in part: in its answer on a pass-through entity that overpays, it says "the pass-through entity may request a refund," that "A pass-through entity cannot amend a return merely to request a refund," and that "the member must file a timely claim for credit or refund." The sources read do not say how the regulation and the publication fit together, and a separate article in this library covers Illinois overpayments of withholding. California allows a refund or credit to the withholding agent "only to the extent that the amount of the overpayment was not deducted and withheld by the employer or withholding agent," with no interest, for tax imposed by sections 18662 and 18666 of the Revenue and Taxation Code. Separately, the California regulation provides that "No refund of tax withheld from payments to pass-through entities is allowed," a sentence that, on its words, addresses an entity that was the payee of the withheld payment. A partnership, LLC or S corporation that files a group return as agent holds the credit on that return, as described above. Tax withheld from a partner is that partner's credit, claimed on the partner's own return.
- Composite tax in Alabama. The overpayment is the filing entity's to credit forward or refund, within a window. Form PTE-C has a line for the amount "to be credited to the following tax year" (line 7a) and a line for the amount "to be refunded" (line 7b). The rule provides that "An amended composite return reporting an overpayment of tax" may be filed by the extended due date for the partnership return, and the instructions repeat that amended composite returns reporting a refund "may be filed up to the extended due date." After that date, "No refund may be requested by a pass-through entity after the extended due date for filing the composite return," and any refund "must be requested on the Alabama income tax return of the" nonresident owner. For a calendar-year entity the 2025 instructions state a return due date of March 15, 2026 and an extended due date of September 15, 2026. The Department's FAQ confirms that a nonresident cannot opt out of the composite return and that the entity must file it.
- Composite tax in Louisiana. Two routes exist. The first belongs to the partnership: when a composite return shows an overpayment, "the overpayment shall be paid to the partnership that filed the composite return," and Schedule 6922 carries the overpayment, the part applied to the next year and the part refunded. The second belongs to the partner: "To the extent that the payment made on behalf of the nonresident partner or member exceeds the income tax liability of the nonresident partner or member, that nonresident partner or member shall be entitled to a refund, or may elect to utilize such excess as a credit against amounts that may be paid by the partnership on his behalf with respect to subsequent taxable periods." The sources read do not show how a partner makes or reports that election; the Schedule 6922 lines read are entity-level lines.
- Group return in New York. The opposite rule applies. The instructions for Form IT-203-GR state that the amount overpaid is applied automatically to the partner's estimated tax for the following year and cannot be refunded, and the regulation says an overpayment "will not be refunded, but applied to" the partner's estimated income tax for the following year.
- New York estimated tax payment for nonresident owners. The payment is deemed the owner's estimated tax payment, so the route for an excess is the owner's own return. The filing rule itself was not read.
- Elective entity-level tax. The entity's overpayment of its own tax follows the entity's refund rules, which this article does not develop. The partner's excess credit follows the partner-credit rules in the previous section.
For the ordinary Alabama case the sources supply a method: the statute's annual record to each member of the tax remitted for that member, column (F) of Schedule PTE-CK1, the member's credit and the member's own return. A member's refund is then the excess of the amount recorded for that member over that member's own tax. Two cases are not answered by the sources read: whether an overpayment first found after the extended due date can still be credited forward, and how an entity-level excess that no member's record carries is handled. Both are listed under open points. A separate article in this library takes up refunds of excess nonresident withholding in eight states, including Pennsylvania.
What the partner's own return must show
- Withholding. The partner's return shows the income and the credit named on the statement the entity furnishes. California passes the credit to owners on Form 592-B, and the California regulation says it "must be claimed by the entity's owners on their respective tax returns." For Illinois, the Illinois Department of Revenue's Publication 129 states that when the pass-through withholding satisfies a nonresident individual's Illinois liability, the individual is not required to file an Illinois return. A partner whose withholding exceeds the liability and who wants the excess files the claim, as the Illinois regulation provides. In the worked example below, partner D is a partner whose withholding exceeds the liability.
