Skip to main content
Direct +1 949.864.9199 Office +1 714.234.5538 info@gandgsalt.com
G&G State Tax Group

MultistateIncome and franchise tax

Which payroll withholding traps does an employer miss when employees live in one state and work for an office in another?

The short answer

A reciprocal agreement ends only the work state's income tax withholding on wages, and only after the employee gives the employer that state's certificate. The agreements do not reach the Philadelphia Wage Tax, Pennsylvania's local earned income tax, Ohio municipal income taxes, Indiana county taxes or the Maryland county tax withheld from a Pennsylvania resident. Whether the employer must then withhold home-state tax depends on that state's law: New Jersey requires withholding unless three conditions are met, Virginia treats withholding as the resident's request, and Massachusetts excuses an employer whose only connection is a resident working elsewhere. In New Hampshire v. Massachusetts the Supreme Court of the United States denied leave to file a bill of complaint on June 28, 2021, so there is no merits ruling, and since 2021 Massachusetts sources a nonresident's wages by days worked in Massachusetts. New York, Pennsylvania and Delaware tax a nonresident's wages for days worked at home the employer did not require, and a New York withholding employer must adjust for them even if IT-2104.1 understates them. For a Connecticut resident on a New York payroll, both states can withhold on the same wages until the credit is claimed on the Connecticut return.

Working through this on a live matter? Contact the firm

A reciprocal agreement starts with the employee's certificate

A reciprocal agreement between two states does nothing by itself. The employee gives the employer the work state's certificate, and that state's withholding then stops. The certificate names matter because payroll systems are keyed on them:

  • Pennsylvania: Form REV-419, the Employee's Nonwithholding Application Certificate. The form's note says that, unless the state of residence changes, residents of the reciprocal states "do not need to refile this application every year." The instructions separately tell the employee to revoke the certification within 10 days of the day the employee anticipates owing Pennsylvania personal income tax for the year. The form does not mention local taxes, Philadelphia or earned income tax.
  • New Jersey: Form NJ-165, the Employee's Certificate of Nonresidence in New Jersey, which a Pennsylvania resident gives a New Jersey employer. The employer keeps it, because the form says "Do not forward this Form to the Division of Taxation." A different 10-day duty sits on this form: an employee who changes residence from Pennsylvania to any other state must notify the employer within 10 days. The form does not mention local taxes.
  • Virginia: Form VA-4, which a resident of a reciprocity state employed in Virginia completes to certify the exemption. The Virginia Department of Taxation's page adds that the exemption must be re-certified every year.
  • Maryland: Form MW507, the Employee Maryland Withholding Exemption Certificate, which the Comptroller's 2026 withholding guide still names for an employee who certifies residence in a reciprocal state. The 2026 certificate instructions that were read are the state-payroll copy, printed as "2026 MARYLAND FORM MWH", so the name of the general 2026 certificate is one to confirm on the Comptroller's current forms page before a payroll file is keyed to it.
  • Ohio: Form IT 4, the Employee's Withholding Exemption Certificate. The Department of Taxation's reciprocity page names IT 4 and not IT 4NR. The Department's alert on the revised form says it "replaces" the IT 4NR, Employees' Statement of Residency in a Reciprocity State, for new hires and for employees making withholding updates on or after December 7, 2020, and that an employee with a valid IT 4NR on file need not complete the updated form unless reporting a change to the information previously provided.
  • Indiana: Form WH-47, the Certificate of Residence, named in the Department of Revenue's Income Tax Information Bulletin 33 (December 2024).
  • New York: Form IT-2104.1 is not a reciprocal certificate at all. It is an allocation certificate on which a nonresident states the percentage of services performed in New York, and it is treated in the section on the stacked paycheck below.

The two 10-day duties on the Pennsylvania and New Jersey forms differ in kind: the Pennsylvania one is a revocation by an employee who expects to owe Pennsylvania tax, and the New Jersey one is a notice of a move. Each is calendared as its own form states it.

The next question is the home state's withholding, and the sources do not make it an automatic consequence of the certificate:

  • Pennsylvania makes the home-state withholding a condition of its own relief. The Department of Revenue's Personal Income Tax Guide says that no Pennsylvania withholding is required for a resident of a reciprocal state who works in Pennsylvania "provided an REV-419, Employee's Nonwithholding Application Certificate" "is filed by the employee with the Pennsylvania employer and the Pennsylvania employer withholds" "the income tax of that state in which the employee resides." On the Department's words, the Pennsylvania employer that does not withhold the home state's tax has not met the condition on which Pennsylvania withholding stops. The Guide also says that an out-of-state employer of a Pennsylvania resident withholds Pennsylvania tax if it has a requirement to do so and otherwise "may elect to withhold Pennsylvania personal income tax."
  • Virginia states the resident's side as a request: a Virginia resident who works in a reciprocity state and meets the criteria asks the employer to withhold Virginia tax and, if the employer will not, asks that no tax be withheld and makes estimated payments to Virginia.
  • Indiana's bulletin says employers "are not required to withhold Indiana adjusted gross income tax from qualified nonresidents" and are "encouraged to withhold the appropriate taxes on behalf of the state where the employee resides."
  • Massachusetts says that an employer whose only connection to Massachusetts is the employment of a Massachusetts resident outside Massachusetts does not have to withhold, and may withhold for the employee's convenience if both agree.
  • New Jersey is the contrast. The Division of Taxation's withholding instructions, NJ-WT, say an employer is "not obligated to withhold New Jersey Income Tax if a New Jersey resident meets all three" conditions: the resident is "Employed totally outside New Jersey;" is "Subject to the withholding tax of that state; and" the withholdings required by that state "equal or exceed the withholdings required for New Jersey." If the employee works only part of the time out of state, or the other state's rate is lower, the instructions tell the employer to withhold New Jersey tax in addition to the other state's, to offset the employee's resident liability. For a New Jersey resident working in New Jersey the instructions require the employer to register, file and pay. For a New Jersey resident who works in Pennsylvania, they say the employer should withhold for the state where the employee lives.

The rule that follows is narrower than the usual shorthand. The certificate ends the work state's withholding. Whether the employer must then withhold the home state's tax depends on the home state's law and on the employer's connection with that state. Where there is no connection, withholding for the home state is by agreement, and the employee otherwise pays estimated tax. In payroll terms the practical result is not always a registration in the home state: it is one for a New Jersey resident who works in New Jersey, and it is a condition of Pennsylvania's relief, but it is not the result in every pair.

What an agreement covers and what it leaves out

An agreement covers the work state's state-level income tax on the wages of a resident of the partner state. It does not cover income other than wages. Indiana's bulletin says its agreements bar Indiana adjusted gross income tax on the "salaries, wages, tips, and commissions" of residents of reciprocal states who work in Indiana, and that income from other sources is subject to the tax. New Jersey's reciprocal agreement page tells a resident of Pennsylvania with self-employment or other income taxable in both states to file a New Jersey nonresident return and report it. An agreement stops no withholding before the certificate is on file; tax withheld before then is recovered by return.

Three refund routes follow from the certificate rule. A Pennsylvania resident whose wages were withheld on by New Jersey stops the withholding with Form NJ-165 and files a New Jersey nonresident return to recover the tax. A New Jersey resident whose employer withheld Pennsylvania income tax stops the withholding with Form REV-419EX, the New Jersey page's name for the Pennsylvania form, and files a Pennsylvania return to get a refund. For Virginia, the Department's page tells a nonresident whose employer withheld Virginia tax to correct the withholding for the future and file Form 763-S to claim a refund.

One trap follows from the New Jersey side. The Division of Taxation's credit bulletin for wage income (GIT-3W, January 2026) says: "We do not allow a credit for taxes paid in error to Pennsylvania on employee compensation." A New Jersey resident whose Pennsylvania state tax was withheld by mistake therefore has one remedy, the Pennsylvania refund, and no New Jersey credit to offset it.

