Skip to main content
Direct +1 949.864.9199 Office +1 714.234.5538 info@gandgsalt.com
G&G State Tax Group

MultistateIncome and franchise tax

What does a corporate partner need from a partnership's state package, and what must the package carry for an upper tier whose factors all come from below?

The short answer

A corporate partner needs the partnership's factors in states that combine them and its state income in states that allocate it, so it should collect both. California (for most businesses), New York, Illinois and Kentucky apportion by one receipts factor, so the package supplies the partnership's receipts by state in dollars, at 100 percent and the partner's share, with the ownership chain; property and payroll still matter for tests such as California's doing-business thresholds. Arkansas, Louisiana and Oklahoma tax the corporate partner on its share of the state income the partnership computed. North Carolina's Department of Revenue has a corporate partner include its share of the partnership's sales when the partnership's income is apportionable; the state's franchise tax now rests on net worth. Michigan turns on partner control of the partnership. For an upper tier (a partnership owning another), Minnesota's minimum fee excludes a partner's share of lower-tier factors; Kentucky's entity tax includes lower-tier receipts and credits the lower tier's tax, and the $175 minimum still applies; a Michigan entity that made no flow-through entity tax election owes members its apportionment information; and New York's commuter mobility tax uses zone percentages that differ from the state allocation percentage.

Working through this on a live matter? Contact the firm

States that combine the partner's share with its own factors

A state treats a corporate partner's share of a partnership in one of two main ways, and Michigan and North Carolina mix them. In an aggregate state the partner adds its share of the partnership's factors to its own, so the partner needs the factors as dollar numerators and denominators. In an allocation state the partnership computes the state income, the partner's share is allocated to the state on the partner's own return, and the partnership's factors stay out of the partner's formula. A separate article in this library sets out the taxonomy of approaches for lower-tier partnerships, and another covers the roll-up of factors through tiers. This article takes the package a corporate partner needs and the items an upper tier must carry.

One receipts factor in four aggregate states. California, New York, Illinois and Kentucky each apportion by a single receipts factor for 2025 and 2026, with exceptions noted below.

  • California. Section 25128.7 of the Revenue and Taxation Code provides that, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2013, "all business income of an apportioning trade or business," other than "an apportioning trade or business described in subdivision (b) of Section 25128," is apportioned to California "by multiplying the business income by the sales factor." Subdivision (b) of section 25128 reaches a business that "derives more than 50 percent of its gross business receipts" from qualified business activities, and subdivision (c)(2) lists, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, only "An agricultural business activity." and "An extractive business activity." The three-factor formula therefore survives for those businesses and not for most corporate partners.
  • New York. Section 210-A(1) of the Tax Law provides that "Business income and capital shall be apportioned to the state by the apportionment factor," and that "The apportionment factor is a fraction, determined by including only those receipts" the section lists. The parts of the section read name no property or payroll factor.
  • Illinois. Section 304(h)(3) of the Illinois Income Tax Act (IITA) names, "for tax years ending on or after December 31, 2000, the sales factor." Subsection (a) of the same section still refers to "weighting their property, payroll, and sales factors as provided in subsection (h)" for the formula. The section was read at a mirror of the 2023 compilation, because the Illinois General Assembly's hosts refuse automated reads.
  • Kentucky. Section 141.120(9) of the Kentucky Revised Statutes (KRS) sets a fraction "the numerator of which is the total receipts of the taxpayer in this state during the taxable year" over a denominator "the denominator of which is the total receipts of the taxpayer everywhere during the taxable year," and the subsection "applies to taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2018."

The package consequence holds for all four: the partner needs the partnership's receipts in dollars, by state, at 100 percent, with the ownership chain. Percentages cannot be rebuilt into a numerator and a denominator, and a figure given only at the partner's share cannot be checked against the partnership's own return.

Where property and payroll still matter. California's doing-business test counts the partner's share. Section 23101(b)(3) treats a taxpayer as doing business if its California property exceeds "the lesser of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or 25 percent of the taxpayer's total" property, subdivision (c) provides that the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) "shall annually revise the amounts in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4)," and subdivision (d) provides that the taxpayer's sales, property and payroll "include the taxpayer's pro rata or distributive share of pass-through entities." The FTB's doing-business page, last updated November 7, 2025, lists the 2025 figures as sales of $757,070, real and tangible personal property of $75,707 and payroll compensation of $75,707, against $735,019, $73,502 and $73,502 for 2024, and says the owner includes its distributive share of the property, payroll and sales of pass-through entities. No 2026 row was posted when the page was read. The 2025 property test is therefore the lesser of $75,707 or 25 percent of total property. California values owned property at original cost: "Property owned by the taxpayer is valued at its original cost." Rented property is "valued at eight times the net annual rental rate." Property and payroll also stay in the formula of a business described in section 25128(b). The other named uses are Kentucky's factor-furnishing statute and New York's commuter district surcharge, taken up below.

California: profits interest, unity and the tier sentence. California's partnership regulation, title 18 of the California Code of Regulations, section 25137-1, combines factors for a partner whose activities and the partnership's activities are unitary "disregarding ownership requirements." Subdivision (a) extends the rule to tiers: "The same principle applies when a taxpayer has an interest in a partnership that itself owns an interest, directly or indirectly, in one or more other partnerships." Under subdivision (f)(3), "The partnership's sales which give rise to business income, shall be included in the denominator" of the partner's sales factor, and under (f)(4) the interest is determined "by reference to its interest in profits of the partnership." The regulation was read at a mirror of the official text. It also provides that a partnership that is not unitary with the partner is "another trade or business of the taxpayer," apportioned on the partnership's own factors. The regulation states no formula for carrying a profits interest through a tier in the parts read. This article multiplies the interests at each link, so 30 percent of a 50 percent interest is 15 percent; that is an application of subdivisions (a) and (f)(4), and the example in this article rests on it. On unity, the FTB's partner instructions for Schedule K-1 (565) say "The final determination of unity is made at the partner level," while the regulation tests unity "disregarding ownership requirements." The two fit together on this reading: the regulation sets the test without regard to ownership, and the instructions place the final determination with the partner, so the partnership supplies the data and the partner decides.

Table 2 of Schedule K-1 (565) carries the data. According to the 2025 instructions, "The partner's share of the partnership's business income is entered on Table 2, Part A," and "The partner's share of the partnership's property, payroll, and sales factors is in Table 2, Part C." The instructions add: "Partners will use Table 2, Part C to determine if they meet threshold amounts of California property, payroll and sales." The description of Part B as the partner's share of nonbusiness income from real and tangible property, and the instruction that the partnership complete only Part C for a partner that is not unitary with it, are carried from an earlier reading of the 2024 and 2025 editions and were not re-read.

