MultistateIncome and franchise tax
How does North Carolina's franchise tax reach a corporate partner's share of real property held through partnerships, and what changed when the property bases were repealed?
The short answer
From 2023, North Carolina's franchise tax reaches a corporate partner's share of partnership real property only through net worth. The partner is usually taxed on its investment's book value; the partnership, only if it elected corporate treatment. One statute, section 105-114.1, attributes more: a corporation that, with affiliates, owns more than 50 percent of the capital interests in a noncorporate LLC includes the same percentage of the company's net worth. Before 2023 the base was the greatest of net worth and two property bases (55 percent of appraised value of real and tangible property, and actual investment in tangible property). Net worth is apportioned by the sales factor, and the partner's share of partnership sales enters the factor when its share of the partnership's income is apportionable, a fact-based test that a state rule and a 2020 Department notice state differently. A C corporation pays $1.50 per $1,000 of tax base, with a $200 minimum and, from 2025, a $500 maximum on the first $1,000,000 of base. A Schedule K-1 lacks the interest's book value and property-level cost, depreciation and debt, and no source found requires the partnership to supply them. Refund claims for property-base years are almost all closed.
Working through this on a live matter? Contact the firm
Who owes the franchise tax
North Carolina's franchise tax is a privilege tax on a corporation doing business in the State. The imposing sentence reads "An annual franchise or privilege tax is imposed on a corporation doing business in this State" (N.C. Gen. Stat. section 105-122(a)). In this article "the Department" means the North Carolina Department of Revenue.
The franchise tax article defines a corporation to include a limited liability company or a partnership only when it elects to be taxed as a corporation; the definition "does not otherwise include a limited liability company or a partnership" (section 105-114(b)(2)). A partnership that owns a warehouse therefore files no franchise tax return on its own account unless it has made that election. The taxpayer is the corporate partner, and it owes the tax if it is a corporation doing business in the State. A limited liability company that has elected corporate treatment is itself a franchise taxpayer, and the Department's bulletin states that its rules on corporate members of limited liability companies, discussed below, do not apply to such a company.
The statute defines doing business as "Each and every act, power, or privilege exercised or enjoyed in this State, as an incident to, or by virtue of the powers and privileges granted by the laws of this State" (section 105-114(b)(3)). The Department's Corporate Income, Franchise, and Insurance Tax Bulletin, in the edition that reflects changes made in the 2025 regular session of the General Assembly (the bulletin), lists "Corporations who are partners in a partnership or joint venture operating in North Carolina" among the corporations that are doing business in the State. That list sits in the part of the bulletin on the corporate income tax, and its lead sentence is limited to income tax purposes. The sections of the bulletin's franchise tax part on the base, net worth, apportionment and corporate members of limited liability companies carry no matching statement. The conclusion that a corporate partner files a franchise tax return therefore rests on the statute's definition, and the Department's income tax list is the nearest published guide to how it applies the term. No Department statement on the franchise tax for a corporate partner was found.
This article covers the franchise tax only. How a lower-tier partnership's apportionment factors reach its partners for the income tax is the subject of a separate article in this library, and this article adds only the North Carolina income tax classification rule that the franchise tax borrows.
What the franchise tax base contains from 2023
For franchise tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2023, the franchise tax base is net worth, apportioned, and nothing else. The Department's bulletin states the rule in one sentence: "For tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2023, franchise tax is calculated using only" the net worth base. S.L. 2021-180, section 42.3, removed the two property bases (55 percent of appraised value and actual investment), leaving net worth. The Department's law-change page gives the effective date as "taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2023" and states that the change "is applicable to the calculation of franchise tax reported on the 2022 and later corporate income tax returns."
The session laws pair each effective date with a return one year earlier, so the article names both. The franchise tax year 2023 is reported on the 2022 return, and the franchise tax year 2025 is reported on the 2024 return. The Department names a fiscal-year return by the year in which the income year begins: "File the 2025 return for calendar year 2025 and fiscal years that begin in 2025." In this article, franchise tax year means the year for which the tax is imposed, and return means the corporate return that reports it. Section 105-122 does not define "taxable year," and its net worth paragraph speaks of both "the close of its income year" and "the end of the corporation's taxable year." This article follows the pairing of effective dates with returns as the sources state it.
The net worth computation
The statute measures net worth from the corporation's own books. A corporation "shall determine the total amount of its net worth on the basis of the books and records of the corporation as of the close of its income year." Net worth is "its total assets without regard to the deduction for accumulated depreciation, depletion, or amortization less its total liabilities," computed under generally accepted accounting principles, or under the corporation's federal tax accounting method if it keeps no such books (section 105-122(b)). The statute then lists the adjustments. The list below is complete as the statute now reads. The bulletin predates the 2026 act and lists four adjustments: the depreciation deduction, the asset valuation, the affiliated indebtedness addition and the creditor deduction.
- Subdivision (1) allows a deduction for accumulated depreciation, depletion, and amortization, and subdivision (1b) values the assets that qualify for it by the method used for federal income tax purposes.
- Subdivision (2) adds back indebtedness the corporation owes to a parent, a subsidiary, an affiliate, or a noncorporate entity in which the corporation or group of corporations owns directly or indirectly more than 50 percent of the capital interest, unless the indebtedness creates qualified interest expense as the statute defines it.
- Subdivision (2a), a deduction for a creditor corporation, was repealed by S.L. 2026-31, section 8.7(a).
- Subdivision (2b) values a foreign entity's net worth by the assets deemed to be in the United States, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2023.
- Subdivision (9) allows a deduction for an investment in an insurance company when the corporation owns, directly or indirectly, more than 80 percent of its voting stock, voting capital interests or ownership interests.
Subdivisions (3) through (8) are repealed. Subsection (b1) supplies eight definitions for subsection (b): affiliate, affiliated group, capital interest, governing law, indebtedness, noncorporate entity, parent and subsidiary. A noncorporate entity is "A person that is neither a human being nor a corporation."