Conditions vary by pair. Virginia ties its exemptions to limits that run in both directions: a Virginia resident working in Maryland, Pennsylvania or West Virginia must be present in that state 183 days or less, maintain no abode there and receive only wage or salary income there, and residents of the District of Columbia and Kentucky are exempt in Virginia if they are taxed in their home states, commute to Virginia every day and receive only wage or salary income there. Maryland's Tax Tip 56 ties its exemptions for residents of the District of Columbia, Virginia and Pennsylvania to not living in Maryland more than six months, and exempts a West Virginia resident regardless of how long the resident lives in Maryland. A certificate is therefore one input, and the employee's days and abode are another.

The pairs read

The list below holds only the pairs read at a department's own page or withholding guide in preparing this article. Other agreements exist and are checked at the work state's own withholding guide, and the Illinois pairs are carried by the library's article on withholding and unemployment insurance for employees who work in more than one state.

  • Pennsylvania with Indiana, Maryland, New Jersey, Ohio, Virginia and West Virginia, by the Department of Revenue's Personal Income Tax Guide and Form REV-419.
  • New Jersey with Pennsylvania only: the Division's withholding page says that, under a reciprocal agreement, Pennsylvania residents are the only "residents exempt from New Jersey withholdings" among out-of-state residents, and that once the employee gives the employer a completed Certificate of Nonresidence the employer stops withholding New Jersey tax.
  • Virginia with the District of Columbia, Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and West Virginia, by the Department of Taxation's reciprocity page.
  • Maryland with the District of Columbia, Pennsylvania, Virginia and West Virginia, by Tax Tip 56. For a Pennsylvania resident the exemption reaches the state portion only, as the next section explains.
  • Ohio with Michigan, Indiana, Kentucky, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, by the Department of Taxation's reciprocity page.
  • Indiana with Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, by Bulletin 33.

Kentucky's, Michigan's, Wisconsin's, Minnesota's and the District of Columbia's own certificates were not read, so no certificate name is given for them here.

Local taxes the agreements do not reach

The agreements do not reach local taxes, and the sources say so in several places. The New Jersey Division of Taxation states it in its withholding instructions: "The reciprocal agreement does not excuse a Pennsylvania employer from withholding local wage taxes imposed by cities, towns, or other localities in Pennsylvania for New Jersey resident employees." Its credit bulletin says the New Jersey and Pennsylvania agreement "does not apply to the income or wage tax imposed and collected by the City of Philadelphia or any other municipality in Pennsylvania." Indiana's bulletin says residents of reciprocal states "are subject to LIT in the same manner as residents of nonreciprocal states," LIT being Indiana's county income tax.

Maryland shows the same pattern from the work-state side. A Pennsylvania resident's certificate exempts the employee from the state portion only: the 2026 instructions say these employees "should complete line 5 to exempt themselves from the state portion of the withholding tax," and that they are "still liable for withholding tax at the rate in effect for the Maryland county in which they are employed," unless they qualify for an exemption on line 6 or line 7. Pennsylvania residents of York and Adams counties may claim an exemption from the local withholding by completing line 6. Tax Tip 56 adds that residents of certain Pennsylvania cities and townships that tax the wages of Maryland residents may have to file Maryland Form 515.

For Pennsylvania and Ohio the forms are silent. The REV-419 and the NJ-165 do not mention local taxes. The older Ohio certificate, Form IT 4NR (Rev. 5/07), has the employee claim "exemption from withholding of Ohio income tax" on compensation paid in Ohio and does not mention municipal income tax, and the revised IT 4 reciprocity line was not read. No Ohio department or municipal statement that the state agreements do not reach municipal income tax was found, so the article rests the Ohio point on the statute: section 718.03(A)(1) of the Ohio Revised Code directs each employer "located or doing business in a municipal corporation that imposes a tax on income" to withhold from each employee tax on the qualifying wages "earned by the employee in the municipal corporation," and the section as read lists no exception for a resident of a reciprocal state.

The next sections take the local taxes one at a time: the Philadelphia Wage Tax, Pennsylvania's local earned income tax under Act 32, Ohio's municipal income taxes, and the other local taxes read.

The Philadelphia Wage Tax and days worked at home

The Philadelphia Department of Revenue's Wage Tax page for employers lists the rates. The nonresident rate was 3.43 percent for the period from July 1, 2025 and is 3.425 percent from July 1, 2026; the resident rate went from 3.74 percent to 3.735 percent on the same dates. A 2026 payroll year therefore straddles two rates, and the example below carries each half of the year separately. The page also says: "All employers located in Pennsylvania are required to register with the City of Philadelphia" within 30 days of becoming an employer of a covered employee. By its words that sentence reaches an employer located in Pennsylvania, and it does not on its face reach an employer with no Pennsylvania location.

Pennsylvania's Department of Community and Economic Development (DCED) states the nonresident rule in its local withholding FAQ: "Employers are required to withhold the Philadelphia non-resident rate for employees who work in Philadelphia, but live outside of Philadelphia." The same part of the answer says "Remittances are made directly to the Department of Revenue." No state reciprocal agreement removes this tax, as the previous section showed.

Required days and days by choice

The City's question for a nonresident employee of a Philadelphia employer who works away from the City is whether the employer required it. The Department's policy guidance on nonresident employees in the era of remote work, updated October 12, 2023, states what it calls the Requirement of Employment policy: the compensation of a nonresident who works for a Philadelphia-based employer is not subject to the Wage Tax during the time the employee is required to work remotely from a location outside Philadelphia, including at home. It states the converse in these words: "If an employer allows an employee to work from home, at the convenience and discretion of the employee", the compensation is subject to the Wage Tax.

The examples in the guidance draw the line:

  • An employee required to work at a client's site is not taxed for those days, and "the employer can modify Wage Tax withholding."
  • Where the employer has limited workstations and the employee works from home on that account, the guidance says: "If the employer withholds tax on 100% of the employee's compensation, the non-resident employee may apply" "for a refund of Wage Tax for the days worked from home."
  • A home day is taxable only if the employee could have worked in the Philadelphia office. The guidance says: "An employee must have either dedicated work space or the option to work regularly" "in the Philadelphia office in order to be taxable."
  • A written policy that requires the employees to work in the Philadelphia office two days each week, and adds that "Employees may come into the office more often if they wish," does not make the other days required. Because the policy lets the employee come in as often as the employee likes, the guidance treats the employee as subject to the Wage Tax for the days worked from home as well.
  • An employee required to work from home out of necessity is not taxed for those days. In one example the Philadelphia office is not wheelchair accessible, the employee uses a wheelchair and the employer lets the employee work exclusively from home, and the guidance concludes that, out of necessity, the employee is obligated to perform the duties from the personal residence outside Philadelphia. In another, the employer's written policy requires employees with underlying medical conditions to work from home, and the guidance concludes that the employee is not subject to the Wage Tax for the home days. The example about child care reaches the opposite result. The employer's policy allows employees with child care issues to work from home only with manager approval, and the guidance says: "The employer's policy does not establish a work from home requirement." It adds that child care issues are particular to the employee, so the Department considers working from home for child care reasons to be at the convenience of the employee.
  • An employee assigned to the Philadelphia office for administrative purposes only, who works entirely from home outside the City and rarely visits the office, is not taxed.

The Department's reading of its own policy, as the guidance's words support it (Philadelphia's likely position), is that every home day that is not required by the employer is taxable, that permission is not requirement, and that a written hybrid policy fixing two office days but leaving the office open on other days does not make the other days required. An employer that reduces withholding at payroll takes the Department's test on itself, and bears the withholding exposure if the days are later found to have been worked by choice. That consequence is reasoning from the policy, not a statement the guidance makes.