New York: the aggregate method, eight presumptions and the capital interest. Section 9-2.2(a) of title 20 of the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations (NYCRR) provides that a corporation "must use the aggregate method" when it has access to the partnership's information. Access is presumed when any one of eight conditions is met. The corporation is conducting a unitary business with the partnership; is a general partner or, for a limited liability company (LLC), a managing member; has a 5 percent or greater interest; has reported information from the partnership on the aggregate method in a prior year; holds an interest that is more than half of its total assets; has a basis in the interest above $5,000,000 under section 705 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) on a date the regulation specifies; has a member of its affiliated or combined group that holds the information; or "is claiming a tax credit based upon the activities of the partnership" or a credit computed at the partnership level that flows through to the corporation. A corporation that meets none of them and certifies the facts to the Commissioner may use the entity method. For a tiered structure the method applies "at each tier." The regulation's history line shows adoption in the New York State Register of December 27, 2023, effective that day. The New York regulations cited in this article were read at a mirror of the official text.

The Department of Taxation and Finance's 2025 instructions for Form IT-204-CP, "New York Corporate Partner's Schedule K-1," list seven conditions in the extract read, and the credit condition was not among them. The regulation controls. The IT-204-CP instructions direct the partnership to submit a Form IT-204-CP for each corporate partner that is taxable under Article 9-A. For a partner that is itself a partnership or an LLC, the partnership provides both Forms IT-204-IP and IT-204-CP to that partner.

The measure of the interest differs from California's. Section 9-2.3(a)(2) provides that the corporation's proportionate part "is determined in accordance with the corporation's capital interest in the partnership." If the capital interest "does not properly reflect" the corporation's share of business income, investment income and other exempt income, the proportionate part is "determined using the percentage resulting from the manner in which the partners divide the partnership's profits in a profit year and losses in a loss year." Section 9-2.3(f) provides: "A corporation must include its distributive share of the partnership's business receipts when computing its BAF," the business apportionment factor. The same lower tier can therefore be scaled at one percentage in California and another in New York, and the package states the interest measure with each figure.

Illinois: the attached schedule of factors. The Illinois Department of Revenue's instructions for Schedule K-1-P(1) (revision R-12/25) have the partnership enter "see attached schedule of factors" on Line 4 of Step 1 for a unitary partner and attach a schedule showing the partner's share of the partnership's apportionment factors. The instructions' further detail on what the schedule covers, namely the Illinois and everywhere amounts, the business income the partnership earns directly and the factors and income passed up from other unitary partnerships, is carried from an earlier reading and was not re-read. The instructions also tell a partner that is itself a pass-through entity to complete a pro forma Schedule K-1-P, and they refer the partner to 86 Ill. Adm. Code Section 100.3380(d), which this article did not read, because the Illinois Joint Committee on Administrative Rules' host refuses automated reads.

A separate article in this library states the condition that governs when factors combine at all: for taxable years ending on or after December 31, 2017, a partner that apportions by a different formula under IITA section 304 than the partnership does not combine the partnership's factors with its own, so unity alone is not enough (86 Ill. Adm. Code 100.3380(d)(2)(C)(i), as that article cites it). The package should say which formula the partnership used.

Kentucky: the statute sends each factor to each owner. KRS 141.206(10)(a) provides that a pass-through entity doing business in Kentucky and elsewhere "shall compute and furnish to each partner, member, or shareholder the numerator and denominator" "of each factor." Under (10)(b) a pass-through entity that is a partner or member of another is "deemed to own the pro rata share of the property owned or leased" by the other and "shall also include its pro rata share of the other pass-through entity's payroll and sales." Under (10)(c) the rule "shall extend to each level of multiple-tiered pass-through entities." The page read is the 2025 statutes at a mirror. A separate article in this library covers the Kentucky statute for upper-tier apportionment in more detail.

States that tax the partner on allocated income

Arkansas, Louisiana and Oklahoma keep the partnership's factors out of the corporate partner's formula and tax the partner on the share of state income the partnership computed. In these three states the package needs the state-source income, not the factors. They are allocation states and not separate accounting states: Arkansas names separate accounting only as an alternative method when apportionment does not fairly represent the partnership's activity in the state.

Arkansas. Section 26-51-802(c) of the Arkansas Code, read at a mirror of the 2025 code, provides in (c)(1) that "A partnership that files an Arkansas partnership return" with income from inside and outside Arkansas apportions it under the Uniform Division of Income for Tax Purposes Act. Under (c)(2), "all partnership income from activities within this state shall be allocated to this state" by each partner, subject to section 26-51-202(e), as reported on the Arkansas partnership return. Under (c)(3), separate accounting, a change of factors or another method is available only if apportionment does not fairly reflect the partnership's Arkansas business activity; the partnership may petition for it or the Secretary of the Department of Finance and Administration may require it.

The Department's rule, Rule 1.26-51-802(b), read at a mirror, states that a taxpayer with an interest in a partnership with Arkansas income "must directly allocate the partnership's Arkansas income to Arkansas" "rather than include partnership income and apportionment factors in the taxpayer's" "apportionment formula." It also backs the partnership's income out of the apportionable base: "If the taxpayer's operations are multistate, all partnership income must be deducted on Schedule A," "Part A, 'Deduct Adjustments'," and "The partnership's Arkansas income should then be entered on Schedule A, Part C," "'Direct Income Allocated To Arkansas' line of Form AR1100CT." The rule's example takes a partnership with total income of $100,000, of which $50,000 is directly allocated to Arkansas, and gives a 10 percent corporate partner $5,000 and a 90 percent corporate partner $45,000. The corporate partner therefore needs the partnership's total income, to back it out, and the Arkansas-allocated share, to add back. The Arkansas Schedule K-1 reports the owner's share of each item apportioned to Arkansas in the 2021 edition of the instructions, the latest read; the 2025 edition was not read.

Louisiana. Section 47:287.93(A)(5) of the Louisiana Revised Statutes provides: "For purposes of this Part only, estates, trusts, and partnerships having a corporation as a member or beneficiary shall compute, allocate, and apportion their income or loss within and without this state in accordance with the processes and formulas prescribed by this Part, and the share of any corporation member or beneficiary in the net income or loss from sources in this state so computed shall be allocated to this state in the return of such corporation." Section 47:287.92(B)(3) lists "Income from estates, trusts, and partnerships." among the items of allocable income. The Department of Revenue's instructions for Form IT-565 (tax year 2025) follow the statute: "Partnerships having a corporation as a partner must allocate and apportion their income" under the corporate formulas, the corporate partner's Louisiana share "must be allocated to Louisiana in the return of the corporate partner," and the instructions note that "a single revenue ratio is used to apportion income" except for certain oil and gas businesses. Schedule H of the form reconciles federal net income to Louisiana net income, so the partnership starts from its federal figures. The corporate partner reports the share on its own return; the instructions for Form CIFT-620 add to allocable income, at Schedule D, line 27, "the share of any corporate member or beneficiary in the net income from sources in this state." The instructions direct a corporation to report partnership income on its own corporation return, and they have the partnership give each partner a Schedule K-1 and other documentation that substantiates the partner's share of any credit passed down from the entity.