- Composite tax in Alabama. The 2025 instructions for Form PTE-C say that "Every nonresident owner or shareholder whose income is reported on a composite return must file an Alabama" return and report the Alabama-source income, and then make an exception for a nonresident who has no other Alabama-source income. The statute says an included member "may" file its own return and receive credit. The two are consistent. The statute's "may" gives the included member a right to file and take the credit. The general duty to file is in section 40-18-27(a), under which a taxpayer with gross income above the stated sum, "as allowed for his or her respective filing status, shall each year file" a return, and the instructions state the Department's version of that duty, with an administrative exception for a member whose only Alabama income is on the composite return. Rule 810-3-24.2-.03(1) says the same for members of a qualified investment partnership. The rule on refunds gives one reason an excused member files anyway: a refund after the extended due date must be requested on the member's own return. A nonresident with a loss is left off the composite return: the instructions say "If a nonresident owner/share holder has a loss, do not include him/her on Form PTE-C," and the instructions add that the exclusion does not apply if the loss offsets guaranteed payments.
- Composite tax in Louisiana. A partner with a valid agreement files Form IT-540B. The regulation says that "The filing of a true, correct, and complete partnership composite return will relieve any nonresident partner properly included in the composite return from the duty to file an individual return, provided that the nonresident partner does not have any income from Louisiana sources other than that income reported in the composite return." The Louisiana Department of Revenue's instructions for the partnership return (Form IT-565i) state that nonresident partners who have a valid agreement or who have other income derived from Louisiana sources "must be listed on Schedule A, NOT Included Partner's Share of Income and Tax," and must include all income derived from Louisiana sources on Form IT-540B. The sources read do not say how the regulation's treatment of an amount paid for a partner with other Louisiana income, as an advance payment of the liability on that partner's individually filed return, fits with the instructions' Schedule A placement of that partner.
- Group return in New York and California. A partner included in a group return generally files no individual return for that income. New York's instructions say that "the partner is not required to file an individual New York State personal income tax return," that the partner must waive New York personal income tax credits, and that a qualified partner may have no other New York-source income; the regulation adds that the Department "retains the right to require the filing of an individual" return, so both the instruction and the reservation belong in the analysis. California's group return is available "in lieu of" the partners filing their own returns.
- Elective entity-level tax. The credit appears on the partner's return: in Illinois under section 201(p), in Connecticut for members subject to the chapter 229 income tax, and in California on Form FTB 3804-CR. For a New York City resident partner, Form IT-219 carries the UBT credit; the instructions state that "The credit is also available to partners in partnerships," that the credit is 100 percent of the UBT imposed at city taxable income of $42,000 or less and 23 percent at $142,000 or more, and that "Any unused credit cannot be refunded or carried over." In Alabama, a member seeking the electing entity's credit has to file a return.
What changes when a lower-tier partnership pays for an upper-tier partnership
A lower-tier partnership's payment for an upper-tier partnership is a different instrument in each state.
- Alabama. A lower tier that has not elected the entity-level tax pays composite tax for a nonresident partner that is a Subchapter K entity (a partnership taxed under Subchapter K of the Internal Revenue Code, IRC) not commercially domiciled in Alabama. The statute reaches "A Subchapter K entity or business trust that is created or organized under the laws" of another jurisdiction and "that is not commercially domiciled in this state." The upper tier then has its own filing duty: the rule says that a pass-through entity that is a member of another pass-through entity and is credited with a composite payment "must also file a composite return to properly report the composite payment." The instructions report the credit on Schedule CP-B, and the schedule's total goes on line 5c of Form PTE-C. A lower tier that has elected the entity-level tax files no composite return on the Department's FAQ: "No, if an entity elects to be treated as an Electing Pass-Through Entity, the composite return is not required." That relief rests on the Department's pronouncement and not on statutory words, and the statute says the owners are not liable for the tax on their shares. A lower tier cannot exempt an indirect owner on its own. The exemption needs advance approval: the instructions say the request must be submitted "30 days before the original due date (without extension)" with Form NRC-Exempt, and the rule provides that requests on Form PTE-R "must be received at least 30 days before the original filing date." That is the route for an upper-tier partner that would not itself owe composite tax, such as an exempt organization.
- Louisiana. Partners that are themselves partnerships are outside the composite return. The instructions state that "Partners who are themselves partnerships cannot be included," and the regulation says corporate partners and partners that are themselves partnerships "cannot be included in composite returns filed by a partnership." The exclusion is regulatory: no sentence of the composite statute read excludes a corporation or partnership as a partner. The lower tier does not pay composite tax for the upper tier; the upper tier files its own return and its own Schedule 6922 for its nonresident individual, estate and trust partners.