The route for required days

The route is first a withholding matter. The guidance says the employer can modify Wage Tax withholding for days the employee was required to work outside the City. If the employer instead withholds on all pay, the employee recovers the tax after the end of the tax year: the guidance says the nonresident employees "can request a refund" for Wage Tax withheld "during the time they were required to perform their duties from outside of Philadelphia" "by filing a Wage Tax refund petition," and that "Employees file for a refund after the end of the tax year and will need to provide documentation." The documentation includes the employee's W-2 and a signed letter from the employer on company letterhead certifying the requirement, and the guidance adds a date and location worksheet for a paper petition.

The 2025 refund petition for salaried employees adds the deadline and the calculation. Its statute of limitations line says that "any claim for refund must be filed within three (3) years from the date" "the tax was paid, or due, whichever date is later." The days outside the City go on Line 2D, "Number of actual Days/Hours worked outside of Philadelphia in Line 2C," with a list of dates and locations attached that the employer has verified and signed, and Line 2E divides Line 2D by Line 2C and rounds the percentage to four decimal places. The petition also says: "A nonresident who works remotely for the sake of his or her convenience is not exempt from the Wage Tax, even with the employer's authorization."

The guidance and the petition differ on one point of procedure. The policy guidance says employees file for the refund after the end of the tax year, and its employer certification template, as the Department posts it, has the employer's authorized official certify that the employee was required to work outside Philadelphia on the dates reported. The petition form says that a petition for refund of erroneously withheld wage tax "must be made by the employer for and on behalf of the employee," cites General Regulations Section 306(2) for it, carries both an employer and an employee signature line, and tells the authorizing official to sign only with knowledge of the employee's whereabouts. The article states both documents' words and does not decide between them. The consequence for setup is the same either way: the payroll file needs a day-level record of why the employee was outside the City, because the employee's own statement does not support the petition.

The New Jersey credit for the Wage Tax

For a New Jersey resident the Wage Tax is a credit item on the New Jersey return. The Division of Taxation's bulletin GIT-3W defines the jurisdictions whose tax can be credited as "any state of the United States other than New Jersey, a political subdivision (e.g., county or municipality) of any state other than New Jersey, or the District of Columbia," and says the reciprocal agreement "does not apply to the income or wage tax imposed and collected by the City of Philadelphia or any other municipality in Pennsylvania." The bulletin's Philadelphia method has the resident divide the wage tax deducted, as reported in the Local income tax box of the W-2, by the Philadelphia nonresident tax rate to find the income for line 1 of Schedule NJ-COJ, and the amount on line 1 "cannot be more than the amount of Philadelphia wages included on line 15, Form NJ-1040." A separate Schedule NJ-COJ is completed for each jurisdiction or each tax imposed by a jurisdiction. A Philadelphia refund petition reduces the tax that may be credited, so the credit base falls by the refund. The statute allows the credit for "any income tax or wage tax imposed for the taxable year by another state of the United States or political subdivision of such state, or by the District of Columbia," and caps it at "the proportion of the tax otherwise due under this act that the amount of the taxpayer's income subject to tax by the other jurisdiction bears to his entire New Jersey income" (New Jersey Statutes Annotated, N.J.S.A., section 54A:4-1, read at a Justia mirror of the statute). The credit is claimed by return, never at payroll.

Two points were not found in the sources read. Whether the Division accepts Philadelphia-taxed wages for New Jersey home days worked by choice as income also taxed by the other jurisdiction is not stated in the bulletin as read. And the New Jersey rule that fixes the employer's New Jersey withholding is separate from the credit: it appears in the example below.

Pennsylvania outside Philadelphia: the Act 32 earned income tax

Outside Philadelphia, Pennsylvania's local earned income tax is the Act 32 system, and DCED publishes the withholding FAQ that the employer works from. DCED's FAQ says an employee's local earned income tax rate is set by comparing the employee's total resident rate, for the municipality where the employee lives, with the work location nonresident rate, for the municipality where the employee works: the rate owed and to be withheld is always the higher of the two rates. The employer is told to withhold that higher rate, with the Local Services Tax, and to remit to the local tax collector for the worksite location. The employee's residency information comes from a form: DCED's Residency Certification Form for local earned income tax withholding (CLGS-32-6, 05/17) says it "must be used by employers when a new employee is hired or when a current employee notifies" the "employer of a name or address change." The employer records the employee's resident political subdivision code, known as the PSD code, at hire and on a move.

For an employee who lives out of state, DCED's FAQ says the resident PSD code is 880000 and the total resident earned income tax rate is 0 percent. A New Jersey resident working at a Pennsylvania site outside Philadelphia therefore carries the 880000 code and a 0 percent resident rate, and the employer withholds the work location's nonresident rate. Employers also withhold the Local Services Tax, which this article does not cover. The state reciprocal agreement is irrelevant to this tax, for the reasons in the previous sections.

Allocation among municipalities is the point at which the FAQ stops. For an employee on temporary job assignments, DCED says the employer withholds the greater of the employee's resident tax or the employee's nonresident tax, and the nonresident tax is based on the location of the employer's permanent home office for an employee working fewer than 90 consecutive days at a job location, and on the job location for 90 or more consecutive days. The FAQ states no day-by-day allocation for an employee with two fixed Pennsylvania worksites, and the article states none.

DCED also treats a home-based employee's residence as a business site. The FAQ says "Examples of business sites include but are not limited to factories, warehouses, offices and" "residences of home-based employees." In its answer on registration, DCED tells an employer that it does not need to register with the local tax collectors for its employees' home municipalities unless it has employees who work from home, which establishes additional worksite locations. An employer with employees who work from home in a Pennsylvania municipality therefore registers with that municipality's collector. An out-of-state employer, by contrast, is not required to withhold the local earned income tax for a Pennsylvania resident, and DCED says the employer may withhold the resident rate as a courtesy; a Pennsylvania resident whose out-of-state employer does not withhold owes quarterly estimated payments to the home municipality's collector.

Two points are open on the sources read. DCED's FAQ page does not state how a Pennsylvania resident's earned income tax interacts with a tax the resident also pays to a work municipality: the page uses no credit order in its answers, and the Local Tax Enabling Act and the Sterling Act were not read. And DCED states its 90-day rule for temporary assignments only. The library's article on withholding and unemployment insurance for employees who work in more than one state describes a residence-state rule, from California's law, under which the residence state reduces its withholding by the work state's tax. That rule is not carried over here to the hybrid home worker, because DCED's FAQ directs the higher of two Pennsylvania rates and does not speak to a credit.

Ohio municipal income taxes

Ohio's municipal income tax is withheld by work location under section 718.011 of the Ohio Revised Code, and the statute answers how days worked at home are counted. It has no telework rule of its own.

Division (B)(1), subject to divisions (C), (E), (F) and (G), says that an employer is not required to withhold municipal income tax on qualifying wages paid for personal services in a taxing municipal corporation if the employee performed the services there on "twenty or fewer days in a calendar year," unless the municipality is the employee's principal place of work, the employee performed services at one or more presumed worksite locations there, a resident employee has asked the employer to withhold, or the employee is a professional athlete, entertainer or public figure. Division (B)(2) adds that a day counts for a municipality only if the employee spent more time working for the employer there than in any other municipality that day.

The principal place of work is defined in three tiers in division (A)(7): "the fixed location to which an employee is required to report for employment duties on a regular and ordinary basis"; if there is none, the worksite location in Ohio to which the employee is required to report; and if there is none of either, "the location in this state at which the employee spends the greatest number of days" in a calendar year performing services for the employer. The test is "required to report," not where the employee in fact reports. An employee who is not required to report to the office falls to the most-days tier, which for a full-time home worker is the home. A "worksite location," under division (A)(6), "does not include the home of an employee." That sentence bears on the second tier and on the presumed-worksite exception. It does not change the next rule, which counts home days as days of performing personal services in the home municipality.