Oklahoma. The Oklahoma Tax Commission's rule at Okla. Admin. Code section 710:50-17-51(15), read at a mirror, provides that "Partnership income or loss shall be separately allocated," and cites section 2358(A)(4) of title 68 of the Oklahoma Statutes (68 O.S.); the Oklahoma share of the income "shall be allocated to Oklahoma." The rule on partnership returns, section 710:50-19-1, provides in (a)(1) that "The partnership shall also furnish a detailed schedule stating the amount of income distributable" to each partner from Oklahoma sources, and (a)(4)(B) calls for a computation of "each nonresident corporate, S corp or partnership partner's share of Oklahoma distributive" income. The object is the partner's share of Oklahoma income, not the partnership's factors, and the corporate partner's package is that schedule. Section 2358 of title 68 was not re-read for this article; the rule's citation is the source for the separate-allocation reading.

Michigan: control decides which factor applies

Michigan applies a different apportionment rule to a corporate partner depending on whether it controls the partnership. Under section 661(2) of the Michigan Compiled Laws (MCL), business income "shall be apportioned to this state by multiplying the tax base by the sales factor," and for "a direct, or indirect through 1 or more other flow-through entities, ownership interest," the attributable business income is apportioned using an apportionment factor determined under section 663 on the entity's business activity, "unless the flow-through entity is unitary with the taxpayer." The indirect-ownership words reach a corporate partner that holds a lower tier through an upper tier.

Section 663(1) defines the unitary case. "A flow-through entity is unitary with a taxpayer when that taxpayer owns or controls" "more than 50% of the ownership interests with voting rights," or interests "that confer comparable rights to voting rights of the flow-through entity," and the entity "has business activities or operations which result in a flow of value between the taxpayer and the flow-through entity, or between the flow-through entity and another flow-through entity unitary with the taxpayer," or "has business activities or operations that are integrated with, are dependent upon, or contribute to each other." For a unitary entity the numerator of a taxpayer "shall include its proportionate share of the total sales in this state," and under section 663(2) intercompany sales "shall, to the extent of the taxpayer's interest in the flow-through entity, be eliminated." The Department of Treasury's answer in its Corporate Income Tax frequently asked questions puts the two cases in one line each: a non-unitary taxpayer's attributable income "is apportioned to Michigan using the flow-through entity's sales factor," and a unitary taxpayer includes "the taxpayer's proportionate share of the flow-through entity's Michigan and total sales." The page shows no date.

The package therefore carries the entity's own Michigan sales factor for every corporate partner, and Michigan and total sales dollars for any partner that could pass the control test. A corporate partner with a 12 percent indirect interest, as in the example below, is far from the control line and uses the entity's factor.

North Carolina: sales for the income tax, net worth for the franchise tax

North Carolina asks for sales on the corporate income tax and for the partner's own balance sheet on the franchise tax. The North Carolina Department of Revenue has two pronouncements on the corporate income tax.

Corporate income tax. Directive PD-14-2, dated October 10, 2014 and "Effective for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2014," directs that the "portion of the corporate or nonresident individual partners' shares" be determined "by using the allocation and apportionment provisions in G.S. 105-130.4," a reference to the North Carolina General Statutes (G.S.). The partnership files Form D-403 and uses Form NC K-1 "to provide information to its partners." The Department's Corporate Income, Franchise, and Insurance Tax Bulletin (the edition read is revised February 2026), in part II.Q, "Partnership and the Corporate Partner (17 NCAC 05C.1700)," states: "Income from unrelated business activities that make up a discrete business enterprise is nonapportionable." It also states: "When classified as apportionable income, the corporate partner's apportionment factors includes its proportionate share of the partnership's sales." A share classified as nonapportionable "is included in the corporate partner's net taxable income and allocated in accordance with the allocation provisions of" G.S. 105-130.4. The package for North Carolina therefore carries the partnership's North Carolina and everywhere sales at the partner's share, as well as the apportioned share on the Form NC K-1.

The rule the bulletin cites, 17 NCAC 05C .1702 (title 17 of the North Carolina Administrative Code), was not re-read for this article. It is reported to be in a readoption cycle, and its property and payroll words are reported to predate the single sales factor. The bulletin states what the Department applies, which is sales, and the rule's status is open (see What remains open).

Franchise tax. For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2023, "A corporation's tax base is the proportion of its net worth" (G.S. 105-122(d)). Net worth is measured from "total assets without regard to the deduction for accumulated depreciation," and subsection (c1) begins: "A corporation that is doing business in this State and in one or more other states must apportion" the corporation's net worth to the state. The balance of subsection (c1) was not re-read. The Department's page on the 2021 law changes reports that Session Law (S.L.) 2021-180, section 42.3(a), is "eliminating the fifty-five percent (55%) of appraised value of North Carolina property tax base," effective for "taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2023." The appraised-value-of-property alternative is gone, so property detail no longer drives the base.

Debt detail still matters in two cases. First, subdivision (b)(2) of section 105-122 adds back indebtedness owed to a parent, subsidiary, affiliate or noncorporate entity in which the corporation or its affiliated group "owns directly or indirectly more than fifty percent (50%) of the capital interest," subject to an exception for qualified interest expense that this article did not re-read. The definitions are in subsection (b1). Capital interest is "The right under an entity's governing law to receive a percentage of the entity's assets" "upon dissolution after payments to creditors." Indebtedness covers loans, credits, goods, supplies and other capital furnished by those related persons, other than indebtedness endorsed, guaranteed or otherwise supported by one of the corporations. A noncorporate entity is "A person that is neither a human being nor a corporation."

Second, G.S. 105-114.1(b) has a corporation or affiliated group that owns more than 50 percent of the capital interests in a noncorporate limited liability company include "the same percentage of the noncorporate limited liability company's net worth" in its base. Its investment in the company then "is not included" under subsection (d), and subsection (f) turns the rule off if the company's total book value of assets "never exceeded" $150,000. The inclusion rule in (b) names only a noncorporate limited liability company, while (c)(2) treats "any noncorporate entity other than a partnership, estate, or trust" as a partnership, so whether the rule reaches a limited partnership is open.

A corporate partner at or below the 50 percent line, such as the 15 percent indirect holder in the example below, keeps its investment in its own net worth, because subsection (d) removes the investment only when the inclusion rule applies. The package needs the LLC's net worth only for a partner or group above that line.

The creditor-side deduction is repealed. Section 8.7 of S.L. 2026-31 (Senate Bill 595), ratified June 25, 2026 and approved July 2, 2026, repeals G.S. 105-122(b)(2a). That subdivision opened: "If the creditor corporation is taxable under this Article, the creditor corporation may deduct" an amount of related-party indebtedness owed to it, a deduction the act removes. The rest of the subdivision's wording was not re-read. Section 8.7(b) provides: "This section is effective retroactively for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2021" "and applicable to the calculation of franchise tax reported on the 2020 and later corporate income tax returns." The statute page now shows subdivision (2a) as "Repealed by Session Laws 2026-31, s. 8.7(a), effective retroactively for taxable years beginning" "on or after January 1, 2021." The debtor-side add-back in (b)(2) remains. The act repeals a deduction; it does not add one.

What the package carries, by method

The package that serves a corporate partner in one state fails it in another, so the contents follow the state's method.