A partnership interest is an asset
A partnership interest is an asset on the corporate partner's books. No statutory provision found removes it from total assets for a partner outside the rule discussed in the next section. The practical consequence is that the corporate partner needs the carrying value of its interest on its own books, not the partnership's property schedule. When the partnership carries a mortgage, the liability reduces the partnership's equity, and on the usual accounting the partner's carrying value follows that equity. The mortgage then reduces the carrying value and does not appear as a separate item in the corporate partner's computation. That is an accounting result assumed in the example below, not a rule found in a statute or in a Department publication.
A corporate partner's debt to a partnership it does not control is not added back. The add-back in subdivision (2) reaches a noncorporate entity only when the corporation or its group owns more than 50 percent of that entity's capital interest, so a 40 percent partner that owes money to the partnership has nothing to add.
Equity-method investments: the Department's words and the open reading
The Department publishes two sentences on investments, and both speak of subsidiary corporations. The first reads "A parent corporation may exclude any retained earnings of existing subsidiary corporations that it has capitalized or otherwise recorded on its books, through an equity method of accounting." The second reads "No reduction of the net worth base is allowed for the investment in subsidiary" except as the limited liability company rule provides. Neither sentence mentions a partnership, and the Schedule C section of the instructions for the 2025 corporate return does not mention partnerships.
A corporation that carries a partnership interest on the equity method has capitalized undistributed partnership earnings in the same way a parent capitalizes a subsidiary's earnings. The first sentence therefore neither reaches nor excludes a partnership, and the Department's words are the only published position. No published example was found. When the amount matters, a written request to the Department is the route to an answer.
The one attribution rule: a corporation owning more than 50 percent of a noncorporate LLC
The general rule is stated in the Department's instructions for the 2025 corporate return: "A limited liability company's income, assets, liabilities, or equity is generally not attributed to a corporation that is a member of the LLC." The exception follows in the same passage: "However, if the corporation or an affiliated group of corporations owns more than 50% of the capital interests in a LLC, the corporation must include a percentage of the LLC's net assets in the calculation of the corporation's franchise tax." The source of the exception is section 105-114.1, headed "Controlled Companies." It is the only provision found that attributes an entity's assets to a corporation, and it applies to a noncorporate limited liability company, defined as "A limited liability company that does not elect to be taxed as a corporation under the Code" (section 105-114.1(a)(5)).
What the statute says
For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2023, subsection (b) provides that when a corporation or an affiliated group of corporations "owns more than fifty percent (50%) of the capital interests in a noncorporate limited liability company," the corporation or group "must include in its tax base pursuant to G.S. 105-122 the same percentage of the noncorporate limited liability company's net worth." A capital interest is the right under the company's governing law to receive a percentage of the company's assets upon dissolution after payments to creditors (subsection (a)(2)). That right can differ from the profit percentage a partner reads on its Schedule K-1.
Subsection (c) counts ownership through intermediate entities. Ownership is "determined by reference to the constructive ownership rules for partnerships, estates, and trusts" in section 318(a)(2)(A) and (B) of the Internal Revenue Code, with capital interest substituted for stock, with a noncorporate limited liability company and any noncorporate entity other than a partnership, estate or trust treated as a partnership, and with the operating rule of section 318(a)(5) applied without paragraph (5)(C). On those rules a corporation can pass the 50 percent line through an intermediate partnership only if its direct holdings plus its proportionate share of the capital interests held through the partnership exceed 50 percent. The bulletin gives an example that stops at the line: a partnership owns 100 percent of the capital interests of an LLC, and Corporation A is a 50 percent owner of the partnership, so "Corporation A constructively owns fifty percent (50%) of the capital interest in the LLC." Fifty percent is not more than fifty percent, so on the statute's words Corporation A does not reach the threshold on those facts, although the bulletin's example does not say so.
Four more provisions complete the rule:
- Subsection (e) allocates the percentage among the members of an affiliated group that are doing business in the State, by the capital interests each member owns. The bulletin's example has a group of three corporations owning an LLC. Corporation A, doing business in the State, owns 50 percent, Corporation B, also doing business in the State, owns 10 percent, and Corporation C, not doing business in the State, owns 40 percent. Corporation A includes 100 percent times 50 over (50 plus 10), or 83.33 percent, and Corporation B includes 16.67 percent.
- Subsection (f) provides that the section "does not apply to assets owned by a noncorporate limited liability company" whose total book value of assets never exceeded $150,000 during its taxable year.
- Subsection (g) measures ownership "as of the last day of its taxable year," requires the adjustments to be made on the owner's next following return, and measures ownership at the end of the corporation's or group's taxable year when the company and the corporation have engaged in a pattern of transferring assets between them so that neither owned the capital interests on the last day of its own year.
- Subsection (d), headed "No Double Inclusion," provides that when a corporation includes the company's amounts, "its investment in the noncorporate limited liability company is not included in its computation of net worth base under G.S. 105-122(b)."
What the rule does not say
The words "general partnership" and "limited partnership" do not appear in section 105-114.1, and the word "partnership" appears only in the ownership rules of subsection (c). The bulletin addresses an LLC and does not address a limited partnership interest. Whether a limited partnership or a general partnership counts as a noncorporate limited liability company is therefore open, and no ruling or notice was found. This article states the text and draws no conclusion about a partnership that is not an LLC; the text gives no express rule for such a partnership either way.
The exclusion of the investment: mandatory in the statute, permissive in the Department's words
The statute states the exclusion as mandatory: the investment "is not included." The bulletin and the instructions state it as permissive. The bulletin says a corporation required to include a percentage of the LLC's assets "may exclude its investment in the LLC from its computation of the net worth base," and the instructions say "the corporation may exclude its investment in the LLC from the computation." The Department's wording is the published position. A corporation that attributes the LLC's net worth and also leaves its own investment in its net worth counts the same equity twice, which the subsection's heading forbids.
What was included before 2023 and what is included now
Before 2023, subsection (b) required the corporation to include in its three tax bases "the same percentage of (i) the noncorporate limited liability company's net worth; (ii) fifty-five percent (55%) of the noncorporate limited liability company's appraised ad valorem tax value of property; and (iii) the noncorporate limited liability company's actual investment in tangible property in this State, as appropriate." The Department's 2021 law-change page describes the change as including "the same percentage of only the net worth base," in place of three tax bases. From 2023 only the net worth percentage is added.