Division (D)(1) supplies the rule for those days. Once the days an employee spends performing personal services in a municipal corporation exceed "the twenty-day threshold described in division (B)(1) of this section, the employer shall withhold and remit tax" to that municipal corporation for the later days in that calendar year on which the employer pays qualifying wages for personal services performed there. Division (C) adds a condition for the office municipality: where the employee's principal place of work is in a taxing municipality, the twenty-day exception applies only if the employer withholds and remits tax on the qualifying wages to that municipality.

An employee who is required to report to an office in one Ohio taxing municipality and works at home in a different one illustrates the rule. The employer withholds for the office municipality from the first day. The first twenty home days need no withholding for the home municipality, and under division (C) that relief holds only if the employer is withholding the same wages for the office municipality. From the twenty-first home day, division (D)(1) says the employer shall withhold and remit tax to the home municipality for the later days. At three home days a week the twenty-first day falls in the seventh week, since 3 times 7 is 21.

The small employer rule is mandatory. Division (E) says that, "Without regard to the number of days in a calendar year on which an employee performs personal services" in any municipal corporation, a small employer withholds municipal income tax on all of the employee's qualifying wages for the taxable year and remits it only to the municipal corporation in which the employer's fixed location is located. Section 718.01 defines a small employer as an employer that "had total revenue of less than five hundred thousand dollars during the preceding taxable year."

The municipality's reading

The home municipality's likely position, from the statute's words, is that an employer with no office in the employee's home city has a withholding duty there once the twenty-day threshold is passed. Section 718.03(A)(1) directs each employer "located or doing business in a municipal corporation that imposes a tax on income" to withhold tax on the qualifying wages of the employee "earned by the employee in the municipal corporation." Division (G) makes an employer required to withhold liable for the payment of the amount required to be withheld, and division (E)(1) provides that an employee "is not relieved from liability for a tax by the failure of the employer" to withhold. Whether one employee at home is "doing business" in the home municipality is the employer's argument, not a statutory exemption. The registration consequence follows: every Ohio taxing municipality in which an employee works more than twenty days, the home municipality included, is a withholding point, unless the employer is a small employer under division (E). The article does not address the net profit tax election, which is a different subject.

The 2020 and 2021 temporary rule

Ohio's temporary rule, Section 29 of House Bill 197, treated an emergency-driven home day as a day at the principal place of work. The Supreme Court of Ohio upheld it on February 14, 2024, in Schaad v. Alder, 2024-Ohio-525 (No. 2022-0316), five to two. The majority held that Section 29 "does not violate the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, and was a valid exercise of the General Assembly's constitutional authority," and affirmed. The Chief Justice and Justice Fischer each dissented in a written opinion.

House Bill 110 reinstated the rule. The Legislative Service Commission's analysis of the enrolled act, which is an analysis and not the statute, says the rule expired on July 18, 2021, that the act reinstates and extends it through December 31, 2021, and that from January 1, 2021 the rule applies only for purposes of municipal income tax withholding and the situsing of an employer's net profits, not for determining the employee's actual tax liability. The enrolled text itself was not read.

The refund route today is the municipal tax administrator under section 718.19. Division (B)(1) says that, except as otherwise provided in the chapter, requests for refund are filed with the tax administrator on the prescribed form "within three years after the tax return, including any valid extension, was due or paid, whichever is later." A new request for 2021 tax is therefore out of time unless the tax was paid later, and the temporary rule matters now only for claims filed in time and still pending with an administrator or on appeal. For 2026, the rule is section 718.011 as described above.

Other local taxes read

Only jurisdictions read at an official source are listed. For each, the state agreements reviewed do not mention local taxes, and where a source says in terms that an agreement does not reach it, the earlier sections give the words.

  • Philadelphia: residents and nonresidents who work for a Philadelphia employer; the employer withholds, and the City's rules on required days govern nonresidents (see above).
  • Pennsylvania Act 32 municipalities: residents by the home rate and nonresidents by the work rate, with the higher of the two withheld and remitted to the work location's collector (see above).
  • Maryland counties: the employer withholds the county rate for the county of employment from a Pennsylvania resident unless line 6 or line 7 of the certificate applies.
  • Ohio municipalities: withheld by work location under section 718.011, with the twenty-day rule and the small employer rule (see above).
  • Indiana counties: for an out-of-state resident whose principal place of work is in an Indiana county as of January 1, the county tax at that county's rate. Departmental Notice 1, effective October 1, 2026, lists rates such as Hamilton 0.011, Marion 0.0202 and Lake 0.015, and says an employer is not required to withhold state or county income tax on some employees if the employee will work in Indiana 30 days or less during the taxable year. The notice says: "An asterisk (*) beside a county name indicates the rate has changed since Departmental Notice #1 was published on Jan. 1, 2026." One county carries the asterisk, Boone, at 0.0171.
  • Kansas City, Missouri: the city's earnings tax is a 1 percent tax on an individual's earned income such as salaries, wages, commissions, tips and other compensation. Residents owe it wherever they work, and nonresidents owe it on income earned within the city limits. The Revenue Division's FAQ says an employer should withhold the earnings tax for an employee who works in the city, that businesses with employees in the city are subject to local taxes including "earnings tax withholding and business licensing," and that "If any portion of a day is worked within Kansas City, Missouri, that day would not be considered" a day worked outside the City. Refund requests for the wage earner and profits taxes beginning with tax year 2022 "must be filed by the" "15th day of the 4th month after the end of its tax year." A nonresident completing Form RD-109NR is required to obtain the employer's signature. The Revenue Division's FAQ names the Employer's Quarterly Return of Earnings Withheld (Form RD-110) and says employers withholding earnings tax must file an annual reconciliation (Form RD-113). The ordinance and the forms were not read. The Kansas City Revenue Division's likely position, from its FAQ, is that a partly worked day is a city day, that the employer signs the nonresident refund form, and that the refund deadline is the return date, so an employer that withholds on all pay for a hybrid nonresident leaves the employee a short window.
  • Yonkers, New York: the nonresident earnings tax. The Tax Department's publication on Yonkers withholding for 2026 says "The Yonkers nonresident earnings tax rate is .50%," effective January 1 through December 31, 2026, and describes three methods for employees residing outside Yonkers who earn wages in Yonkers, "paid by an employer maintaining an office or transacting business within New York State."
  • New York City: the City's personal income tax reaches residents only. The Tax Department's FAQ says nonresidents of the City are not liable, so a Connecticut or New Jersey resident on a Manhattan payroll has no City withholding.

Kentucky occupational license taxes, Detroit and the other Michigan cities, and St. Louis were not read and are left out.

What New Hampshire v. Massachusetts settled for remote workers

Nothing, on the merits. Massachusetts adopted an emergency rule in 2020, 830 CMR (Code of Massachusetts Regulations) 62.5A.3, "Massachusetts Source Income of Non-Residents Telecommuting due to the COVID-19 Pandemic." Under it, all compensation received by a nonresident who, immediately before the Massachusetts state of emergency, was engaged in performing services in Massachusetts, and who was performing services from a location outside Massachusetts because of a pandemic-related circumstance, "will continue to be treated as Massachusetts source income subject to personal income tax" and to withholding. An employee who had apportioned by days worked in Massachusetts kept apportioning, on the percentage of work days in Massachusetts from January 1 through February 29, 2020, or on the 2019 apportionment percentage if the employee worked for the same employer in 2019. The regulation applied to services "performed commencing March 10, 2020 through 90 days after the date on which the Governor" of the Commonwealth gives notice that the Massachusetts COVID-19 state of emergency is no longer in effect.