For the aggregate states, the partner needs the partnership's receipts by state in dollars: the numerator and the partnership's own denominator, at 100 percent and at the partner's share, with the interest measure stated. California measures the interest by profits and New York by the capital interest first, so one lower tier can carry two percentages. The package also carries the year end of each tier, the partnership's federal taxable income with the state modifications, and each lower tier's data at the same level. It adds property and payroll only where a use calls for them: a doing-business threshold, a business described in section 25128(b), Kentucky's factor statute, or the New York commuter district surcharge.

The surcharge is a corporate tax and separate from the individual tax discussed below. For the surcharge, subdivision (g) of 20 NYCRR section 9-2.3 has the corporation take account of "its distributive share of the partnership's receipts and payroll," and the receipts factor is "divided by the corporation's New York receipts." The receipts factor of the surcharge therefore has a New York denominator.

For the allocation states, the partner needs the state-source income the partnership computed. Arkansas also needs the partnership's total income, to back the partnership out of the apportionable base; Oklahoma needs the partnership's schedule of the income distributable to each partner from Oklahoma sources; Louisiana needs the Louisiana share and documentation for any credit passed through.

For Michigan and North Carolina, the package follows the control and sales rules above. Michigan needs the entity's own sales factor and, for a partner that could pass the control test, Michigan and total sales. North Carolina needs the partnership's North Carolina and everywhere sales at the partner's share, the apportioned share on the Form NC K-1, and net worth only for an LLC held above 50 percent.

A state Schedule K-1 is needed only where the state's form carries items the partner cannot derive. Minnesota's Schedule KPC carries the amount on line 3, labeled "Partnership's minimum fee," the "Pro Rata Share of MN Source Gross Income" on line 36, and the Minnesota and everywhere factor shares under the heading "Apportionment Information (partner's share)." Kentucky's Schedule K-1 carries the nonrefundable credit that Form PTE, Part II, line 4 uses. California's carries Table 2. New York's Form IT-204-CP is the "New York Corporate Partner's Schedule K-1," and a partner that is itself a partnership or LLC receives both Forms IT-204-IP and IT-204-CP. A unitary partner that already holds the factors and the federal income still lacks those items.

A reconciliation to federal Schedule K serves the recipient without exposing the underlying return. Louisiana's own Schedule H reconciles federal net income, from Form 1065, to Louisiana net income. No state in the sources read requires a particular reconciliation format, so a schedule that ties each state's figures to the federal Schedule K lines, with modifications shown separately, is a practice recommendation and not a state requirement.

State by state, in one list

  • California. A unitary partner combines the partnership's sales according to its profits interest; sales factor for most businesses. The package carries Table 2 of Schedule K-1 (565), sales in dollars, and property at cost and payroll for the doing-business thresholds. Upper-tier item: the thresholds include the partner's share of pass-through amounts.
  • New York. Aggregate method when access exists or is presumed; business apportionment factor built from receipts. The package carries Form IT-204-CP and lower-tier data at each tier. Upper-tier items: IT-204-CP with IT-204-IP for a partner that is a pass-through, and zone percentages for the individual commuter tax.
  • Illinois. Aggregate for a unitary partner using the same formula; sales factor. The package carries the attached schedule of factors and the business income earned directly. Upper-tier item: a pro forma Schedule K-1-P from a partner that is itself a pass-through.
  • Kentucky. Aggregate by statute at every tier; total receipts. The package carries the numerator and denominator of each factor to each owner. Upper-tier items: the entity tax counts lower-tier receipts, credits lower-tier tax, and keeps a $175 floor.
  • Michigan. Over 50 percent control plus a flow of value or integration combines sales; otherwise the entity's own sales factor. The package carries the entity's Michigan sales factor in any reasonable form. Upper-tier item: a non-electing entity still furnishes the member information.
  • Minnesota. Schedule KPC carries the factor shares; a partner that is not unitary with the partnership uses only the partnership's factors. Upper-tier item: the minimum fee excludes a partner's share of lower-tier factors.
  • North Carolina. The Department has the corporate partner include its share of the partnership's sales when apportionable; the franchise tax rests on the partner's net worth. Upper-tier items: inclusion of a controlled LLC's net worth above 50 percent, and the repeal of the creditor-side deduction.
  • Arkansas. Allocation of Arkansas income; the partnership's income is backed out of the partner's base. The package carries the Arkansas-apportioned share and the partnership's total income.
  • Louisiana. The corporate partner's Louisiana share is allocated on its own return. The package carries that share and credit documentation.
  • Oklahoma. Separate allocation of the Oklahoma share. The package carries the schedule of income distributable to each partner from Oklahoma sources.

Arkansas, Louisiana and Oklahoma have no mandatory fee, credit or information item for an upper tier in the sources read here, and each state's elective entity-level tax is outside this article.

Minnesota: the minimum fee stays at the lower tier

Minnesota imposes a minimum fee on "a partnership required to file a return under section 289A.12, subdivision 3" (Minn. Stat. 290.0922, subd. 1(b)). The 2025 instructions for Form M3 state when the fee applies: "the sum of its Minnesota source property, payroll and sales or receipts is at least $1,250,000." Schedule M3A prices the property at original cost (line 1 reads "owned at original cost"), takes payroll "including guaranteed payments to partners," adds sales "including rents received," and sets the fee from a table on line 9. There is no fee below that sum. The 2025 table reads $260 from $1,250,000 to $2,509,999, $750 from $2,510,000 to $12,539,999, and $2,510 from $12,540,000 to $25,069,999; higher rows follow.

The statute excludes a partner's share of lower-tier factors. Subdivision 4 of section 290.0922 provides: "For the purposes of this section, a partner's pro rata share of a partnership's property, payroll, and sales or receipts is not included in the property, payroll, and sales or receipts of the partner." The sentence has no condition. An upper-tier partnership is a partner of the lower tier in the ordinary sense, so on the statute its share of the lower tier's factors stays outside its own fee base, and the lower tier pays on its own factors.

The form subtracts less than the statute does. Line 7 of Schedule M3A is labeled "Adjustments (see instructions, page 9)." The instructions for line 7 tell the filer to subtract amounts included on lines 3 and 5 that represent the filer's share of factors passed through from other partnerships. Line 3 holds property and capitalized rents, and line 5 holds sales. Line 4 holds payroll, and the line 7 instruction as read names neither line 4 nor payroll. On the form's literal reading, an upper tier's share of lower-tier payroll stays in its fee base; on the statute it does not. The statute controls. A filer who follows the form's words would report the payroll. The difference matters only when pass-through payroll is large: a payroll share that alone reaches $1,250,000 would produce a fee on the literal reading and none on the statute. The instructions say: "Enclose a schedule showing the computation and pass-through information." The package should carry the lower tier's three factors separately, at 100 percent and at the upper tier's share.