- Illinois. An owner that is itself a pass-through entity may use the lower tier's withholding credit against what it must withhold from its own owners, once. For the elective tax, the credit passes down a tier: when the taxpayer "is itself a partner of a partnership making the election," the credit "shall be allowed to the taxpayer's partners or shareholders" in accordance with sections 702 and 704 of the IRC.
- Connecticut. The elective tax has a tier rule. Stated by function, the member entity, when computing its Connecticut source income, subtracts its distributive share of income, or adds its distributive share of loss, from the entity of which it is a member. The statute applies the rule when "an affected business entity, the lower-tier entity, is a member of another affected business entity, the upper-tier entity." The statute's labels are the reverse of this article's: its lower-tier entity is the member. The term affected business entity does not depend on an election, so as written the rule applies when the member and the entity of which it is a member are both affected business entities, whether or not the second elected. The Department of Revenue Services' instructions for the entity tax were not read and may say otherwise.
- California. Withholding credit passes up through the pass-through entity's owners; a separate article in this library covers the lower-tier credit.
- New York. The estimated tax provision names owners that are nonresident individuals or C corporations, and a partnership owner is not among them in the text read. The group return requires a qualified partner who is a nonresident individual.
- Georgia. The rule lets tax withheld at one level be claimed on a composite return at another level; see the short note below.
Credit for tax paid to another state
The partner's state of residence decides whether a payment made to another state earns a credit at home, and it applies its own label. Each state's rule is stated in its own words:
- California. California allows a credit for "net income taxes imposed by and paid to another state" on income taxable under the same part of the code. The FTB's instructions for Schedule S (Other State Tax Credit) say that California residents "who are included in a group nonresident tax return similar to the tax return" described in section 18535, filed with the states listed in the instructions, "may also claim a credit" for their share of income taxes paid to those states, unless a state allows a credit for taxes paid to California on the group return. The word composite does not appear in that part, and the list of states in the instructions includes both Alabama and Louisiana. The FTB is therefore not silent, but the instructions do not say whether Alabama's mandatory composite return, or Louisiana's default one, is a group nonresident tax return similar to California's elective group return. Whether the difference between a return that is mandatory or the default and one that is elective bears on the similarity test is not stated in any source read, so the question is left open. The instructions also state that, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2022, and before January 1, 2026, "the calculation of the other state tax credit has changed"; the article does not develop that change.
- New York. Form IT-112-R is a resident's form: the instructions say it is claimed by "a full-year or part-year resident of New York State." Line 24 measures the credit by the income tax imposed on the resident's return for the other jurisdiction and says not to enter tax withheld, estimated tax payments or payments of balances due on that line. Line 24a takes amounts paid on the resident's behalf on a "group (composite) return." Line 24b takes pass-through entity tax "substantially similar to New York State's pass-through entity tax" and excludes taxes that are not substantially similar to it. A nonresident of New York in a New York group return or estimated tax payment claims any credit under the home state's rules and not on Form IT-112-R.
- Illinois. Section 601(b)(3) allows a credit for the tax "imposed upon or measured by income and which is paid by a resident for a taxable year to another state or states," limited to the amount that "bears the same ratio to the tax imposed" as stated in the section, and the credit "shall not be allowed if any creditable tax was deducted in determining base income." Whether the credit reaches a composite or group payment was not read.
- Connecticut. A resident or part-year resident member of an affected business entity is entitled to a credit against the chapter 229 income tax for the member's "direct and indirect share of taxes paid to another state" on a tax "substantially similar to the tax imposed under this section."
Exemptions and elections
In the states covered, a partner or an entity may opt out of one instrument by taking another, and the timing rules differ:
- Alabama. Form NRC-Exempt, the Subchapter K affidavit of exemption by a nonresident, lists six categories: a real estate investment trust; an exempt organization, an insurance company member, a capital credit exemption and a C corporation with losses, each marked "annual election required"; and a pre-approved tiered structure exemption. For the trust category the form says "Copies of original affidavit should be attached to future years' returns." For the tiered structure the form requires "prior written approval required and a copy must be attached each year." The form also says a copy should be attached to the entity's composite and income tax return each year, so the form is an annual attachment in every category and only the trust's election is made once. The entity-level election under section 40-18-24.4 relieves the entity of the composite return on the Department's FAQ.