New Hampshire's motion for leave to file a bill of complaint against Massachusetts in the Supreme Court of the United States, No. 22O154, was filed October 19, 2020. On January 25, 2021, the Court invited the Acting Solicitor General to file a brief expressing the views of the United States, which was filed May 25, 2021. The brief said: "In the view of the United States, the motion for leave to file a bill of complaint should be denied." It called the case "a facial constitutional challenge to a temporary Massachusetts tax rule," said the rule "will expire shortly after the pandemic-related emergency ends," and said that "individuals who are subject to Massachusetts income tax may file an abatement request," with further review by the Appellate Tax Board and then judicial review in state court available. The June 28, 2021 docket entry reads: "Motion for leave to file a bill of complaint DENIED." and "Justice Thomas and Justice Alito would grant the motion."

A denial of leave to file a bill of complaint is not a ruling on the merits. The order gives no reasons, so the case settled nothing about whether a state may source a nonresident's home-state wages to the employer's location, and the denial is not a finding against Massachusetts either. The regulation stayed in force for its whole period, and for a 2020 or 2021 return still open the Department of Revenue's position is the regulation's.

The Massachusetts emergency was declared March 10, 2020 and "terminated on June 15, 2021." The Department of Revenue's September 2021 news item says "Until September 13, 2021, emergency pandemic income sourcing rules were in place," and that after that date pay for nonresident employees is sourced to where they perform their work. June 15 plus 90 days is September 13, 2021 (15 plus 31 plus 31 plus 13 is 90).

The Massachusetts rule now

Massachusetts sources a nonresident's pay by where the work is done. The regulation, 830 CMR 62.5A.1, dated 01/03/2025 on the Commonwealth's regulations page, says: "All types of compensation received for personal services performed in Massachusetts, regardless of where paid, are Massachusetts source income." Where the exact pay for Massachusetts work cannot be established, a day fraction applies, with the number of days spent working in Massachusetts over total working days. For a day worked partly in Massachusetts, paragraph (5)(a) says: "When a working day is spent working partly in Massachusetts and partly elsewhere, it will be treated as a day spent working in Massachusetts, unless the non-resident can prove that he or she worked outside Massachusetts for more than half the day." As of November 13, 2026, the regulation contains no convenience or necessity rule: its twelve sections, from General to Effective Dates, never use those words. It has its own example of a telecommuter: "A telecommuter works for a Massachusetts firm, mainly out of her home in Ohio," works 240 days, is in Massachusetts on 60 of them, and earns $120,000, and "Her Massachusetts source income is $30,000." A nonresident whose Massachusetts source income exceeds $8,000, or the personal exemption to which the nonresident is entitled after apportionment, whichever is the lesser, must file a nonresident return.

The employer's side is a separate regulation. Under 830 CMR 62B.2.1 (date of promulgation June 5, 2026), "Employers that maintain an office or transact business within Massachusetts and that make payment of wages taxable to a resident or nonresident individual shall deduct and withhold a tax from such wages for each payroll period," in an amount "substantially equivalent to the tax amount reasonably anticipated to be due." The Department's guide for employers says the employer still needs to withhold wages paid to a nonresident "for services performed in Massachusetts." What the June 2026 text changed from the prior version was not read.

For a New Hampshire resident who works four of five days at home in New Hampshire for a Boston office, New Hampshire taxes no wages: its Department of Revenue Administration says New Hampshire "does not have an income tax on an individual's reported W-2 wages." So no New Hampshire withholding or credit is involved. Massachusetts sources the Boston-day share of the pay, and the Boston employer, which has an office in Massachusetts, withholds on that share. The employer's day record is its proof. For a 2020 or 2021 return that is still open, the pandemic rule applies by its own dates.

Convenience and necessity states

The convenience rule itself, its factors and its cases belong to the library's article on whether New York taxes a nonresident's wages for days worked from home in another state. This article points to it and adds the employer's side.

Of the states read for this article, New York, Pennsylvania and Delaware apply a necessity or convenience test to a nonresident's days outside the state, and Connecticut and New Jersey apply a mirror rule to residents of states that use a similar test. The list is not complete, because no other state was read.

  • New York treats a nonresident whose primary office is in New York as working in New York on days spent telecommuting, unless the employer has established a bona fide employer office at the telecommuting location. In Matter of Zelinsky v. Commissioner of Taxation & Finance, 2026 NY Slip Op 04251 (3d Dept July 2, 2026), the Appellate Division confirmed the determination and dismissed the petition. The taxpayers' appeal to the Court of Appeals (No. APL-2026-00107) and a motion in the matter (2026-511) were pending as of November 13, 2026, on the Court's lists as updated November 12, 2026.
  • Pennsylvania is a convenience state by its own regulation and its own guide. The regulation, 61 Pa. Code (the Pennsylvania Code) 109.8 (read at a Cornell mirror of the Pennsylvania Code, which gives the amendment as December 10, 1999, effective 12/11/1999), provides: "However, any allowance claimed for days worked outside of this Commonwealth shall be based upon the performance of services which, of necessity, obligate the employe or casual employe to perform out-of-State duties in the service of his employer or casual employer." The word convenience does not appear in the regulation, and "of necessity" does. The Department of Revenue's Personal Income Tax Guide says that Pennsylvania, "like many other states, follows" the convenience-of-the-employer doctrine, under which compensation of a nonresident cannot be allocated to the places of actual performance if the services were performed there only for the employee's convenience or not "of necessity in the service of the employer." The Guide's definition of a working day within Pennsylvania reaches the case where "All of the work done outside Pennsylvania was done there only for the worker's convenience or" "was not performed there of necessity in the service of the employer."
  • The Pennsylvania telework guidance covers a narrower case. It says that a nonresident employee who is "required to telework full-time from home in another state" "should treat his compensation as non-Pennsylvania source income" "even if his employer is located in Pennsylvania," and that "In those situations, the employer is not required to withhold on the employee's compensation." The page does not mention convenience or part-time telework. Together with the regulation, it applies the necessity test to the case of required full-time telework and is not a departure from it; that reading is reasoning from the two texts, not a statement on the page.
  • Delaware is read at the Division of Revenue's Schedule W for the 2025 nonresident return, which says that any allowance "must be based on necessity of work outside the State of Delaware in performance of duties for the employer, as opposed to solely for the convenience of the employee." The worksheet adds that working from an office out of the employee's own home does not satisfy the necessity requirement and is considered for the employee's convenience, unless working from home is a requirement of employment with the employer. The Division's reading is therefore strict: permission to work from home is not a requirement. No Delaware statute, regulation or employer withholding instruction was read, and the article cites no section of the Delaware Code.
  • Connecticut and New Jersey have mirror rules that reach only residents of states that use a similar test, and the New York article carries them, with Connecticut Public Act 25-172.
  • Nebraska is not listed. The statute as it now reads sources a nonresident's compensation for services performed outside Nebraska for the nonresident's convenience to Nebraska only where the nonresident is present in Nebraska "for more than seven days during the taxable year," and adds: "Only compensation paid to the individual for services performed within this state shall constitute income derived from sources within this state under this subdivision" (Neb. Rev. Stat. 77-2733(8)(c), as amended by Laws 2024, Legislative Bill 1023 (LB1023), operative for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025). On those words the subdivision does not source home-day pay to Nebraska, and the older 2006 regulation predates the amendment.

For a nonresident from a state without an agreement, such as a Delaware or New York resident on a hybrid schedule for a Philadelphia office, the Department of Revenue's likely position follows from the Guide and the regulation: home days by choice are Pennsylvania working days. The Guide's withholding chapter tells the employer to withhold on all compensation paid to nonresidents who work within and outside Pennsylvania unless the employer maintains "adequate current records to determine the accurate amount of compensation from Pennsylvania sources." For a New Jersey resident on the same schedule, the Pennsylvania state tax is out of the picture because of the agreement, as the example below shows, and the Philadelphia Wage Tax is not.

The stacked paycheck: a Connecticut or New Jersey resident on a New York payroll

The payroll mechanics for a Connecticut or New Jersey resident reporting to a New York office run in three layers: New York's withholding, the home state's withholding and the credit. The two home states differ.