The pass-through reaches the corporate partner on Schedule KPC. The instructions have the partnership provide Schedule KPC to each corporate and partnership partner. The schedule carries the amount on line 3 labeled "Partnership's minimum fee" and the partner's share of the Minnesota and everywhere factors. A partner that is not unitary with the partnership uses only the partnership's factors for its share: "If the partner is not unitary with the partnership, it will use only these factors." The sentence implies that a unitary partner combines the shares with its own, but the lines read do not say so. For a partnership partner the instructions begin: "Partnership Partners: When completing Form M3 and Schedules KPI and KPC, include any amounts." The instructions carry draft notations on some pages (October 2 and October 7, 2025), and the final edition of the instructions should be confirmed before the package is relied on.

Kentucky: the entity tax counts lower-tier receipts and credits lower-tier tax

Kentucky taxes a limited liability pass-through entity under KRS 141.0401, and the tax follows the entity up through its tiers. The statute page shows "Effective: July 15, 2026" and the history line "Amended 2026 Ky. Acts ch. 161, sec. 51, effective July 15, 2026." The 2026 amendment is reported to have changed only subsection (6), the list of exempt entities, with a related cross-reference in KRS 141.206(4)(a); the act's own text was not re-read.

The base counts lower-tier receipts. Subsection (1)(a) defines Kentucky gross receipts to include "the proportionate share of Kentucky gross receipts of all wholly or partially owned" lower-tier entities, "including all layers of a multi-layered" structure. Subsection (1)(b) defines gross receipts from all sources as an amount equal to "the computation of the denominator of the apportionment fraction under KRS 141.120," and the sales-factor rules, and it "includes the proportionate share of gross receipts from all sources of all wholly or partially owned limited liability pass-through entities, including all layers." An upper tier's all-source receipts therefore include its share of every lower tier's.

The tax is the lesser of two computations. Under subsection (2)(b), "The limited liability entity tax shall be the lesser of subparagraph 1. or 2. of this paragraph." One computation is "seventy-five cents ($0.75) per one hundred dollars ($100)" of the entity's Kentucky gross profits, and the other is "nine and one-half cents ($0.095) per one hundred dollars ($100)" of Kentucky gross receipts. In the band of all-source receipts "greater than three million dollars ($3,000,000) but less than six million dollars ($6,000,000)," the receipts computation is "reduced by an amount equal to two thousand eight hundred fifty dollars ($2,850)" and the $0.75 computation is "reduced by an amount equal to twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars ($22,500)." At receipts of $6,000,000 or more the page read for this article applies the rate without a reduction, and the example below does the same.

A credit offsets the double count, and a floor survives it. Subsection (2)(c) gives the upper tier a credit for its proportionate share of the lower tier's calculated tax after that tax "has been reduced by the minimum tax," and "The credit at each layer shall include the credit from each lower layer." Subsection (2)(a) sets the minimum at "one hundred seventy-five dollars ($175), regardless of the application of any tax credits." The Department's Form PTE agrees. In the 2024 instructions, Part II, line 6 reads: "Enter the greater of Line 3 less Lines 4 and 5, or $175 minimum." The upper tier's tax after the lower-tier credit is therefore never below $175. The instructions for Part II, line 4 call for the nonrefundable credit from the entity's Kentucky Schedules K-1, and they state that copies of those schedules "must be attached to the tax return in order to claim the credit." The lines read do not provide a refund or carryforward of a (2)(c) credit that exceeds the tax it offsets.

Owners receive a nonrefundable credit that runs through the layers. Under subsection (3)(b), the credit allowed to members, shareholders or partners "shall be the members', shareholders', or partners' proportionate share of the tax calculated under subsection (2) of this section for the current year after subtraction of any credits identified in KRS 141.0205, as determined after the amount of tax paid has been reduced by the minimum tax of one hundred seventy-five dollars ($175)." It is applied to income tax "assessed on income from the limited liability pass-through entity," and "Any remaining credit from the limited liability passthrough entity shall be disallowed." Subsection (8) provides that the credit "shall flow through multiple layers of limited liability pass-through entities and shall be claimed by the taxpayer who ultimately pays the tax on the income of the limited liability pass-through entity."

The Department's method for the credit an upper tier passes on. On Schedule K, Section B, line 5 of the 2024 instructions, the line asks for the entity's "limited liability entity tax (LLET) nonrefundable credit" from page 3, Part II, and the instruction adds a fragment reading "the total of Lines 4 and 6, less $175." The two fragments were returned separately, and this article reads them together as the Department's method: the credit an upper tier passes to its owners is the credit it received on line 4, plus its own tax after credits and the minimum on line 6, less $175. The statute's words in (3)(b) support that method, and the printed instruction should be confirmed before it is quoted.

The statute speaks of limited liability pass-through entities. The tax, the (2)(c) credit and the owner credits are all framed in those words, and the credit chain is traced through entities of that kind. The statutory definition (KRS 141.010) was not re-read, and whether a general partnership tier breaks the chain is open.

The factor-furnishing statute is a separate duty. KRS 141.206(10)(a) requires a pass-through entity doing business in Kentucky and elsewhere to furnish each owner the numerator and denominator of each factor (see the aggregate section above), and a separate article in this library covers that statute for upper-tier apportionment in more detail. The entity tax in this section is a different charge.

Michigan: an entity that made no election still furnishes the information

A nonresident partner needs the entity's Michigan information to compute its Michigan tax. MCL 206.110(2)(b) reaches income "As a distributive share of the net profits of a business, profession, enterprise," "as the result of work done, services rendered, or other business activities" "conducted in this state, except as allocated to another state." The quoted language does not use the word partnership, and the duty to furnish the information is in a different section.

The furnishing duty binds an entity that did not elect. The elective flow-through entity tax sits in Part 8 of the Michigan income tax statute. Section 809(3) defines a taxpayer for that part as a flow-through entity "that elects pursuant to section 813" "to be subject to the tax under this part." An entity that did not elect is not a taxpayer under Part 8. Section 839(1) nevertheless reaches it: "A taxpayer or a flow-through entity that did not make the election under section 813 shall" provide the items its paragraphs (a) through (d) list. They include "Information regarding the allocation and apportionment of the business income," "The member's allocable share of the reporting flow-through entity's taxes," and "The member's allocable share of the reporting flow-through entity's refund," together with a list that begins with "the member's share of the tax imposed under this part on the taxpayer for the tax year." Section 839 was added by 2021 Act 135, with an immediate effective date of December 21, 2021, and amended by 2024 Act 216, effective April 2, 2025.

The Department of Treasury allows any reasonable form. In its guidance on implementing the flow-through entity tax, Treasury states that "there are no statutory requirements related to the form by which this information must be" provided, and that the information may be furnished "in any reasonable manner, including as separate statements or as notes." It adds that "these specific reporting requirements apply to both electing and non-electing flow-through entities." The page shows no date and carries a note on 2021, so it may predate the 2024 amendment of section 839, effective April 2, 2025. The page does not say whether the amendment changed that.

Tiers. On the statute's words, an upper tier that is a flow-through entity with members and that made no election owes its own members the same items. The Treasury guidance on passing items from lower tiers up to ultimate members was not re-read. A publicly traded partnership is outside the definition: section 805(3) provides that "Flow-through entity does not include a publicly traded partnership," and the section was amended by 2025 Public Act 24, immediately effective on October 7, 2025.