The sources label the attributed amount differently. The statute says "net worth" in subsection (b), the cross-reference in subsection (d) and the bulletin say "assets," and the instructions say "net assets." That difference in labels is not an open computation question.
Where the attributed amount enters the computation
The statute does not say whether the LLC's net worth percentage joins the corporation's net worth before the apportionment or is added to the tax base afterward. Subsection (b) says to include the amount "in its tax base pursuant to G.S. 105-122," and the 2023 and later version of section 105-122(d) says a corporation's tax base is "the proportion of its net worth as set out in subsection (c1)." The bulletin says the corporation includes the percentage "in its net worth base," and it uses "Net Worth Base" as the heading of the section that computes net worth before apportionment. The 2021 law-change page uses the words "net worth base" in the same way. Those words support adding the amount to net worth before apportionment, and the worked example follows that placement. The example also shows the other placement in one paragraph, because the two give different tax from 2025.
The LLC's net worth has no published method
No source found says how an LLC's net worth is computed. Section 105-122(b) defines net worth for "a corporation," subsection (b) of section 105-114.1 says only "net worth" of the LLC, and the bulletin says "assets" and gives no method. The variant in the worked example computes it as the corporation would compute its own net worth, by analogy to section 105-122(b), and assumes that the LLC's book accumulated depreciation equals its federal reserve. Those are assumptions, not published methods.
The property bases before 2023
For franchise tax years beginning before January 1, 2023, the franchise tax was calculated on the largest of three bases. The Department's December 2018 bulletin edition says "Franchise tax is calculated on the largest of the following tax bases:" and lists net worth, 55 percent of the appraised ad valorem tax value of real and tangible property in the State, and actual investment in tangible property in the State. The statute's subdivisions in section 105-122(d) read as follows for those years.
- Net worth: "The proportion of its net worth as set out in subsection (c1) of this section."
- Appraised value: "Fifty-five percent (55%) of the corporation's appraised value as determined for ad valorem taxation of all the real and tangible personal property in this State," with the valuation taken as "the ad valorem valuation for the calendar year next preceding the due date of the franchise tax return."
- Actual investment: "The corporation's total actual investment in tangible property in this State," defined as the total original purchase price or consideration to the reporting taxpayer of its tangible properties, including real estate, in the State, plus additions and improvements, "less (i) reserve for depreciation as permitted for income tax purposes and (ii) any indebtedness specifically incurred and existing solely for and as the result of the purchase of any real estate and any permanent improvements made on the real estate."
The debt subtraction in clause (ii) applied to taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2020, under S.L. 2017-204, section 1.3(b), with the effective date in section 1.3(d). It applied to franchise tax reported on the 2019 and later returns. For the franchise tax years 2020 through 2022 the investment base was therefore reduced by the depreciation reserve and by debt incurred for real estate. The 2018 bulletin edition describes limits on the subtraction: the debt must be "indebtedness specifically incurred in the purchase and permanent improvement of real estate," "The deductible amount cannot exceed the book value (cost less depreciation) of the real estate," and "Indebtedness incurred in the purchase of personal property is not deductible." Net worth, by contrast, always reduced assets by liabilities, so a mortgage affected the net worth base in every year.
Both property bases measured the property of "the corporation" and "the reporting taxpayer." A 40 percent corporate partner in a limited partnership did not own the warehouse, and no provision found attributes partnership property to a partner. Constructive ownership of an entity's property exists only inside section 105-114.1, for a corporation above 50 percent of a noncorporate limited liability company. The property bases were not apportioned, because they counted property in the State, and only the net worth base was multiplied by the apportionment fraction.
How net worth is apportioned, and when the partnership's sales count
The statutory fraction
The statute apportions net worth by the corporation's income fraction, which is now a fraction of North Carolina sales over sales everywhere. A corporation subject to income tax "must apportion its net worth by using the fraction it applies in apportioning its income" under the corporate income tax article (section 105-122(c1)(1)). The subdivision calls this the statutory method of apportionment and presumes it to be the best method of determining the net worth attributable to the corporation's business in this State. Subdivision (c1)(2) allows "a written request to the Secretary for permission to use an alternative method." The bulletin states that the request is due "not later than ninety (90) days after the regular or extended due date" of the return and notes a $5,000 fee for a written determination.
The income fraction is the sales factor alone for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2018. Apportionable income of corporations is apportioned "by multiplying the income by the sales factor" (section 105-130.4(i)), and the sales factor is a fraction whose numerator is the corporation's sales in the State during the income year and whose denominator is its sales everywhere during the income year (section 105-130.4(l)). The former property and payroll factors were repealed by S.L. 2015-241, section 32.14(d), as amended by S.L. 2015-268, section 10.1(c), effective for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2018.
Apportionable and nonapportionable income
Whether a corporate partner's share of partnership sales enters the fraction depends on whether the partner's share of the partnership's income is apportionable. The statute's definition of apportionable income begins "All income that is apportionable under the United States Constitution," and includes income that arises from either of two sources. The first is "Transactions and activities in the regular course of the taxpayer's trade or business." The second is "Tangible and intangible property if the acquisition, management, employment, development, or disposition of the property is or was related to the operation of the taxpayer's trade or business." Nonapportionable income is "All income other than apportionable income" (section 105-130.4(a)). S.L. 2017-204, section 1.5(a), rewrote the definition of apportionable income, effective under section 1.5(b) for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2017.
Rule 17 NCAC 05C .1702 ("Apportionable Income or Nonapportionable Income") applies the classification to a corporate partner. The rule's words below come from a commercial reproduction of the rule that states it is current through Register Vol. 39, No. 24, June 16, 2025. The official Office of Administrative Hearings periodic review report confirms the rule's number, title and its 2018 readoption, and the official codifier's own page could not be opened. The rule reads:
- "Income shall be classified as nonapportionable income where the corporate partner limits its connection to the partnership to the investment of funds or property and does not regularly or materially participate in the day-to-day operation of the partnership."