Layer one: New York's withholding

A New York employer's duty rests on the Tax Law and a regulation. Section 671(a)(1) of the Tax Law says the employer maintaining an office or transacting business in New York "shall deduct and withhold from such wages for each payroll period a tax computed in such manner as to result, so far as practicable, in withholding from the employee's wages during each calendar year an amount substantially equivalent to the tax reasonably estimated to be due under this article resulting from the inclusion in the employee's New York adjusted gross income or New York source income of the employee's wages received during such calendar year." The regulation, 20 NYCRR (the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations) 171.6, read at a Cornell mirror, speaks to the nonresident's certificate. Subdivision (b)(2) says: "The employer should withhold New York State personal income tax on the basis of the apportionment shown by the nonresident employee on form IT-2104.1, but must nevertheless make necessary adjustments during the year so that the proper amount of New York State personal income tax is withheld from the employee's wages." Subdivision (b)(5) says: "The mere filing of the certificate on form IT-2104.1 does not, however, relieve the employer from the duty of withholding the proper amount of New York State personal income tax from wages paid to an employee." The Tax Department's employer guide (NYS-50, revised December 2024) applies the same standard of reliance: "an employer may accept a completed Form IT-2104.1, New York State, City of New York, and City of Yonkers Certificate of Nonresidence and Allocation of Withholding Tax, as documentation of an employee's nonresident status, as long as the employer does not have any actual knowledge or reason to know the certificate is incorrect or unreliable."

The Tax Department's likely position, put together from those words, is that a home day without a bona fide employer office is a New York day, that New York source income therefore includes the pay for those days, and that the certificate does not relieve the employer. On the facts of employee C below, the employer knows the schedule, knows that the home days are by choice and knows that no office was set up at the home. A certificate showing 40 percent is then a starting basis that the employer must adjust, and an employer that withholds on 40 percent while knowing the facts under-withholds, with the exposure the employer's as well as the employee's. The precision the sources allow is this: no source read says in one sentence that home days count in the withholding fraction. The link runs through the phrase "New York source income" in section 671, "the proper amount" in the regulation, and NYS-50's pointer to the Department's convenience memorandum for the home-office case. The form's own example is an individual who works in New York "two out of five days for the entire year," which the form says is 40 percent of all services; the example does not address the convenience rule, and the form does not use the words telecommuting or convenience. Sections 675 and 685 of the Tax Law, which govern employer liability and penalties, were not read, so the article states the duty and no penalty. The mechanics of the certificate itself are in the New York article.

Layer two: the home state's withholding

Connecticut. For a Connecticut resident who works for the employer only in another state, the Department of Revenue Services' 2026 withholding tax information page says: "The employer will withhold tax for the state in which the individual works" and, where the employer is also registered in Connecticut, withholds Connecticut tax "only to the extent that Connecticut income tax withholding exceeds the amount required" "to be withheld for the state in which the services are performed." Examples 1 to 3 of Circular CT deal with a resident who works only in another state and conclude with $60 of Connecticut tax in Example 1 and none in Examples 2 and 3. That is the single-state rule. A resident who also works in Connecticut falls under a different rule, which prorates. Circular CT (IP 2026(1), issued December 12, 2025, effective January 1, 2026) says that for a resident who works for the employer in one or more qualifying jurisdictions and in Connecticut, the employer first determines the Connecticut tax that would otherwise be withheld from total wages and prorates that amount between the qualifying jurisdictions, and that the prorated tax amount for Connecticut is the Connecticut income tax that would otherwise be required to be deducted and withheld from the employee's total wages, less the prorated tax amount for each qualifying jurisdiction in which the employee works for the employer. The regulation, section 12-705(a)-2(b)(2)(C) of the Regulations of Connecticut State Agencies (read at a Cornell mirror), uses a fraction whose numerator is "the employee's wages for work performed in the qualifying jurisdiction" and whose denominator is "the employee's total wages." Its Example 5 has a resident employed in Connecticut and New York, with $450 of Connecticut tax on total wages and one third of the wages for work performed in New York. The prorated New York amount is $150, the prorated Connecticut amount is $450 less $150, or $300, and because the New York tax required to be withheld on the New York wages ($210) exceeds the prorated New York amount, no Connecticut tax is required on the New York wages, and $300 is withheld for Connecticut.

The consequence for the employee in the example is that Connecticut withholds its share on the Connecticut-worked wages in full, and New York's withholding is never set against that share. Connecticut's likely position, from its regulation and circular, is that "wages for work performed in the qualifying jurisdiction" means the place where the work is performed, which is how the regulation's Example 5 allocates, and that the circular repeats the rule for 2026 without a convenience exception. Relief from the overlap is then the resident credit on the return.

Whether Connecticut withholding applies at all to an out-of-state employer turns on the registration test. Section 12-705(a)(1) of the Connecticut General Statutes says: "Each employer, as defined in section 12-707, maintaining an office or transacting business within this state and making payment of any wages taxable under this chapter to a resident or nonresident individual shall deduct and withhold from such wages." Circular CT says anyone who "maintains an office or transacts business in Connecticut and is considered an employer" "for federal withholding purposes must withhold Connecticut income tax whether or not the payroll" "department is located in Connecticut," and that an employer not required to register may register solely to withhold Connecticut tax if the employer and the employee both voluntarily agree, and is then treated as an employer required to withhold while the agreement remains in effect. No source read defines "transacts business" for one home worker or says whether one employee working at home in Connecticut meets it. The Connecticut Department of Revenue Services can be expected to say that an employer whose employee regularly performs the employer's work in Connecticut transacts business there, but no source read says so. Voluntary registration is the route that removes the doubt.

New Jersey. NJ-WT nets differently. As quoted above, it reduces the New Jersey withholding by the income tax withheld "for other states, their political subdivisions, or the District of Columbia," and full relief needs all three of its conditions. The two home states are stated separately here, and neither rule is extended to the other.

Layer three: the credit

The credit is claimed on the home-state return, never at payroll. New Jersey allows it by Schedule NJ-COJ and bulletin GIT-3W, described above. Connecticut allows a resident credit that the Department's 2026 withholding tax information page describes as "the lesser of the tax paid to the other state or the tax which Connecticut imposes" "on the resident's out-of-state wages," claimed on "Form CT-1040, Schedule 2," for tax "on income earned for services performed in the other state." The 2025 Form CT-1040 instructions for Schedule 2 list, as income sourced to the other jurisdiction, "Compensation received as an employee for personal services performed from a home office in Connecticut for an employer in a qualifying jurisdiction that applies a convenience of the employer test." The New York article carries the credit's reach to home-office pay and Connecticut's Public Act 25-172, which applies only after a refund won on appeal and adds nothing at an ordinary filing. An employee may lower Connecticut withholding in anticipation of the credit. The Department's publication on checking withholding (IP 2026(7), effective January 1, 2026) has a resident enter the credit for income taxes paid to other jurisdictions on its first worksheet and, where the worksheets show overwithholding, says: "Enter the amount from Line 9b of Worksheet 2 on Line 3 of your new withholding form." Line 3 of Form CT-W4 (Rev. 12/25) is the "Reduced withholding amount per pay period." The publication cautions that "Underwithholding may result in interest charges." The reduction is the employee's to claim on the certificate.

Two cases for the Connecticut resident

The two cases below use fractions only, because no Connecticut or New York rate was read. T is the Connecticut tax that would otherwise be withheld from the employee's total wages.