What the partner does with it. A nonresident individual partner uses the apportionment information on the individual return, and a corporate partner uses it under the control rules in the section above. No penalty for failing to furnish the section 839(1) items was located.

New York: the commuter tax zone percentages are not the state allocation percentage

An individual partner's Metropolitan Commuter Transportation Mobility Tax (MCTMT) is computed on net earnings from self-employment attributable to the Metropolitan Commuter Transportation District (MCTD), and the zone percentages the partnership reports for that tax differ from the percentage it uses for state allocation.

The tax. Section 800 of the Tax Law defines two zones. Zone one is "comprised of the counties of Bronx, Kings, New York, Queens, and Richmond." Zone two is "comprised of the counties of Dutchess, Nassau, Orange, Putnam, Rockland, Suffolk and Westchester." Net earnings from self-employment have "the same meaning as in section 1402" of the IRC, and subdivision (e) provides that "an individual shall not be considered a limited partner" if the individual takes part in management or operations "such that the individual is not a passive investor." For years before 2026, section 801(a)(2) applies zone rates of 0.60 percent (zone one) and 0.34 percent (zone two) "of the net earnings from self-employment" attributable to the district if those earnings "exceed fifty thousand dollars for the tax year." For calendar years beginning in 2026, section 801(a)(3) states the threshold as "exceed one hundred fifty thousand dollars," with the same rates. The rate text applies to "the net earnings from self-employment," not to the excess over the threshold. Section 801(b)(1) sends the individual to allocation and apportionment "in the manner required for allocation and apportionment of income under article twenty-two." The Department's regulation on a partnership of which a nonresident individual is a member, 20 NYCRR section 132.15, takes in subdivision (c) "the average of the percentages described in subdivisions (d) through (f)," and subdivision (d) is the property percentage. The sections read are the May 16, 2025 revision.

The partnership reports two different percentages. On Form IT-204, lines 116b and 116c carry the zone percentages. The 2025 instructions provide that a partnership doing business only in zone one enters 100 percent on line 116b, and one doing business only in zone two enters 100 percent on line 116c. A partnership that "maintains separate books and records and they reflect the self-employment income" in a zone enters "on this line the percentage of net earnings from self-employment" "allocated to MCTD Zone 1." Otherwise the instructions tell the partnership to use "the worksheet below," transferring "the amounts in Section 10, Part 2, column A, of Form IT-204" to the worksheet. Line 8 of the worksheet has the partnership "divide total percentages on line 7 by three or by actual number of percentages if less than three," so the zone percentage is an average of property, payroll and gross income percentages. Line 126, by contrast, is the business allocation percentage, and the instructions for Form IT-204-IP have the partnership take its business allocation percentage from Form IT-204, line 126.

The partnership hands the zone percentages to the individual on Form IT-204-IP, lines 29b and 29c. Line 29b has the partnership enter the zone one allocation percentage it reported on Form IT-204. The instructions that were read do not restate how the individual should use the figure; the mechanism is the Department's method for a partner whose books do not isolate zone earnings.

The two percentages differ. On the forms as read, the business allocation percentage divides New York amounts by everywhere amounts, and the zone percentage divides zone amounts by everywhere amounts, using the same three factors in each case. A zone is part of New York, so the zone percentage can never exceed the business allocation percentage. A partner who is handed the line 126 percentage for the footnote overstates the district earnings, and a zone line left at zero understates them. The two zones are separate percentages, and the zone two percentage is zero for a partnership with no activity there. The instruction text for line 126 itself was not re-read.

An upper tier is an open point. No source read states how an upper tier with no operations of its own computes lines 116b and 116c, and whether those lines can carry a lower tier's percentages is open.

The corporate partner's surcharge is a different tax. The surcharge under Tax Law section 209-B is measured on the corporate partner's share of district property, receipts and payroll, as described in the package section above, and it has no connection to the individual tax in this section.

Cost, adjusted basis and book value across tiers

The ways the states measure property differ, and for the general formula of California, New York, Illinois and Kentucky they do not enter a corporate partner's formula for 2025 and 2026, because each of those states apportions by receipts. They still matter where property is used.

  • California values owned property at original cost: "Property owned by the taxpayer is valued at its original cost." The measure serves the doing-business thresholds and a business described in section 25128(b). Original cost does not reflect accumulated depreciation.
  • Minnesota prices owned property on Schedule M3A at original cost (line 1 reads "owned at original cost").
  • New York, for the individual commuter tax, speaks in 20 NYCRR section 132.15(d)(1) of "the average of the values, at the beginning and end of the taxable year," and for rented property uses "the gross rents payable during the taxable year by eight." The measure that Form IT-204 uses for owned property was not re-read.
  • North Carolina starts the franchise tax base from "total assets without regard to the deduction for accumulated depreciation," which is a balance-sheet measure and not a cost or basis measure.
  • Kentucky keeps a property question only for the factor-furnishing statute, KRS 141.206(10), and for any return line that still asks for property.

A lower tier's property schedule is usable by an upper tier only if it states which measure it uses. A mix of cost, adjusted basis and book value across tiers produces a figure that matches no state's definition, and the cure is to ask each lower tier for cost and for adjusted basis separately.

Where the law moved

  • North Carolina. The franchise tax base rests on net worth for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2023, after S.L. 2021-180, section 42.3(a), eliminated the appraised-value alternative. S.L. 2026-31, section 8.7, ratified June 25, 2026 and approved July 2, 2026, repealed the creditor-side deduction in G.S. 105-122(b)(2a) retroactively for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2021. The appraised-value base is no longer current law, and the creditor-side deduction is repealed, with no new deduction added by the act.
  • New York. The corporate partner regulation, 20 NYCRR section 9-2.2, shows adoption in the State Register of December 27, 2023, effective that day. For the individual commuter tax, section 801(a)(2) governs years before 2026 with a $50,000 threshold, and section 801(a)(3) governs calendar years beginning on or after January 1, 2026 with a $150,000 threshold. The first form year in which Form IT-204-IP carried lines 29b and 29c is not established, so no start date for the zone lines is stated.
  • California. Section 25128(c)(2), as read, confines the three-factor formula to agricultural and extractive business activities for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025. The act that made the change was not re-read.
  • Kentucky. KRS 141.0401 was last amended by 2026 Ky. Acts ch. 161, section 51, effective July 15, 2026. The entity return in the instructions read is Form PTE for tax year 2024.
  • Michigan. MCL 206.839 was added by 2021 Act 135 and amended by 2024 Act 216, effective April 2, 2025. MCL 206.805(3) was amended by 2025 Public Act 24, effective October 7, 2025.
  • Minnesota. The fee is indexed, and the 2025 threshold is $1,250,000. The history line of section 290.0922 is reported to show a 2024 amendment adding cooperatives to the exempt list, effective August 1, 2027, and two 2026 amendments whose content was not read.