- Louisiana. The agreement is the partner's election and carries forward: once an agreement is timely filed for one period, the statute treats it as timely filed for each subsequent taxable period of the partnership. The entity-level election cannot be made for a year in which the entity files a composite return.
- Illinois. A nonresident owner that is not an individual, and from which the partnership has received the certificate described in subsection (c), is outside withholding: the partnership "shall not be required to withhold tax under subsection (a)" for such an owner. An entity that made the section 201(p) election does not withhold for that year: "The provisions of Section 709.5 of this Act shall not apply" to it. The composite-return exclusion in section 709.5(a) is dormant, as described above.
- Connecticut. A composite election for nonresident individual members, which section 12-699b once provided, was repealed effective January 1, 2024.
- Who may not join a composite. In Louisiana, corporations, partnerships and tax-exempt trusts, and nonresident partners with an agreement or other Louisiana income. In Alabama, a nonresident with a loss. In New York, a partner with New York-source income beyond the share, or a partner who is not a nonresident individual.
Georgia and Pennsylvania
Georgia's Rule 560-7-8-.34 on nonresident members lets an entity "elect to file a composite income tax return" in lieu of withholding. It provides that tax "withheld at one level can be claimed on a composite return at another level," and that withholding "shall not be required for a member which is also an entity." The Cornell text of Rule 560-7-8-.34 read for this article shows the rule's last amendment effective December 19, 2018. The Georgia Department of Revenue's Notice ITD-2026-001 proposed to amend the rule, with a remote hearing set for March 5, 2026, and the separate Georgia article in this library, which read the official compilation, reports the rule as amended effective June 11, 2026, with subsection (4)(b) unchanged. The quotations above are from the earlier text, and the article did not compare subsections (3)(a) and (5)(a) with the amended text.
Pennsylvania's guide says a partnership with nonresident individual owners "must withhold and pay Pennsylvania personal income tax on each owner's expected share." The guide adds that an entity may not withhold for another entity or a Pennsylvania resident individual, and that the final payment may be made with Form PA-40 NRC "if the nonresident owners elect to file a PA-40 NRC, Nonresident Consolidated Income Tax Return." The consolidated return is Pennsylvania's elective counterpart of a composite or group return. The article states nothing on Pennsylvania overpayments: no refund or credit rule for excess nonresident-owner withholding was located in the part of the guide read, and a separate article in this library covers Pennsylvania's rule.
State-by-state reference
Each line gives the instrument, whose account it is, how an overpayment is handled and what the partner must still file:
- Alabama, composite tax. The partner's tax on the entity's return. The entity credits forward (line 7a) or refunds (line 7b) until the extended due date; after it, the member claims the refund on its own return. The instructions require a member to file unless the member has no other Alabama-source income; the statute says the member "may" file.
- Alabama, electing pass-through entity. The entity's tax; the owners are not liable for the tax on their shares. The Alabama Department states that owners receive a refundable credit. A member seeking the credit files a return, and the Department's FAQ says the electing entity files no composite return.
- Louisiana, composite tax. The partner's tax on the entity's return. A composite-return overpayment is paid to the partnership; the excess of an included partner's payment over that partner's own tax is the partner's, by refund or credit election. Agreement partners and partners with other Louisiana income file Form IT-540B; a properly included partner with no other Louisiana income is relieved of filing.
- Louisiana, entity election. The entity's tax at the individual rate, barred for a year in which the entity files a composite return.
- Illinois, pass-through withholding. The partner's account. The regulation bars the entity from claiming an overpayment and the partner files the claim; Publication 129 also says the entity may request a refund. A nonresident individual whose liability the withholding satisfies need not file.
- Illinois, replacement tax. The entity's own tax, an additional 1.5 percent of net income for a partnership. No partner credit appears in the statutes read; the base under section 203(d) was not read.
- Illinois, elective entity tax. The entity's tax, with a partner credit and no withholding in an election year. A credit above the partner's liability is an overpayment, and the partner files to use it.