- "Where the business of the partnership is directly or integrally related to the business of the corporate partner, the corporate partner's share of the partnership net income is classified as apportionable income."
- "When classified as apportionable income, the corporate partner's apportionment factors shall include its proportionate share of the partnership's property, payroll, and sales."
- If the income is nonapportionable, the rule includes it in the corporate partner's net taxable income and allocates it under the allocation provisions of G.S. 105-130.4.
The rule's history note reads "Authority G.S. 105-130.4; 105-262; Eff. February 1, 1976; Amended Eff. January 1, 2005; January 1, 1994; October 31, 1981; Readopted Eff. May 1, 2018." A companion rule, 05C .1701, "Reporting Partnership Net Income," is effective August 19, 2017, and its text was not found.
The Department's restatement and its sales-only reading
The bulletin restates the classification in its part on the corporate income tax, under the heading "Partnership and the Corporate Partner." It says the classification depends on the facts in each case, that in general income from transactions and activities dependent upon or contributing to the taxpayer's operations is apportionable, and that income from unrelated business activities making up a discrete business enterprise is nonapportionable. It continues that when income is classified as apportionable, "the corporate partner's apportionment factors includes its proportionate share of the partnership's sales." The bulletin does not use the words property or payroll in that passage, and it says that nonapportionable income is allocated under section 105-130.4.
The rule's words about property and payroll reflect the earlier three-factor formula. The statute has used only a sales factor since taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2018, and the rule's text as reproduced still names all three factors. The periodic review report classifies the rule as "Necessary," with readoption required. The Department applies sales only, so this article presents the property and payroll words as a text with no apportionment use after 2017 and not as a live conflict.
The Department's wider reading of apportionable income
The Department's Important Notice of December 31, 2020 bears on a passive limited partner. It describes Final Agency Decision No. 09 REV 5669, issued April 21, 2011, which held that the gain from the sale of an out-of-state taxpayer's minority limited partnership interest was nonapportionable. The decision rested on findings that the taxpayer was a passive investor, "was not involved in the partnership's day-to-day operation" and did not derive the income from its unitary business. The notice states that the 2017 session law, in its section 1.5(a), amended the statute "to clarify that the definition of 'apportionable income' means all income under the U.S. Constitution, including income that arises from transactions and activities in the regular course of business, or tangible and intangible property if the acquisition, management, employment, development, or disposition of the property is or was related to the operation of the taxpayer's trade or business." That sentence is the notice's description of the amendment, and the statute's own words are quoted above. The notice then concludes that the 2011 decision "is no longer the correct application" of section 105-130.4. The Department "will no longer follow Decision No. 09 REV 5669 for transactions occurring after the date of this Important Notice" and will apply the statute "as amended by S.L. 2017-204, to evaluate what items constitute apportionable income."
The notice does not cite rule 05C .1702 or any rule number, and it does not say whether a day-to-day participation test survives for a corporate partner. It describes the facts of the abrogated decision and then points to the statute's test, which asks whether the property "is or was related to the operation of the taxpayer's trade or business." The notice does not say in so many words that a passive limited partner's share is apportionable. The Department's likely position, an inference from the notice, is that a passive limited partner's share can be apportionable when the interest is or was related to the partner's trade or business, because the statute's test asks about relatedness and says nothing of day-to-day participation. The 2017 act made the rewritten definition effective for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2017, while the notice applies it to transactions after the notice date, and the notice does not explain how the two dates fit. The abrogated decision concerned a gain on a sale, not annual operating income, and no ruling or decision found applies the relatedness test to a minority limited partnership interest on facts like those of a rental partnership.
Putting the two together
The rule's words are the starting point, and on its first sentence a corporate partner that only invests funds or property, without regularly or materially participating in the day-to-day operation of the partnership, holds nonapportionable income. The partner's share of partnership sales then stays out of both the numerator and the denominator of its factor, and its share of the income is allocated. Where the partnership's business is directly or integrally related to the partner's business, the share is apportionable and the share of partnership sales enters the factor. The Department's wider reading adds a second route to apportionability for an interest related to the partner's trade or business. "Unrelated" in this discussion therefore means outside the statute's relatedness test, not outside a participation test. Whether a given interest is related is a question of fact, and the preparer's decision, with the facts that support it, belongs in the file. The same decision classifies the partner's share of the partnership's income for the corporate income tax, because the fraction the corporation uses for its income is the fraction it uses for its net worth.
Rate, minimum and maximum
For franchise tax years beginning before January 1, 2025, a C corporation paid $1.50 per $1,000 of tax base with a $200 minimum. For years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, the statute reads: "For a C Corporation, as defined in G.S. 105-130.2, the tax rate is one dollar and fifty cents ($1.50) per one thousand dollars ($1,000) of its tax base with a minimum of two hundred dollars ($200.00) and a maximum of five hundred dollars ($500.00) for the first one million dollars ($1,000,000) of its tax base" (section 105-122(d2)). An S corporation pays differently: "the tax rate is two hundred dollars ($200.00) for the first one million dollars ($1,000,000) of its tax base and one dollar and fifty cents ($1.50) per one thousand dollars ($1,000) of its tax base that exceeds one million dollars ($1,000,000)." A partner that is an S corporation, on a tax base of $666,667, therefore pays $200.
Only the S corporation sentence carries the words "that exceeds one million dollars." For a C corporation the rate sentence covers the whole base, and the minimum and maximum attach to the first $1,000,000. The charge of $1.50 per $1,000 on the excess is the reading the words support, and it is the step the Department states in its instructions for the 2025 corporate return: "If the net worth base exceeds $1,000,000, multiply the amount over $1,000,000 by $1.50 per $1,000 (.0015) and add $500." The first $1,000,000 carries "a maximum of $500." One sentence in the same paragraph of the instructions repeats older wording on the minimum tax and a maximum; the statute's text is quoted above and controls.