What remains open

  1. Minnesota. The Schedule KPC factor headings returned in the lines read are Property and Sales, and whether a payroll column appears is not confirmed. The unitary half of the Schedule KPC sentence is the complement that the sentence implies, and the Form M4 instructions and Minn. Stat. 290.17, subd. 4 were not read to confirm it. Whether an upper tier whose only Minnesota income is passed through is "required to file a return" under Minn. Stat. 289A.12, subd. 3 was not read. The content of the two 2026 amendments in the history line of section 290.0922 and the 2026 Form M3 were not read. The 2025 Form M3 instructions carry draft notations on some pages, so the final edition is unconfirmed.
  2. Kentucky. The Schedule K, Section B, line 5 instruction came in two fragments, so the credit method above should be confirmed against the printed page. KRS 141.010's definition of a limited liability pass-through entity, KRS 141.0205, the schedule for a pass-through entity that is a partner of another, a 2025 edition of Form PTE and the act's own effective-date sections were not read; the statute page's effective date of July 15, 2026 is relied on. No refund or carryforward of an unused (2)(c) credit appears in the lines read, and whether a general partnership tier breaks the credit chain is open.
  3. Michigan. No penalty for failing to furnish the section 839(1) items was located. The composite return rules and the repeal of flow-through withholding were not read. Whether the Treasury guidance changed after the April 2, 2025 amendment, and what it says about tiers, is not established.
  4. New York. No source read states how an upper tier with no operations of its own computes lines 116b and 116c. Tax Law section 209-B(2) and section 801(a)(1), the instruction text for Form IT-204 line 126 and the 2023 instructions for Form IT-204-IP were not read. The Department's instructions for Form IT-204-CP list seven conditions in the extract read, and the regulation lists eight. The certification that permits the entity method and the words of the "at each tier" rule beyond the fragment read were not read in full.
  5. Illinois. 86 Ill. Adm. Code section 100.3380(d) was not read, because the host refuses automated reads. Section 304 of the Income Tax Act was read only at a mirror of the 2023 compilation, and the same-formula condition is cited as a separate article in this library states it.
  6. Arkansas, Louisiana and Oklahoma. Whether the Arkansas rule applies at each tier of an Arkansas partnership is not stated ("as reported on the Arkansas partnership return"). The 2025 Arkansas Schedule K-1 and instructions, the official Arkansas Code, La. R.S. 47:287.94 and 47:287.95, LAC 61:I.1130 and 68 O.S. section 2358(A)(4) were not read; the Oklahoma rule's citation is the source for the separate-allocation reading. The elective entity-level taxes of Arkansas and Oklahoma are outside this article.
  7. North Carolina. Whether G.S. 105-114.1(b) reaches a limited partnership is open. Subsection (c1) of section 105-122 beyond its first sentence, the pre-2023 subsection (c), the exception in (b)(2) for qualified interest expense and the 17 NCAC 05C .1700 series at the official codifier were not read, and the final readoption outcome for .1702 is not known.
  8. California. The act that narrowed section 25128 for 2025 was not re-read. The regulation states no formula for carrying a profits interest through a tier, so the multiplication of interests at each link is this article's reading of subdivisions (a) and (f)(4).

Worked example

The example is invented and uses round figures. It shows what each state asks for from the same ownership chain; where a rule's input is unknown, it says so.

Structure for tax year 2025. Upper Holdings LLC (called Upper below), taxed as a partnership, rents industrial equipment through three lower-tier limited liability companies taxed as partnerships (LT1, LT2 and LT3) and has no operations of its own. Corporation C holds 30 percent of Upper's profits and is unitary with Upper and with each lower tier for California purposes. Five individuals hold the other 70 percent. None is a resident of California, Kentucky, Michigan or Minnesota, and one of them, N, holds 10 percent of Upper's profits and is a New York resident. Upper holds 50 percent of LT1 (California and Minnesota activity), 40 percent of LT2 (Kentucky and Michigan activity) and 60 percent of LT3 (New York activity in zone one and elsewhere in the state). All tiers use calendar years. Upper elects neither the Michigan flow-through entity tax nor a composite return.