- Connecticut, elective tax. The entity's tax, with an 87.5 percent credit to members subject to the chapter 229 income tax, refunded without interest if it exceeds the member's liability. A resident member has a credit for substantially similar tax paid to another state.
- California, withholding. The partner's account. The owners claim the credit; an entity that was the payee gets no refund; a group-return entity holds the credit on that return.
- California, group return. The partner's tax on the entity's return as agent. The partner does not file on that income, and the home state's credit rule applies.
- California, elective tax. The entity's tax, with a partner credit carried over up to five years; the live articles cover it.
- New York, estimated tax for nonresident owners. The owner's estimated tax. The route for an excess is the owner's own return; the filing rule was not read.
- New York, group return. The partner's tax on the entity's return. An overpayment is applied to the partner's estimated tax for the following year with no refund. The partner generally files no return, waives New York credits, and remains subject to the Department's right to require a return.
- New York City, unincorporated business tax. The partnership's tax. A New York City resident partner claims the Form IT-219 credit, which cannot be refunded or carried over.
What remains open
- Alabama, crediting forward after the extended due date. The Alabama rule bars an entity refund request after the extended due date, and the 2025 Form PTE-C instructions repeat that deadline. No source read says whether an overpayment first found after that date can still be credited forward on a later return. Line 5a of Form PTE-C asks for the overpayment "as shown on the Form PTE-C return for the previous tax year," which presupposes an overpayment shown on the prior return and, under the rule on amended returns, reported by the extended due date; that is an inference from the form.
- Alabama, an entity-level excess that no member's record carries. For the ordinary case the sources supply the method described above. No source read gives a method for an excess that is not 5 percent of any member's share, such as the duplicate payment in the example.
- California, whether Alabama's mandatory or Louisiana's default composite return is a group nonresident tax return similar to California's elective group return. The FTB's instructions list both states and use the phrase "similar to"; no FTB page read states the answer.
- Louisiana, the partner's election and the partner with other income. The sources read do not show how a partner's refund or credit election under the statute is made or reported. They also do not show how the regulation's treatment of an amount paid for a partner with other Louisiana income, as an advance payment, fits with the instructions' placement of that partner on Schedule A. No Louisiana withholding instrument on a nonresident partner's distributive share was found in the statute, the regulation, the instructions or the Department's partnership page, but a negative cannot be proven from the pages read.
- Illinois, section 203(d) and the replacement tax base. The section could not be read at the hosts tried. Whether the base for an upper-tier partnership already excludes income of a lower-tier partnership subject to the same tax depends on that section. Also unread: section 709.5(d) beyond its opening clause, and amendments to 86 Ill. Adm. Code 100.7035 after 2016.
- Illinois, the regulation and Publication 129 on an entity refund. The regulation bars the entity's claim and the publication says the entity may request a refund; no source read states how the two fit.
- Connecticut, the Department of Revenue Services' instructions for the entity tax and the 2026 supplement to the General Statutes. Subsection (d) is read; whether the Department applies it only when both entities elected is not stated in any source read. The supplement could not be read.
- Georgia, the amended text of June 11, 2026. The proposed amendment was read as a notice; the amended rule was not read for this article, and subsections (3)(a) and (5)(a) are quoted from the earlier text.
- Smaller unread points. Where the Alabama electing entity's refundable owner credit is codified, since the Department's page is the citable source; the Louisiana statute and session law text behind the 3 percent individual rate, which the article takes from the Department's instructions; New York City Administrative Code section 11-503, which imposes the UBT; whether the text of the California regulation on withholding credits (title 18 of the California Code of Regulations, section 19002) as read matches the FTB's current text; whether the condition in section 19916(a) is met, which the FTB's page treats as met by stating the election is available through 2030 and which was not tested; and a New York owner-return filing rule for the section 658(c)(4) payment. Alabama section 40-18-24.2 was read as printed in the 2024 Code of Alabama, and sections 40-18-5, 40-18-24.4 and 40-18-27 as printed in the 2025 Code of Alabama; the official host refused automated reads.
Worked example
The partnership, the partners and the amounts below are invented, and the amounts are round figures chosen for the illustration. The example does not describe a typical or recommended structure.
