Skip to main content
Direct +1 949.864.9199 Office +1 714.234.5538 info@gandgsalt.com
G&G State Tax Group

TennesseeIncome and franchise tax

Which entities in a chain of partnerships above Tennessee single-member LLCs file franchise and excise tax returns, and how does an upper tier that paid without Tennessee nexus get the tax back?

The short answer

A Tennessee single-member LLC with a noncorporate member files its own franchise and excise tax return; owners above it file no return from ownership alone. Tennessee disregards a single-member LLC only when its single member is a corporation (Tenn. Code Ann. sections 67-4-2007(d) and 67-4-2106(c)), so each apartment LLC is a taxpayer and the owners above it are not part of its return. That no filing follows from ownership alone is the Department of Revenue's position, not a statute or court holding, and the nexus definition, section 67-4-2004(47)(A), lists owning capital in Tennessee. A general partnership at the top is looked through to its owners. An upper tier registered with the Tennessee Secretary of State still files and pays at least the $100 minimum franchise tax on the Department's reading of section 67-4-2119; a taxpayer can argue otherwise. Excise tax is 6.5 percent of net earnings; franchise tax is 0.25 percent of net worth. Tax paid without nexus is recovered by an amended return or refund claim filed within three years of December 31 of the payment year (section 67-1-1802). The final return box is for an entity that has ended its Tennessee activity, not for correcting an earlier filing.

Working through this on a live matter? Contact the firm

The structure and the two questions

An owner holds Tennessee apartment buildings through single-member limited liability companies, called the apartment LLCs in this article. A mezzanine LLC is the sole member of each apartment LLC, and a holding limited partnership is the sole member of the mezzanine LLC. No entity has elected to be classified as a corporation for federal income tax purposes. The first question is which of these entities file Tennessee franchise and excise tax returns, what the apartment LLCs owe, and whether anything flows up to the entities above them. The second is separate: an affiliate paid Tennessee franchise and excise tax on a return, later concluded that it had no Tennessee nexus, and asks how it recovers the payment and by when.

The entity type at the top matters, and the article uses a limited partnership for a reason given below. A separate article in this library covers the classification rule from the other side, an LLC that registers for sales tax and then draws an estimated franchise and excise tax assessment, and another covers the franchise tax computation for real estate and the repealed property measure. This article stays on the filing duty of the upper tiers, the current computation and the refund route.

Tennessee judges each entity alone, and a noncorporate member disregards nothing

The statutory rule. Under the federal classification regulations, a domestic eligible entity with a single owner is, unless it elects otherwise, "disregarded as an entity separate from its owner" (Treas. Reg. section 301.7701-3(b)(1)). Each LLC in the chain has a single owner and has made no election, so each is disregarded federally. Tennessee starts from federal classification and then overrides it. For the excise tax, entities that are disregarded for federal income tax purposes "shall not be disregarded for Tennessee excise tax purposes," except "limited liability companies whose single member is a corporation" (Tenn. Code Ann. section 67-4-2007(d)). The franchise tax statute states the same exception and the same override in its own words (section 67-4-2106(c)). The test is who the single member is. If it is a corporation, the LLC disregards into it. If it is anything else, the LLC is a taxpayer.

What "corporation" means. The Department of Revenue (the Department) reads the word by federal classification: "any entity that is classified as a corporation for federal income tax purposes." The sole member "can be any type of entity that is classified as a corporation for federal tax purposes," and the notice lists a business trust, a limited liability company and a limited partnership among the entities that qualify (Important Notice 13-16, November 2013). So a mezzanine LLC that elected corporate classification would be a corporation for this purpose, and an ordinary LLC or limited partnership that made no election would not. The Department's Franchise and Excise Tax Manual (June 2026) (the manual) adds that treatment as a disregarded entity for franchise and excise tax "is not an option or an election," and that the rule "only applies to SMLLCs," meaning single-member LLCs. For deeper stacks the manual describes a "top-down" analysis, which this chain does not need, because no tier has a corporation as its single member.

The Court of Appeals. In EmeraChem Power, LLC v. Gerregano (Tenn. Ct. App. June 1, 2020), two single-member LLCs were involved, and the sole member was an LLC that was treated as a partnership for federal tax purposes. The excise tax for 2010 through 2012 was in dispute. The court held that the two LLCs "are not disregarded entities for Tennessee F&E tax purposes" and that "they cannot compute their excise tax on a consolidated basis." It read "corporation" in section 67-4-2007(d) by federal tax classification. The case supports the result where the single member is a noncorporate entity. The owner there was an LLC taxed as a partnership, and the single member of each apartment LLC here is an LLC that is not classified as a corporation either.