  • Case 1: New York withholds on the certificate's 40 percent. New York withholding lands on $60,000. Connecticut withholds 0.60T on the $90,000 worked in Connecticut, plus any excess of 0.40T over New York's amount on the $60,000. Nothing is withheld twice on the same wages. The trap is a New York balance due at filing, because New York has under-withheld on the $90,000, and the credit and any return of Connecticut tax follow the filing. This case also leaves the employer exposed on its own duty to adjust.
  • Case 2: New York withholds on 100 percent, which is what its rules call for on these facts. New York withholding lands on all $150,000, including the $90,000 of home-day wages. Connecticut's regulation still requires 0.60T on the wages for work performed in Connecticut, the same $90,000. Both states withhold on the same dollars until the employee gives the employer a new Form CT-W4 with a reduced withholding amount for the expected credit, or claims the Connecticut resident credit on the return. That is the double withholding trap. How Connecticut counts New York's withholding on the Connecticut-worked wages in the excess comparison is not stated in a sentence read: the regulation compares the prorated tax amount for the qualifying jurisdiction with the income tax required to be deducted and withheld from such wages for such qualifying jurisdiction, and no source read says whether New York's withholding on home-day wages counts in that comparison.

Worked example: one employer, three employees

A software company is headquartered in Philadelphia, with a second office in Boston and a client-services team that reports to an office in New York City. Each employee below is paid $150,000 a year in even installments and works 240 days a year (48 weeks of five days). State income tax rates other than the Philadelphia Wage Tax were not read, so they are assumptions in this example: no state income tax dollar amount is computed, and those results appear as fractions of wages or of an unknown tax. The Philadelphia figures use the two rates described above, each applied to half of the year's pay.

Employee A is a New Jersey resident on a hybrid schedule: three days a week in the Philadelphia office and two days at home in New Jersey by choice.

  • Pennsylvania: the employer holds A's REV-419 and withholds New Jersey tax, so Pennsylvania state tax is not withheld.
  • New Jersey: A works part of the time at home in New Jersey, so A is not "Employed totally outside New Jersey" and fails the first of the three conditions in NJ-WT. The instruction then tells the employer to withhold New Jersey tax, reduced by tax withheld for other states, their political subdivisions or the District of Columbia. Philadelphia is a political subdivision of Pennsylvania, so the instruction's words can be read to let the Wage Tax withheld reduce the New Jersey amount. That is a reading of the words, not a statement of the Division: the instruction does not mention Philadelphia, and no Division statement on it was found. The New Jersey rate was not read, so no amount is computed, and whether any New Jersey withholding remains after the reduction depends on the rate. Whether an employer with no other New Jersey connection is bound by the instruction is an open point below.
  • Philadelphia Wage Tax, home days by choice: all $150,000 is taxable at the nonresident rate. For January through June, $75,000 at 3.43 percent is $2,572.50. For July through December, $75,000 at 3.425 percent is $2,568.75. The total withheld is $5,141.25.
  • Variant, home days required: suppose the office is closed to A on the two home days, the employer requires A to work from home on them, and the employer certifies the requirement. The taxable share is the 144 office days of 240, or 60 percent (three days a week for 48 weeks; on the refund petition, Line 2D is 96 days outside Philadelphia and Line 2E is 40 percent). The tax on that share is $2,572.50 times 0.60, or $1,543.50, plus $2,568.75 times 0.60, or $1,541.25, a total of $3,084.75. The difference from $5,141.25 is $2,056.50. If the employer modifies withholding at payroll, the $2,056.50 is never withheld. If the employer withholds on all pay, A recovers it by the refund petition after year end, with the employer's signed certification and the list of dates, within three years of the date the tax was paid or due, whichever is later. A written policy of two office days a week that leaves the office open on the other days would not make the home days required.
  • At filing: A claims a New Jersey credit for the Wage Tax on Schedule NJ-COJ. In the base case, $2,572.50 divided by 0.0343 is $75,000 and $2,568.75 divided by 0.03425 is $75,000, so line 1 is $150,000, which does not exceed the $150,000 of Philadelphia wages on line 15. In the variant the refund reduces the tax that may be credited to $3,084.75, and line 1 is $1,543.50 divided by 0.0343, or $45,000, plus $1,541.25 divided by 0.03425, or $45,000, which is $90,000. The statute's proportion cap limits the credit further, and its dollar amount is not computed because the New Jersey rate was not read. Whether New Jersey accepts the Philadelphia-taxed wages for the home days worked by choice as income also taxed by the other jurisdiction is the open point described above.
  • Registrations: Pennsylvania withholding, which the headquarters already holds; a Philadelphia Wage Tax account; and New Jersey withholding, on the NJ-WT instruction.

Employee B is a New Hampshire resident assigned to the Boston office, with four days a week at home in New Hampshire.

  • New Hampshire: no wage tax, so no withholding and no credit.
  • Massachusetts: the regulation's day fraction applies. One Boston day of five gives 48 Massachusetts days of 240, or 20 percent, so $150,000 times 0.20 is $30,000 of Massachusetts source income. The regulation's own telecommuter example reaches the same kind of result: $120,000 times 60 days of 240 is $30,000. A Boston day with a morning spent at home counts as a Massachusetts day unless B proves that more than half of the day was worked outside Massachusetts.
  • Withholding: the Boston office makes the employer one that maintains an office in Massachusetts, and the employer withholds on the $30,000 share. The Massachusetts rate was not read, so no tax is computed.
  • At filing: B files a nonresident return, because the $30,000 exceeds the regulation's $8,000 filing level (or the personal exemption after apportionment, if less).
  • Registrations: Massachusetts withholding, held through the Boston office.

Employee C is a Connecticut resident reporting to the New York office, with two days a week in New York and three days a week at home in Connecticut by choice.

  • New York: no bona fide employer office exists at C's Connecticut home, so the three home days are New York days on the Department's reading, and New York's proper withholding reaches all $150,000 (96 New York days plus 144 home days is 240). If C enters 40 percent on Form IT-2104.1, which matches the form's own example of two days out of five, the certificate alone supports withholding on $60,000 and leaves $90,000 without New York withholding. The employer knows that the home days are by choice and that no office was set up at the home, so the employer must adjust. No New York rate was read, so no tax is computed.
  • New York City: nonresidents of the City are not liable for the City personal income tax, so no City tax applies to a Connecticut resident.
  • Connecticut: let T be the Connecticut tax that would otherwise be withheld from total wages. The New York-worked share is 40 percent ($60,000) and the Connecticut-worked share is 60 percent ($90,000). Connecticut withholds 0.60T in full on the Connecticut-worked share, plus any excess of 0.40T over the New York income tax required to be deducted and withheld from the New York-worked wages. T is not computed because no Connecticut rate was read. This assumes the employer is a Connecticut withholding employer, either because it maintains an office or transacts business in Connecticut or because it registers voluntarily, and the registration test described above leaves that open for one home worker.
  • Case 1, New York withholds on the certificate's 40 percent: nothing is withheld twice, New York is under-withheld on $90,000 and C owes New York at filing; the credit and any return of Connecticut tax follow the return, and the employer is exposed on its own duty to adjust.
  • Case 2, New York withholds on all $150,000: New York and Connecticut both withhold during the year on the same $90,000. The offset comes through the Connecticut resident credit on Form CT-1040, Schedule 2, limited to the lesser of the tax paid to New York or the Connecticut tax on those wages. C may bring it forward during the year by entering a reduced withholding amount on Line 3 of Form CT-W4, worked out on the worksheets in IP 2026(7). Public Act 25-172 does not apply at an ordinary filing.
  • Registrations: New York withholding, held through the New York office. Connecticut withholding is required if the employer maintains an office or transacts business in Connecticut, which no source read decides for one home worker, and voluntary registration is available.

What the example shows. The Philadelphia day record, the Massachusetts day fraction, New York's duty to adjust and Connecticut's proration by place of work each set the withholding result. A state agreement sets none of them. The example leaves out all state income tax rates other than Philadelphia's, federal tax, unemployment insurance and the Local Services Tax.

The employer's setup record

For each remote or cross-border employee, the payroll file holds:

  • The home address and municipality, with the residence PSD code and the city, county or school district.
  • The work location for each day, with the reason for any day outside the assigned office.
  • The state certificates: the REV-419, NJ-165, VA-4, MW507, Ohio IT 4, Indiana WH-47 and IT-2104.1, plus the home state's own withholding certificate where the home state has one.
  • The local residency certification, which in Pennsylvania is the CLGS-32-6.
  • The dates on which each certificate was given and changed.