Which text was in force, and the flat $500 that never applied
The session laws pair each effective date with the return that reports the tax: years beginning in 2023 apply to the 2022 return, and years beginning in 2025 apply to the 2024 return. For franchise tax year 2025, reported on the 2024 return due in 2025, the rate text in force when the return was due was S.L. 2024-1, section 11.2(a). S.L. 2026-31, section 8.2(a), rewrote the subsection on July 2, 2026, after that return was due. Section 8.2 carries no effective-date sentence of its own, so section 8.8 governs, and the Part is "effective when it becomes law." The act was ratified June 25, 2026 and approved July 2, 2026. The result on a base of $666,667 is $500 under both texts, and the 2026 rewrite does not change that result.
S.L. 2023-134, section 42.6A(a), had earlier set a flat $500 on the first $1,000,000 of a C corporation's base, with $1.50 per $1,000 on the excess. That text never governed a return. S.L. 2024-1 replaced it with the "maximum" wording and kept the $200 minimum, and both acts pair taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025 with the 2024 and later return.
The data a corporate partner needs, and who must supply it
A federal Schedule K-1 does not carry the data the franchise tax computation uses: the interest's book carrying value and the partnership's property cost, depreciation and debt. The Internal Revenue Service's Schedule K-1 instructions describe what it does carry.
- Item J reports percentages, which the instructions describe as generally based on the partnership agreement. The capital percentage is the share of capital the partner would receive if the partnership were liquidated at the end of its tax year by the distribution of undivided interests in its assets and liabilities, and the partnership enters zero when the partner's capital account is negative or zero.
- Item K1 reports the partner's share of the partnership's nonrecourse liabilities, partnership-level qualified nonrecourse financing, and other recourse liabilities, at the beginning and the end of the partnership's tax year.
- Item L reports the beginning and ending capital account "using the tax-basis method," including the capital the partner contributed.
Those entries give a capital percentage, a total share of liabilities and a tax-basis capital account. They do not give the book carrying value of the interest, and they do not give the cost, depreciation or debt of the property by property. For the franchise tax the corporate partner needs the following.
- The carrying value of its interest on its own books at the close of its income year, which is the figure that enters total assets.
- The capital interest percentage under the entity's governing law, measured on the last day of the LLC's taxable year, and not only the profit percentage on the Schedule K-1.
- For the sales factor, the partnership's sales in the State and everywhere, by type of receipt, together with the facts that decide whether the partner's share of the income is apportionable.
- For a corporation above 50 percent of a noncorporate limited liability company, the company's net worth computed as the corporation would compute its own, the book value of the company's assets if the $150,000 exception may apply, and the other capital interest holders, so that an affiliated group can allocate the percentage.
No source found imposes on a partnership any obligation to furnish those items. Sections 105-114.1, 105-122 and 105-130.4, the bulletin's discussion of corporate members of limited liability companies and of the corporate partner, and the text of rule 05C .1702 contain no such duty. Rule 05C .1701, "Reporting Partnership Net Income," may bear on what a partnership reports, and its text was not found. The federal Schedule K-1 is the only furnished statement the sources describe, so a corporate partner obtains the data by agreement or under the partnership agreement. That conclusion rests on the absence of a provision in the sources consulted, and it is marked open.
Open years and refund claims
Refunds follow section 105-241.6(a). A request for refund is timely if made within the later of two periods: "Three years after the due date of the return," or "Two years after payment of the tax." The sentence that limits the amount sits inside the second period: "The amount refunded under this subdivision shall not exceed the portion of the tax paid during the two years immediately preceding the taxpayer's request for refund." A claim made within three years of the due date is therefore not limited to the last two years' payments, and the two-year amount limit belongs to the two-years-after-payment period only. The text does not say whether the due date of the return includes an extended due date, and no source found answers that question.
The property-base years are almost entirely closed
The property bases applied to taxable years beginning before January 1, 2023. For a calendar-year corporation, the return that reported franchise tax for the last property-base year, the franchise tax year 2022, is the 2021 return. It was due April 15, 2022, the fifteenth day of the fourth month after the income year ended, and three years after that date was April 15, 2025. The Department's bulletin gives the extension as six months from the original due date for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2008 and before January 1, 2025, so the extended due date for that return would be October 15, 2022, a Saturday, and three years after it is October 15, 2025. The three-year period therefore ran out in 2025 for a calendar-year corporation, whether or not the extended due date counts.
A fiscal-year corporation can run later. A corporation whose income year ended as late as November 30, 2022 had a franchise tax year beginning December 1, 2022, before January 1, 2023, and reported it on the 2021 return, because the Department names a fiscal-year return by the year in which the income year begins. That return was due March 15, 2023, the fifteenth day of the fourth month after the income year ended. Six months after that date is September 15, 2023, a Friday, and three years after it is September 15, 2026, a Tuesday. The three-year period has therefore run out as of November 11, 2026 for a calendar-year corporation, in 2025, and for the fiscal-year corporation described, by September 2026, whether or not the extended due date counts.
An income year that ended in December 2022 before December 31, as a 52-week or 53-week year can, was not worked through. On the same six-month assumption its return would be due about April 15, 2023, the extended date would be about October 15, 2023, and three years after that is about October 15, 2026, also before November 11, 2026. This article nonetheless describes the property-base years as almost entirely closed and does not call them entirely closed, because the extension length is taken from the bulletin's summary and not from the act and the narrow routes below remain.
What can remain
Four routes remain, each narrow.
- Tax paid within the last two years. The two-years-after-payment period reaches tax paid on a late-filed return or on an assessment, and the refund is limited to tax paid in the two years before the request.
- A waiver. Under section 105-241.6(b)(2), a taxpayer's waiver of the statute of limitations for making a proposed assessment "extends the period in which the taxpayer can obtain a refund to the end of the period extended by the waiver."
- A federal determination. Under section 105-241.6(b)(1), when a taxpayer files a return reflecting a federal determination within the time required, "the period for requesting a refund is one year after the return reflecting the federal determination is filed or three years after the original return was filed or due to be filed, whichever is later." A property-base overstatement has no federal determination behind it, and the Department can be expected to confine the exception to the return that reflects the federal change, so this route does not serve a property-base year without that return.