Three exceptions to separate filing, none of which applies. Subject to exceptions, each taxpayer is a separate business entity. The excise tax statute excepts "unitary groups of financial institutions, captive REIT affiliated groups," and business entities that have been required or permitted to file excise tax returns on a combined, consolidated or separate accounting basis under section 67-4-2014 (section 67-4-2007(e)(1)). The franchise tax statute carries the same two named groups and an exception for entities required or permitted to file combined or consolidated under section 67-4-2112 (section 67-4-2106(c)). No entity in the chain is a group of financial institutions or a captive REIT group, and the example assumes no permission to combine.

The chain. Each apartment LLC has a single member, the mezzanine LLC, which is not a corporation. The mezzanine LLC has a single member, the holding limited partnership, which is not a corporation either. Nothing disregards upward at any level. Each apartment LLC therefore files its own return. Each is also a "pass-through entity" by the statute's own definition, which includes "a business entity that has a single owner and that is disregarded as an entity separate from its owner for federal income tax purposes, but not for purposes of this part and part 21" (section 67-4-2004(35)). That label matters later, because the owner-level adjustment in section 67-4-2006 is written for income from a pass-through entity.

One change in facts alters the result. If the mezzanine LLC elected to be classified as a corporation for federal income tax purposes, for example on federal Form 8832, each apartment LLC would disregard into it, and the mezzanine LLC would file one return covering the group. The same election by the holding limited partnership would not do that, because the mezzanine LLC would then be an LLC with a corporate single member, not an apartment LLC.

The entity at the top. A limited partnership is a "person" or "taxpayer" under the franchise and excise tax definitions, and a general partnership is not on the statutory list (section 67-4-2004(36)). The Department says a general partnership "is not itself a taxable entity, and it is treated as a division of its owner" (help-center article F&E-20), and the manual states that a general partnership is not subject to the tax but its Tennessee activity "is taxed at the first ownership level that offers limited liability protection." That is why the example uses a limited partnership. Had the top entity been a general partnership, it could not owe the minimum tax, the filing question would move to its partners, and the mezzanine LLC would be an LLC with a general partnership as its single member, a case that the receipts factor statute addresses by name (section 67-4-2012(g)).

Who has nexus: the apartment LLCs do, and the owners above them do not by ownership alone, on the Department's position

The two conditions. The excise tax applies to "[a]ll persons, except those having not-for-profit status, doing business in this state" and "having a substantial nexus in this state" (Tenn. Code Ann. section 67-4-2007(a)). The two conditions are cumulative. The franchise tax statute reaches "[a]ll persons doing business in this state and having a substantial nexus in this state," including "any limited liability company regardless of how it is treated for federal income tax purposes," and also "any person exercising the corporate franchise" (section 67-4-2105(a)). The phrase "exercising the corporate franchise" is the opening for the registration question in the next section.

The apartment LLCs. "Doing business in Tennessee" means "any activity purposefully engaged in within Tennessee, by a person with the object of gain, benefit, or advantage," to the extent the United States and Tennessee constitutions permit (section 67-4-2004(14)(A)). An LLC that owns and rents Tennessee buildings is doing business. Substantial nexus is "any direct or indirect connection of the taxpayer to this state" that lets the state require the tax under the United States Constitution, and the statute says that connection "includes, but is not limited to" a listed set, among them owning or using capital in the state and a bright-line presence (section 67-4-2004(47)(A)). The bright-line property test is met when the average value of real and tangible personal property owned or rented and used in the state exceeds the lesser of $50,000 or 25 percent of the average value of all such property (section 67-4-2004(47)(A)(v)(b)). An LLC whose property is all in Tennessee meets that test, because its Tennessee property exceeds 25 percent of its total property. The bright-line tests are one route to nexus and not the only one.

The owners above them: the statute does not answer directly. An upper tier whose only Tennessee connection is its interest in an apartment LLC raises a question the statute does not settle. The definition lists among the connections that "the taxpayer owns or uses its capital in this state," and an equity interest could be argued to be capital. The doing business definition contains a safe harbor for owning specified property, but it is written for financial institutions (section 67-4-2004(14)(C)). Other provisions can be read the other way: the separate "doing business" condition, the single-member LLC rule in sections 67-4-2007(d) and 67-4-2106(c), the subtraction of pass-through income in section 67-4-2006 and the receipts factor rule in section 67-4-2012(g) each treat an owner as a possible separate taxpayer, with or without a return of its own. That is a reading of the structure and not a holding. No statute, ruling or court decision located says whether an upper tier whose only Tennessee connection is its interest in a lower-tier LLC does business or has substantial nexus.