Facts. An upper-tier partnership, called UT below, has four individual partners, A, B, C and D, each with 25 percent. A lives in California, B in New York, C in Texas and D in Florida. UT earns income in three states for 2025. UT is organized under the laws of Delaware and is not commercially domiciled in Alabama, Louisiana or Illinois. Unless a step says otherwise, no partner has other income in the three states.
Alabama: $200,000 earned through a lower-tier partnership. The lower-tier partnership, called LT below, has Alabama-source income of $200,000 allocable to UT. UT is a Subchapter K entity created under the laws of another jurisdiction and not commercially domiciled in Alabama, so LT includes it as a nonresident member. Neither LT nor UT has elected the entity-level tax.
- LT's composite payment for UT is 5 percent of $200,000, which is $10,000. The 5 percent is the rate on Schedule PTE-CK1.
- UT reports the $10,000 on Schedule CP-B and line 5c of its own Form PTE-C, and the rule requires UT to file a composite return.
- UT's own composite computation on its four partners: each share is $50,000, the tax is 5 percent of $50,000, which is $2,500, and the total is $10,000. The credit of $10,000 less the liability of $10,000 leaves a balance of $0.
- UT gives each partner a record of the $2,500 by the date the instructions state, March 15, 2026. Because none of the four has other Alabama-source income, none must file under the instructions. A partner who files, for example to claim a refund after the extended due date, claims the $2,500 as an included member.
- Variant 1, a partner whose own tax is below the composite amount. C also has a $30,000 Alabama-source loss from an unrelated activity, so C files. The composite payment is figured on UT's $50,000 allocation to C, and C's separate loss plays no part in it. C's Alabama taxable income on C's own return is $50,000 less $30,000, which is $20,000. The example assumes, without having read the nonresident return's computation, that the tax is figured at the section 40-18-5 rates for a single filer: 2 percent of $500 is $10, 4 percent of the next $2,500 is $100, and 5 percent of the remaining $17,000 is $850, a tax of $960 before any standard deduction or personal exemption, which were not read. C's credit is $2,500, so C's claim is at least $2,500 less $960, which is $1,540. The recovery runs through C's own return.
- Variant 2, the duplicate payment. UT's workpaper did not show that LT had paid, and UT also paid $10,000 with its extension request. Payments and credits are $20,000 against a liability of $10,000, an overpayment of $10,000. Until the extended due date, September 15, 2026 for a calendar-year entity on the instructions, UT reports the overpayment on an amended Form PTE-C and takes it on line 7a (credit forward) or line 7b (refund). After that date UT cannot request a refund, and a refund must be requested on a member's own Alabama return. The extra $10,000 is not 5 percent of any member's share and so is in no member's record, and no source read gives a method for attributing it, which is why the entity route before the deadline matters. Treating the $20,000 as withholding would also hide the entity's line 7a or 7b route.
- Credit at home. B, a New York resident, can enter the $2,500 on line 24a of Form IT-112-R as an amount paid on B's behalf on a group (composite) return, subject to that form's limits. A, a California resident, falls under the Schedule S sentence on a group nonresident tax return similar to California's; whether Alabama's mandatory composite return meets it is open point 3. The example gives C and D no home-state income tax, so no credit question arises for them.
Louisiana: $50,000 earned directly by UT. Each partner's share is $12,500. A and B have filed no agreement and have no other Louisiana-source income. C and D have timely agreements under the statute.
- Composite base: A and B, 2 x $12,500, which is $25,000. The tax at 3 percent is $750, or $375 each.
- C and D report $12,500 each on Form IT-540B.
- A and B, properly included and with no other Louisiana-source income, are relieved of filing an individual return. If either had other Louisiana-source income, the instructions would place that partner on Schedule A and that partner would file Form IT-540B with all Louisiana-source income; open point 4 notes that the sources read do not settle how the regulation's advance payment treatment then applies.
- UT pays $1,500, which is 3 percent of the full $50,000, as if all four partners were included. The composite return shows $1,500 against a tax of $750, an overpayment of $750. Under the statute that amount is paid to UT, and Schedule 6922 shows it for credit to the next year or refund. That is route one. Route two is the partner's: to the extent the payment made on behalf of A exceeds A's own Louisiana tax, A is entitled to a refund or may elect a credit. The amount depends on A's own computed Louisiana liability, which turns on deductions and credits this example does not model, so no figure is stated, and the form read does not show how the election is made or reported.