- A contingent event. Section 105-241.6(b)(5) extends the period once. If a taxpayer is subject to litigation or a state tax audit that prevents an accurate and definite refund request, the period "is six months after the litigation or state tax audit concludes," and the taxpayer "must file written notice to the Secretary prior to expiration" of the ordinary period. For another event, the taxpayer must "establish by clear, convincing proof that the event is beyond the taxpayer's control." A corporate partner that overstated a property base has no contingent event, and section 105-241.7(b) bars a request "based on a contingent event until the event is finalized."
The route
A taxpayer requests a refund of an overpayment by "Filing an amended return reflecting an overpayment due the taxpayer" or by "Filing a claim for refund" (section 105-241.7(b)). The Department "must take one of the actions listed in this subsection within six months," and inaction "is considered a proposed denial of the requested refund" (section 105-241.7(c)). The Department's 2011 notice on a different franchise tax item, cited here only for the form route, names an amended Form CD-405 or Form NC-19, Claim for Refund of Taxes, with an explanation.
Part VIII of S.L. 2026-31
Part VIII of S.L. 2026-31 contains no refund or limitations language for its retroactive items. Section 8.4 adds the insurance company deduction, effective "retroactively for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2019," and whether it permits claims for years otherwise closed is not answered by any source found. Section 8.7 repeals the creditor corporation's deduction in section 105-122(b)(2a), effective "retroactively for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2021." The repeal removes a deduction and so raises tax for a creditor corporation that took it; it raises no refund question for the taxpayer. Part II of the same act adds subdivision (b)(7), "Final Federal Partnership Adjustment," to section 105-241.6 for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2026, which does not reach the property-base years.
What changed and when
The dates below are the effective dates the sources give, with the return that reports each.
- Debt incurred for real estate subtracted in the actual investment base. Taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2020, reported on the 2019 and later returns. S.L. 2017-204, section 1.3(b), with the effective date in section 1.3(d).
- Definition of apportionable income rewritten. S.L. 2017-204, section 1.5(a), effective under section 1.5(b) for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2017. The Department's Important Notice of December 31, 2020 stops following Decision No. 09 REV 5669 for transactions after the date of the notice.
- The two property bases eliminated, and the matching change to the controlled-LLC rule. Taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2023, reported on the 2022 and later returns. S.L. 2021-180, section 42.3(a) through (d).
- Flat $500 on the first $1,000,000 of a C corporation's base. Enacted for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025 and never applied to a return. S.L. 2023-134, section 42.6A(a).
- A $500 maximum on the first $1,000,000 of a C corporation's base, with the $200 minimum kept. Taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, reported on the 2024 return. S.L. 2024-1, section 11.2(a), rewritten by S.L. 2026-31, section 8.2(a), approved July 2, 2026.
- One word changed in the no-double-inclusion subsection. S.L. 2026-31, section 8.1, changes "bases" to "base" in section 105-114.1(d), effective July 2, 2026, although the statute page prints the new word in the copy labeled for 2023 and later.
- Insurance company deduction, new section 105-122(b)(9). Retroactive to taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2019. S.L. 2026-31, section 8.4.
- Repeal of the creditor's deduction in section 105-122(b)(2a). Retroactive to taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2021. S.L. 2026-31, section 8.7, approved July 2, 2026.
- Extension of time to file. The Department's bulletin (part I.A.8) gives six months from the original due date for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2008 and before January 1, 2025, and seven months for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2025. The instructions for the 2025 return say an extension "may be granted for seven (7) months." The act behind the change from six to seven months was not identified.
Other states with capital-based taxes
The other states below are summarized as the sources state them. Nothing here is a survey, and the states not named were not researched.
- Tennessee. The franchise tax is a tax of "twenty-five cents (25ยข) per one hundred dollars ($100), or major fraction thereof" of "a taxpayer's net worth" (Tenn. Code Ann. section 67-4-2106(a)). The property measure was repealed by Public Chapter 950 (2024) for tax years ending on or after January 1, 2024. The tax is on the entity: limited liability companies, limited partnerships and registered limited liability partnerships are taxpayers under section 67-4-2004(36), and general partnerships, defined separately in subdivision (19), are not in the statute's list. The statute text is from the 2025 Tennessee Code as reproduced commercially, and the Department of Revenue's Notice 24-05 describes the repeal. Live Tennessee articles in this library cover the franchise tax for real estate entities.
- Alabama. The tax reaches "every corporation, limited liability entity, and disregarded entity" (Ala. Code section 40-14A-22(a)). The net worth of a limited liability entity is the sum of the owners' capital accounts, "but not less than zero," measured on the first day of the entity's taxable year (section 40-14A-23(b)). A taxpayer may subtract "The book value of the investment by the taxpayer in the equity of any other taxpayer" when that other taxpayer is "doing business in Alabama" (section 40-14A-23(g)(1)). The Alabama Department of Revenue's 2026 instructions for Form PPT, the return for pass-through entities, list limited liability entities, including limited partnerships, as filers and general partnerships among the owners not subject to the tax. The code text is from a commercial reproduction of the 2025 Code of Alabama.
- Georgia. The net worth tax is based on "corporate net worth according to the following table," with a maximum of $5,000 for net worth over $22,000,000 (Ga. Code section 48-13-73, "Amount of corporate net worth tax; amount for taxable period less than six months," 2025 edition as reproduced commercially). The section applies to corporations, and nothing in it addresses partnership holdings.
- Texas. Another article in this library reports that the Texas franchise tax treats partnerships (general, limited and limited liability) as taxable entities, with an exception for general partnerships owned entirely by natural persons. That article, on lower-tier partnership factors, also describes an elective route under Tax Code section 171.1015 by which a lower tier that is not in a combined group reports total revenue to its upper tiers.
- Other states. Illinois, Louisiana, Mississippi and other states with a capital-based or franchise tax were not researched, and no statement about them is made here.
What remains open
The following points are not answered by any source found. Each is stated above in context.