  • California. C's indirect interests in profits are 30 percent times 50 percent, 15 percent, in LT1; 30 percent times 40 percent, 12 percent, in LT2; and 30 percent times 60 percent, 18 percent, in LT3. Because C is unitary with every tier, its shares of all three enter its factor and its base. LT1 has sales of $40,000,000 everywhere and $10,000,000 in California, so C's share is $6,000,000 everywhere and $1,500,000 in California. LT2 has receipts of $20,000,000 and none in California, so C's share is $2,400,000 everywhere. LT3 has gross receipts of $50,000,000 and none in California, so C's share is $9,000,000 everywhere. C's own sales are $94,000,000 everywhere and $8,500,000 in California. The combined denominator is $94,000,000 plus $6,000,000 plus $2,400,000 plus $9,000,000, or $111,400,000. The combined numerator is $8,500,000 plus $1,500,000, or $10,000,000. The factor is 10,000,000 over 111,400,000, or 8.9767 percent rounded to four places (8.976661 percent unrounded). Combined business income of $20,000,000, which already includes C's shares of the business income of all three lower tiers, apportions $1,795,332 to California on the unrounded factor and $1,795,340 on the rounded factor; the parts of the regulation read state no rounding rule. LT1's California property cost $12,000,000, after $5,000,000 of accumulated depreciation, so its book value is $7,000,000. C's 15 percent is $1,800,000 at cost and $1,050,000 at book value. The 2025 formula is sales only, so the property figure matters for the doing-business threshold, and the cost figure is the one section 25130 uses.
  • Minnesota. LT1's Minnesota factors at 100 percent are average property at original cost of $3,000,000, payroll of $1,000,000 and sales of $6,000,000. Line 6 is $10,000,000, in the row for $2,510,000 to $12,539,999, so LT1's fee is $750. Upper's 50 percent share is property of $1,500,000, payroll of $500,000 and sales of $3,000,000, together $5,000,000. Subdivision 4 excludes that share from Upper's fee base. The form's line 7 subtraction removes the line 3 and line 5 amounts ($4,500,000) and leaves $500,000 of payroll on line 4. Upper's line 8 is therefore $0 on the statute and $500,000 on the form's literal reading, below $1,250,000 either way, and its fee is $0. C's indirect 15 percent share of LT1's Minnesota factors is property of $450,000, payroll of $150,000 and sales of $900,000. Schedule KPC line 3 reports LT1's $750 under the label "Partnership's minimum fee," and the factor shares reach C under the heading for the partner's share.
  • Kentucky. LT2's Kentucky gross receipts are $10,000,000 of $20,000,000 from all sources, so the receipts computation is 10,000,000 over 100, or 100,000, times 0.095, or $9,500. The profits computation is the larger whenever LT2's Kentucky gross profits exceed about $1,266,667, and the example assumes they do, so the receipts computation governs. Upper's all-source receipts are 40 percent of LT2's $20,000,000 ($8,000,000), 50 percent of LT1's $40,000,000 ($20,000,000) and 60 percent of LT3's $50,000,000 ($30,000,000), or $58,000,000, so the full rate applies. Upper's Kentucky gross receipts are 40 percent of LT2's $10,000,000, or $4,000,000, and its tax before credit is 4,000,000 over 100, or 40,000, times 0.095, or $3,800. The subsection (2)(c) credit is Upper's 40 percent of LT2's tax less $175 ($9,325), or $3,730. Upper's tax after the credit is $3,800 less $3,730, or $70, and the greater of $70 or $175 is $175. Upper's entity tax is therefore $175 under KRS 141.0401(2)(a) and Form PTE, Part II, line 6, and it attaches LT2's Kentucky Schedule K-1 under Part II, line 4. On the Department's method, the credit Upper passes to its owners is the credit received ($3,730) plus its own tax after credits and the minimum ($175) less $175, or $3,730. C's 30 percent is $1,119 and N's 10 percent is $373, each equal to the owner's indirect share of LT2's tax less $175 (12 percent and 4 percent of $9,325). The credits offset only Kentucky income tax on income from the entity, and any excess is disallowed.
  • Michigan. LT2's Michigan sales are $8,000,000 of $20,000,000, a factor of 40.0000 percent. With $10,000,000 of Kentucky receipts, $18,000,000 of LT2's $20,000,000 is accounted for and $2,000,000 is elsewhere. LT2 has $5,000,000 of business income. C's indirect interest is 12 percent (30 percent times 40 percent), or $600,000 of income. C does not control more than half of LT2, since 12 percent is not "more than 50% of the ownership interests with voting rights," so under section 661(2) the entity's factor applies to an interest held "indirect through 1 or more other flow-through entities": $600,000 times 40.0000 percent is $240,000 to Michigan. N's indirect interest is 4 percent (10 percent times 40 percent), or $200,000, and $200,000 times 40.0000 percent is $80,000 of Michigan-source distributive share. Upper has no Michigan activity of its own and made no election, so Upper is not a Part 8 taxpayer under section 809(3); LT2 furnishes the apportionment information to Upper under section 839(1)(a), and Upper furnishes its members the same kind of information. The factor is stated as 40.0000 percent and not as 0.4 or 0.004, because a misplaced decimal changes the result by a factor of one hundred.
  • New York commuter tax. N's indirect interest in LT3 is 10 percent times 60 percent, or 6 percent. The example assumes that N takes part in management, so N is not treated as a limited partner under section 800(e), and that N's net earnings from self-employment from LT3 on the Schedule SE basis are $500,000. LT3's Section 10 amounts are average owned real property of $20,000,000 everywhere, $12,000,000 in New York and $8,000,000 in zone one; payroll of $10,000,000, $4,000,000 and $3,000,000; and gross income of $50,000,000, $36,000,000 and $20,000,000. The zone two amounts are zero. The business allocation percentage is property 60.0000, payroll 40.0000 and gross income 72.0000, which sum to 172.0000 and divide by three to 57.3333 percent. Zone one is property 40.0000, payroll 30.0000 and gross income 40.0000, which sum to 110.0000 and divide by three to 36.6667 percent. Zone two is 0.0000 percent. Each percentage is rounded to four decimal places, as the instructions require. N's zone one earnings are $500,000 times 36.6667 percent, or $183,333.50 ($183,333.33 unrounded). Using the 57.3333 percent business allocation percentage would give $286,666.50 ($286,666.67 unrounded), an overstatement of $103,333.00, and a zero on the zone line would give $0 and miss the tax. The 2025 threshold of $50,000 is met on $183,333.50 from this one source, so the whole amount is taxed under section 801(a)(2) at the zone one rate of 0.60 percent, or $1,100.00, before any other district earnings of N. For 2026 the threshold is $150,000, which the same earnings would also exceed. Whether Upper's lines 116b and 116c can carry LT3's percentages is open.

What the example shows. Each state wants a different object from the same chain: dollar receipts and a profits chain in California, a fee that stays at the lower tier with a Schedule KPC for the corporate partner in Minnesota, a duplicated base offset by a credit with a $175 floor in Kentucky, a single sales factor and information without a return in Michigan, and a zone percentage that is not the state percentage in New York. What it leaves out are Illinois, Arkansas, Louisiana, Oklahoma and North Carolina, intercompany eliminations, rate computations, the corporate partner's New York surcharge percentage, and the Michigan, Kentucky and Minnesota income computations themselves.

Practice notes

Build the package by partner type. For a corporate partner, give receipts by state in dollars, as the numerator and the partnership's own denominator, at 100 percent and at the partner's share. Add property and payroll only where a threshold, the New York commuter district surcharge or Kentucky's factor statute calls for them, and add the state-source income share for the allocation states, the partnership's North Carolina sales and its sales everywhere for North Carolina, and the entity's Michigan sales factor. Add balance-sheet items only where a net worth base can reach the partnership: North Carolina where the partner owns more than 50 percent of an LLC, and related-party debt for the franchise tax add-back.

For individual and upper-tier partners, add the state Schedule K-1 items the sources require: the Kentucky K-1 with the entity tax credit, Minnesota Schedule KPC, the Illinois pro forma Schedule K-1-P, Forms IT-204-CP and IT-204-IP for a New York partner that is a partnership or LLC, and the zone percentages on Form IT-204-IP, lines 29b and 29c.

Compute the Minnesota fee from the entity's own factors only. State the statute's exclusion of pass-through payroll wherever the form leaves it on line 4, and show the removed pass-through amounts on the enclosed line 7 schedule.

Attach each lower tier's Kentucky Schedule K-1 to Form PTE when claiming the credit, keep the chain of proportionate shares in the workpapers, and carry the $175 minimum at each tier.

Give every Michigan factor as a percentage with four decimals, and state whether an entity that made no election has furnished the section 839(1) items to its members.

Keep the New York zone percentages on lines 116b and 116c separate from the line 126 percentage, and test the eight presumptions in 20 NYCRR section 9-2.2 before a corporate partner certifies the entity method.

State each factor as a percentage with four decimals, re-add the arithmetic before release, and state which property measure (cost, adjusted basis or book value) every schedule uses. Ask each lower tier for cost and for adjusted basis separately.

Deliver a reconciliation from the federal Schedule K to each state's figures, with modifications shown separately, so that the recipient does not need the federal return.

G&G State Tax Group advises corporate partners, upper-tier partnerships and the partnerships that serve them on the state data a tiered package must carry, on the partner filings that follow, and on the state fees and credits that run through the tiers, alongside its state and local tax practice.

This article states the law as of November 11, 2026

Statutes, rates, thresholds, and agency practice change, and a different set of facts can change the answer. Before acting on anything discussed above, contact G&G State Tax Group, or another state and local tax adviser, to confirm what has changed since this was written and how the rules apply to a specific situation.

Contact the firm+1 714.234.5538 · info@gandgsalt.com

This publication is informational in nature and is not, and should not be considered, legal, accounting, tax, or other professional advice for any person or situation. Correct application of tax law depends heavily on the facts and circumstances in each case, and G&G State Tax Group, LLC assumes no liability in connection with the use of this information, and is not obligated to inform any reader of changes in the law or other factors that could affect the information contained herein.