- Payment for 2025 is due May 15, 2026, and the instructions say an extension of time to file does not extend the time to pay.
- This is a composite payment, not withholding. If the income had come through LT, LT could not include UT in its composite return, and UT would file its own Louisiana return and Schedule 6922.
Illinois: $300,000 earned directly by UT. The $300,000 is business income apportioned to Illinois, the income to which the withholding statute applies. UT made no election under section 201(p) for 2025, so withholding applies. Each partner's share is $75,000.
- Pass-through withholding at the individual rate of 4.95 percent: 4.95 percent of $75,000 is $3,712.50 per partner, and four partners give $14,850. The payment is due no later than the due date of the return without regard to extensions.
- Replacement tax: 1.5 percent of $300,000 is $4,500, on the assumption that UT's Illinois net income for that tax equals $300,000, because the section 203(d) modifications were not read. This is UT's own liability, and no partner credit appears in the statutes read.
- D's own Illinois return shows a liability of $3,000. D's withholding credit is $3,712.50, so D's refund claim is $712.50, which D files because the withholding exceeds the liability. UT cannot claim it.
Totals. Alabama $10,000, paid by LT and credited through UT. Louisiana $750 of composite tax. Illinois $14,850 of withholding and $4,500 of replacement tax.
What the example shows. The same partnership has three instruments in three states, and a partner can recover an Alabama excess on the partner's own return. What it leaves out. The standard deduction and personal exemption, apportionment, estimated payments, penalties, the partner's Louisiana computation, and UT's federal treatment of the replacement tax.
Practice notes
Give the summary of state payments for each partner one column per instrument: withholding, composite tax and entity-level tax. Do not place a composite payment or an entity-level payment under withholding.
For an Alabama composite payment, decide the overpayment route, line 7a or line 7b, before the extended due date. After it the entity cannot ask for a refund and the member's own return carries it. Members whose own tax is below the composite amount file to recover the difference.
For an upper tier with an exempt or otherwise excluded partner, ask the Alabama Department of Revenue for indirect-owner approval at least 30 days before the original due date, with Form NRC-Exempt, Form PTE-R and the other forms the instructions name, so that the lower tier's composite payment does not overshoot.
Put the Alabama and Louisiana composite payments, the Illinois withholding and any elected entity-level tax on the extension calendar by their own due dates. An extension of time to file does not extend the time to pay in the states read. A separate article in this library covers extension payments in other states.
Note on each partner's Schedule K-1 the instrument and the payer, for example Alabama composite tax paid for the partner by the partnership or by a lower-tier partnership, Illinois pass-through withholding, or Connecticut entity tax and the partner's 87.5 percent credit share. Do not use the word withholding for the first.
Keep each Louisiana agreement on file and calendar its carry-forward. A partner without an agreement and without other Louisiana income is in the composite base and relieved of filing, and a partner with other Louisiana income files Form IT-540B and, on the instructions, is listed on Schedule A.
Check whether an Alabama lower tier has elected the entity-level tax before preparing a composite schedule, because on the Department's FAQ an electing entity files no composite return.
For a nonresident owner of a New York group return or estimated tax payment, send the credit question to the owner's home state, because Form IT-112-R is for New York residents.
G&G State Tax Group advises partnerships and their partners on whether a state payment is withholding, composite tax or an entity-level tax, on the overpayment and credit routes that follow, and on the partner filings each one requires, alongside its state and local tax practice.
This article states the law as of November 11, 2026
Statutes, rates, thresholds, and agency practice change, and a different set of facts can change the answer. Before acting on anything discussed above, contact G&G State Tax Group, or another state and local tax adviser, to confirm what has changed since this was written and how the rules apply to a specific situation.
This publication is informational in nature and is not, and should not be considered, legal, accounting, tax, or other professional advice for any person or situation. Correct application of tax law depends heavily on the facts and circumstances in each case, and G&G State Tax Group, LLC assumes no liability in connection with the use of this information, and is not obligated to inform any reader of changes in the law or other factors that could affect the information contained herein.