- Whether a controlled LLC's attributed net worth joins the corporation's net worth before apportionment or is added afterward.
- Whether a limited partnership or a general partnership counts as a noncorporate limited liability company under section 105-114.1.
- Whether a corporation that carries a partnership interest on the equity method may reduce net worth by undistributed partnership earnings.
- How "taxable year" and "income year" relate in section 105-122.
- Whether the retroactive insurance company deduction in S.L. 2026-31, section 8.4, permits refund claims for closed years.
- Whether "the due date of the return" in section 105-241.6(a)(1) includes an extended due date.
- Whether any provision obliges a partnership to furnish the data described above.
- The act behind the change from a six-month to a seven-month extension of time to file, for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2025.
- The text of rule 05C .1702 at the official codifier.
- The method for computing an LLC's net worth for the attribution rule.
- Whether the Department has stated, for the franchise tax, that a corporate partner is doing business in the State.
- Whether a passive limited partnership interest is related to the operation of the taxpayer's trade or business on given facts.
- How the Department's application of the amended definition of apportionable income only to transactions after December 31, 2020 fits the 2017 act's effective date for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2017.
Worked example
Facts. A C corporation with a calendar year owns 40 percent of a limited partnership. The partnership owns one North Carolina warehouse. Its cost is $12,000,000, accumulated depreciation is $3,000,000 and the mortgage is $7,000,000, so net book value is $9,000,000 and, assuming the partnership has no other assets or liabilities, partnership equity is $2,000,000. The example assumes the corporation's carrying value of its interest is 40 percent of $2,000,000, or $800,000, which treats the mortgage as reducing the partnership's equity and so the carrying value. The corporation's own balance sheet shows total assets of $5,000,000 (including the $800,000) and liabilities of $1,000,000, none owed to an affiliate or to a noncorporate entity it controls, so the add-back of indebtedness under section 105-122(b)(2) is $0. It has no depreciable assets, so its net worth is $4,000,000. Its sales everywhere are $20,000,000, of which $3,000,000 are North Carolina sales. The partnership's rents from third-party tenants are $1,000,000, all North Carolina, and the corporation owns no North Carolina real or tangible property itself.
The factor assumption. The facts that make the partner's share of the partnership's sales count in the factor are these: the corporation's freight handling business uses part of the warehouse, and the corporation acquired the interest to secure that warehouse space. Those facts are assumed, and the same facts are assumed for the franchise tax year 2022 (reported on the 2021 return) and the franchise tax year 2025 (reported on the 2024 return). They are offered as satisfying the Department's wider reading, under which the interest is related to the operation of the corporation's trade or business, and the rule's "directly or integrally related" case. The rule's own words ask about the business of the partnership and the business of the partner, and no source found applies them to a limited partner that occupies part of the property, so the factor decision is the preparer's recorded judgment. The same decision classifies the corporation's share of the partnership's income for the corporate income tax.
Factor. The corporation's share of the partnership's sales is 40 percent of $1,000,000, or $400,000. The factor is ($3,000,000 + $400,000) divided by ($20,000,000 + $400,000), which is $3,400,000 divided by $20,400,000, or 16.6667 percent.
Apportioned net worth. $4,000,000 times 16.6667 percent is $666,667. The $800,000 investment stays in net worth, because no provision found removes it for a 40 percent interest in a limited partnership.
Franchise tax year 2022. The three bases are apportioned net worth of $666,667; 55 percent of the corporation's own appraised property, which is $0; and the corporation's own actual investment in tangible property, which is $0, because the warehouse is the partnership's. The greatest is $666,667. Tax is $666,667 divided by $1,000 times $1.50, or $1,000.00, which is above the $200 minimum.
Franchise tax year 2025. The base is $666,667. Tax at $1.50 per $1,000 would be $1,000.00, which exceeds the $500 maximum on the first $1,000,000 of base, so the tax is $500. That is the result under the rate text in force when the 2024 return was due (S.L. 2024-1) and under the 2026 rewrite. An S corporation in the same position would pay $200.
The alternative if the interest is not related to the corporation's business. If the facts show only an investment, with no use of the warehouse and no participation in its operation, the rule's starting point is nonapportionable income. The $400,000 leaves the factor, which becomes $3,000,000 divided by $20,000,000, or 15 percent. Apportioned net worth is $4,000,000 times 15 percent, or $600,000. The tax for the franchise tax year 2022 is $900.00 ($600,000 divided by $1,000 times $1.50), and the computed tax for the franchise tax year 2025 is $900.00, which is above the $500 maximum, so the tax is $500. The factor premise changes the 2022 tax from $1,000 to $900 and leaves the 2025 tax at $500.
What attributing the partnership's property would have done. Nothing in the statute attributes 40 percent of the warehouse to this partner, and doing so would have been an error that raised the 2022 tax. A preparer who used 40 percent of cost less reserve and less debt, $800,000, would have reported a base above $666,667 and a tax of $1,200. A preparer who used 40 percent of net book value, $3,600,000, would have reported a tax of $5,400. Neither figure belongs in the computation. The refund period for those errors has closed for a calendar-year corporation, as the refund section explains.
Variant: the corporation owns 60 percent of a noncorporate LLC instead. The assumptions are these, and no source found states them. The LLC's net worth is computed as the corporation would compute its own under section 105-122(b), by analogy, because section 105-114.1(b) says only "net worth" of the LLC. The LLC's book accumulated depreciation equals the federal-method reserve, $3,000,000. On those assumptions the LLC's net worth is assets of $12,000,000, without deducting accumulated depreciation, less liabilities of $7,000,000, less the accumulated depreciation deduction of $3,000,000, which is $2,000,000. The assumed county appraised value is $10,000,000, the calendar 2021 valuation for a return due in 2022. The corporation includes 60 percent of each item under section 105-114.1(b) and excludes its own investment in the LLC from net worth under subsection (d). To keep the arithmetic short, its other net worth is assumed to be $3,200,000. The LLC's rents are $1,000,000 from third parties, all in North Carolina, and the same relatedness assumption applies, so 60 percent, or $600,000, enters the factor: ($3,000,000 + $600,000) divided by ($20,000,000 + $600,000), which is 17.4757 percent.