The day-by-day record of work locations matters because the sources let an employer withhold on its own records. Pennsylvania's guide tells an employer to withhold on all of the compensation of a nonresident who works both in and outside Pennsylvania unless the employer "maintains adequate current records to determine the accurate amount of compensation from Pennsylvania sources." The same record supplies the list of dates and locations that the Philadelphia refund petition asks the employer to verify and sign, and the day counts that the Massachusetts fraction uses.

Local registration points that this article adds to the state ones:

  • Philadelphia, within 30 days, for an employer located in Pennsylvania.
  • The county or municipal collector for Act 32, and the home municipality's collector where an employee works from home in Pennsylvania.
  • Every Ohio taxing municipality in which an employee works more than twenty days, unless the employer is a small employer under division (E) of section 718.011.
  • The Indiana county, for an out-of-state resident whose principal place of work is in it.
  • The Maryland county of employment, for a Pennsylvania resident.
  • Connecticut, where the employer maintains an office or transacts business there.

The library's article on withholding and unemployment insurance for employees who work in more than one state covers thresholds, state registration triggers and unemployment insurance, and this article restates none of it.

Points the sources do not settle

The sources read for this article leave the following open. Each is stated so that a reader does not take its absence as a rule.

  1. New Jersey credit for home days worked by choice. Whether the Division of Taxation accepts Philadelphia-taxed wages for New Jersey home days worked by choice as income also taxed by the other jurisdiction is not stated in bulletin GIT-3W. The Division's regulation on the credit was not read.
  2. New Jersey withholding by an employer with no New Jersey presence. NJ-WT uses the word "should" for the reciprocal-agreement instruction, and N.J.S.A. 54A:7-1 was not read, so whether a Pennsylvania employer with no New Jersey presence must register and withhold New Jersey tax for a New Jersey resident who works wholly in Pennsylvania is not established here.
  3. Connecticut. No source read defines "transacts business" for one home worker, and Regulation 12-701(b)-1 was not read. No sentence read says how Connecticut counts New York's withholding on the Connecticut-worked wages in the excess comparison. Section 12-704 of the Connecticut General Statutes was not read at source. No Department statement read applies the withholding proration to an employee who works at home for an employer in a convenience state; the Schedule 2 instructions source that pay to the other state for the credit.
  4. Pennsylvania credit order. The Pennsylvania Department of Community and Economic Development pages read do not use the word "credit" for the Philadelphia Wage Tax or state an order of credit between the Wage Tax and the Act 32 earned income tax when a Pennsylvania resident is taxed by a work municipality. The Local Tax Enabling Act and the Sterling Act were not read.
  5. Act 32 and two fixed Pennsylvania worksites. DCED states the 90-day rule for temporary assignments only. How withholding is allocated for an employee with two fixed Pennsylvania worksites is not stated.
  6. Ohio. No statement by the Ohio Department of Taxation or a municipality was found that the state reciprocal agreements do not reach municipal tax. The revised Form IT 4's reciprocity line and notice period were not read, and the enrolled text of H.B. 110 was not read; the Legislative Service Commission analysis is the source for it.
  7. Philadelphia. The Department's employer page and the refund petition cite the Philadelphia Code and its General Regulations (Section 306(2) for who files the petition). None of the cited text was read, so the article cites the Department's pages as pronouncements and gives no Code section. The petition's printed rates were not confirmed, and none is quoted from the form.
  8. Maryland. The general 2026 Form MW507 was not read. The 2026 guide and Tip 56 name MW507, and the state-payroll copy is headed Form MWH. Form 515, and which Pennsylvania localities tax Maryland residents, were not read.
  9. Delaware and Nebraska. No Delaware statute, regulation or 2026 Schedule W was read. The Nebraska Department's current reading, in Circular EN and the Form 1040N instructions, was not read. The slip law shows LB1023 "Approved by the Governor April 23, 2024."
  10. New York. Tax Law sections 675 and 685, which govern employer liability and penalties, were not read, nor was the Department's 14-day withholding policy in TSB-M-12(5)I, nor 20 NYCRR 132.18(a) at source.
  11. Indiana, Kansas City and Virginia. Forms WH-47, WH-4AFF, RD-110, RD-113, RD-109NR, VA-4 and 763-S were not read as forms, the Kansas City ordinance was not read.
  12. Massachusetts. Circular M was not located. The June 2026 text of 830 CMR 62B.2.1 was read without the prior version, so what changed is unknown, and Technical Information Release 20-10 was not separately read.
  13. State income tax rates. The 2026 rates for New Jersey, Massachusetts, New York and Connecticut were not read, which is why the example computes no state tax.

Practice notes

Collect the work state's exemption certificate at hire and at every move, date it and keep it in the payroll file, and calendar each form's own duty: the REV-419 (the Pennsylvania Employee's Nonwithholding Application Certificate) revocation within 10 days of anticipating Pennsylvania tax liability, the NJ-165 (the New Jersey Employee's Certificate of Nonresidence) notice within 10 days of a move out of Pennsylvania, the VA-4 (the Virginia exemption certificate of a reciprocity-state resident) yearly renewal, the Ohio IT 4 (Employee's Withholding Exemption Certificate) update when the employee's information changes and the IT-2104.1 (the New York allocation certificate) notice within 10 days of a change in the percentage (the instructions say a substantial change; the signed certification says any change). Before relying on a certificate, ask whether the home state requires the employer to withhold and for which employees: New Jersey under the three conditions in NJ-WT (the Division of Taxation's withholding instructions), Pennsylvania as the condition of its own relief, Virginia and Massachusetts only by agreement. Register in the home state only where the answer is yes or the employer and the employee have agreed. Review the reciprocal agreement list each year against each department's own page, because an agreement can be changed or ended.

Record the residence and work-site municipality, county and PSD code at hire and on each move, and treat a home worker's Pennsylvania or Ohio municipality as a possible work site and registration point. For Philadelphia, keep a day-by-day record of why each nonresident day was outside the City, obtain a written employer requirement that closes the office on those days where one exists, decide at payroll whether to modify withholding, and calendar the refund petition after year end and inside three years where the employer withheld on all pay. For a Maryland employer of a Pennsylvania resident, withhold the Maryland county tax unless the resident qualifies for an exemption on line 6 or line 7 of the certificate.

For New York nonresidents, treat the IT-2104.1 percentage as the starting basis, set the withholding from the day count including home days worked by choice, keep adequate current records and ask the employee again when the pattern changes, because the duty to adjust is the employer's own. For a Connecticut resident who also works in Connecticut, apply the proration rule of Circular CT and not the excess-only sentence on the Department's withholding tax information page, and model the double withholding that remains until the employee files a new Form CT-W4 with a reduced withholding amount or claims the credit. For a New Jersey resident, apply the NJ-WT reduction and model the credit on Schedule NJ-COJ. G&G State Tax Group provides multistate payroll withholding reviews for employers with remote and cross-border employees alongside its state and local tax practice.

This article states the law as of November 17, 2026

Statutes, rates, thresholds, and agency practice change, and a different set of facts can change the answer. Before acting on anything discussed above, contact G&G State Tax Group, or another state and local tax adviser, to confirm what has changed since this was written and how the rules apply to a specific situation.

Contact the firm+1 714.234.5538 · info@gandgsalt.com

This publication is informational in nature and is not, and should not be considered, legal, accounting, tax, or other professional advice for any person or situation. Correct application of tax law depends heavily on the facts and circumstances in each case, and G&G State Tax Group, LLC assumes no liability in connection with the use of this information, and is not obligated to inform any reader of changes in the law or other factors that could affect the information contained herein.