The example adds the attributed LLC net worth to the corporation's net worth before apportionment, which is the placement the Department's published words support. The statute's words do not state the step.
- Franchise tax year 2022. The net worth side is ($3,200,000 + 60 percent times $2,000,000) times 17.4757 percent, or $4,400,000 times 17.4757 percent, which is $768,932. The appraised value base is 55 percent times $10,000,000 times 60 percent, or $3,300,000, attributed under clause (ii) of the pre-2023 subsection and not apportioned. The investment base is 60 percent times the cost of $12,000,000 less the reserve of $3,000,000 and less the real estate debt of $7,000,000, or $1,200,000. That base takes the LLC-level reserve and real estate debt reductions by analogy to the corporation's own investment base, because clause (iii) borrows "actual investment in tangible property in this State," which section 105-122(d)(3) defines for the reporting taxpayer, and no source found says the reductions apply at the LLC level. The 2018 bulletin's book-value cap on the debt reduction is met, since $7,000,000 of debt is below $9,000,000 of book value. The greatest base is $3,300,000, and the tax is $3,300,000 divided by $1,000 times $1.50, or $4,950. A preparer who used 60 percent of cost less reserve but not debt, $5,400,000, would have computed $8,100, and one who used 60 percent of gross cost, $7,200,000, would have computed $10,800. Both overstate the investment base, and here the overstatement would have changed the tax because each figure exceeds the true greatest base.
- Franchise tax year 2025. The base is the net worth side only, $768,932. Computed tax is $1,153.40, the $500 maximum applies, and the tax is $500.
- The other placement. If the attributed $1,200,000 were added after apportionment, the 2022 net worth side would be $3,200,000 times 17.4757 percent plus $1,200,000, or $1,759,223, still below the $3,300,000 appraised value base, so the 2022 tax stays $4,950. The 2025 base would be $1,759,223, and the tax would be $500 plus ($759,223 divided by $1,000 times $1.50, or $1,138.83), which is $1,638.83 and not $500. Under the same placement, if the interests were treated as unrelated (nonapportionable, factor 15 percent), the Department's placement gives a net worth side of $660,000 and a 2025 tax of $500, and the other placement gives $1,680,000 and a 2025 tax of $1,520.00. The 2022 tax is $4,950 in each of those cases.
What the example shows and leaves out. It shows that a minority corporate partner pays on its book investment, apportioned by a sales factor that depends on a recorded relatedness judgment, and that a controlling LLC owner adds the LLC's net worth to its own, with a different tax under the two placements from 2025. It leaves out interest on any refund, any alternative apportionment request, an affiliated group's allocation and any state other than North Carolina.
Practice notes
Confirm what entities the corporation owns, directly and through other entities, before asking for any property data. Section 105-114.1 attaches only to a noncorporate limited liability company, so identify whether the entity is an LLC or a partnership that is not an LLC, and add the holdings of the corporation's affiliated group to the corporation's own before testing the 50 percent line. Count ownership by capital interest under the entity's governing law, through each intermediate entity, on the last day of the LLC's taxable year.
Request the data in writing and in time for the return. From each partnership, ask for the corporate partner's carrying value of the interest at the close of the corporate partner's income year, the capital interest percentage and not only the profit percentage, the partnership's North Carolina sales by type of receipt, and the facts that bear on whether the interest is related to the partner's trade or business. For an LLC above 50 percent, add the LLC's net worth computed as the corporation would compute its own under section 105-122(b), absent a published method, its assets' book value for the $150,000 test, and its capital interest holders. No source found obliges the partnership to furnish these, so place the obligation in the partnership agreement or in a written side agreement.
Do not rely on Schedule K-1 Items J, K1 and L for the franchise tax. They give a capital percentage, a share of liabilities and tax-basis capital. They do not give book carrying value or property-level cost, depreciation or debt.
Record the factor decision and its facts. Document whether the partnership interest is related to the operation of the corporate partner's trade or business, whether the partner takes part in the day-to-day operation, and the resulting treatment of the partner's share of the partnership's sales. Apply the same decision to the corporate income tax. When an alternative apportionment is worth requesting, calendar the 90 days after the regular or extended due date and the $5,000 fee.
Record whether the corporation excluded its investment in an LLC whose net worth it attributes, and in which step the attributed amount entered, so that the return does not count the same equity twice. Test the placement against the Department's published words and record the position taken.
For every franchise tax year beginning in 2025 or later, test whether the $500 maximum on the first $1,000,000 of base produced the correct tax before accepting a computed amount at $1.50 per $1,000, and confirm whether the corporation is a C corporation or an S corporation, because an S corporation pays $200 on the first $1,000,000.
For a franchise tax year before 2023, file any amended return or claim for refund within section 105-241.6, and treat the two-years-after-payment period, with its two-year amount limit, as the only period likely to remain. Use the amended return or claim route in section 105-241.7(b), and check the conditions of any federal determination or contingent event extension before relying on it. Keep a dated record of the reasons a property-base year is closed or open.
Ask the Department in writing when the treatment of an equity-method partnership investment, or the placement of an attributed LLC net worth, changes the tax materially. The Department's published words are the only authority on both points, and neither answers them directly.
G&G State Tax Group advises corporations and partnerships on state franchise and net worth taxes, corporate partner data packages, apportionment classification and refund claims alongside its state and local tax practice.
This article states the law as of November 11, 2026
Statutes, rates, thresholds, and agency practice change, and a different set of facts can change the answer. Before acting on anything discussed above, contact G&G State Tax Group, or another state and local tax adviser, to confirm what has changed since this was written and how the rules apply to a specific situation.
This publication is informational in nature and is not, and should not be considered, legal, accounting, tax, or other professional advice for any person or situation. Correct application of tax law depends heavily on the facts and circumstances in each case, and G&G State Tax Group, LLC assumes no liability in connection with the use of this information, and is not obligated to inform any reader of changes in the law or other factors that could affect the information contained herein.