The Department's published position. The manual states it under the heading "Ownership Interests Do Not Create Nexus" (printed page 58). In the manual's words, pass-through entities "are taxed at the entity level and not at the owner level," each taxable entity "stands on its own attributes as to whether it is doing business and has substantial nexus in the state," and "[a]n ownership interest in a pass-through entity (e.g., an LP, LLC, or S corp.) that operates in Tennessee does not create a franchise and excise tax filing requirement for the owner." The taxpayer is "always the entity that conducts business in the state." The manual states two exceptions. The first is a single-member LLC owned by an entity taxed as a corporation, which is disregarded, so a corporate owner with no other connection to the state files because of the LLC. The second is a general partnership: it is not itself subject to the tax, and its Tennessee activity is taxed at the first ownership level that offers limited liability protection. Neither exception reaches a limited partnership or an LLC that owns an LLC which is itself a taxpayer.

This is the Department's reading. It is not a statute, a ruling that binds a court or a court holding, and the statute's reference to owned capital is the argument against it. The manual's discussion of Letter Ruling 11-46 is the Department's published answer to that argument. In the manual's treatment (printed page 80), a corporate parent and the single-member LLCs disregarded into it are found not to be doing business and not to have substantial nexus, so they have no filing requirement, although two of those LLCs are the partners of an operating limited partnership that does business in Tennessee. The same discussion finds that two single-member LLCs owned by that limited partnership, which are themselves the partners of a second limited partnership, "are not subject to the state tax because they are not disregarded and do not have nexus with Tennessee." That last sentence is the closest published statement for a single-member LLC with a noncorporate owner and no Tennessee activity of its own. The sources have limits. The letter ruling itself, dated September 12, 2011, does not use the word nexus; its recital is that three of the LLCs "do not have a physical presence in Tennessee," and letter rulings bind the Department only as to the taxpayer addressed. The nexus sentence is the manual's.

Two consequences, each independent of the other. First, on the manual's position the ownership chain alone creates no filing requirement above the apartment LLCs, so no lower-tier return stands in for an upper tier's return, because the upper tier has no obligation unless it has Tennessee activity of its own, such as employees, property or services performed in the state. Second, nothing flows up or down: an apartment LLC's return does not discharge an upper tier that is itself a taxpayer, and an upper tier's status does not change the apartment LLC's own duty.

Activity beyond ownership. Where an upper tier's own people perform asset management work in Tennessee, nexus may follow from that work. No source separates asset management at the owner level from the lower tier's own business, so the point is open. A service delivered to a Tennessee LLC is also a Tennessee receipt under the sourcing rule for service receipts discussed with the example below, which can matter to an affiliate that bills the apartment LLCs.

Registration changes the answer for an upper tier

The ownership position has an exception that can catch upper tiers: registration with the Secretary of State. The franchise tax statute sets the minimum and says who cannot escape it. "The minimum franchise tax payable under this part shall be one hundred dollars ($100)." A taxable entity that is "incorporated, domesticated, qualified or otherwise registered to do business in Tennessee but is, or has become, inactive in Tennessee," or whose registration is forfeited, revoked or suspended without proper termination, "shall not be relieved from filing a return and paying the franchise tax, which shall be no less than the one-hundred-dollar minimum, levied by this part for each tax year" (Tenn. Code Ann. section 67-4-2119). The section sets the floor. The levy is in section 67-4-2105(a), which reaches "any person exercising the corporate franchise," and in section 67-4-2005, which declares that "[d]oing business in Tennessee by any person or taxpayer, and/or exercising the corporate franchise, is declared to be a taxable privilege." Under section 67-4-2105(c) the tax continues to accrue "until such time as the taxpayer has been actually and legally dissolved or withdrawn from this state."

What the Department says. The manual states that all for-profit, foreign and domestic entities formed or qualified with the Secretary of State "must file" a franchise and excise tax return and "pay at least the minimum tax," and that registered entities that are inactive in Tennessee for the entire period "must pay the minimum tax" and may file only the first page (printed pages 86 and 87). The help-center article F&E-15 says the minimum franchise tax "is payable" "regardless of whether the company is active or inactive." Revenue Ruling 02-16 (June 7, 2002) reached the same answer for a mortgage banking business organized as an LLC and registered with the Secretary of State, which had no offices, employees or representatives in Tennessee: the ruling says it "does not, standing alone, have nexus with Tennessee," yet it "is required to file a franchise, excise tax return and pay the $100 minimum franchise tax." The ruling states: "Revenue rulings are not binding on the Department." It is a 2002 ruling and is cited here only for the registration and minimum point.

The Department's reading and the taxpayer's counter. The Department's reading is that registration is a way of exercising the corporate franchise, so a registered entity files and pays the minimum whether or not it has nexus. Four points support that reading: section 67-4-2119 names entities "otherwise registered," which would add little if only corporations were meant; section 67-4-2105(a) names "any limited liability company regardless of how it is treated for federal income tax purposes"; section 67-4-2105(c) keeps the tax accruing until the taxpayer has been dissolved or has withdrawn; and the excise tax provision, section 67-4-2007(a), names no corresponding "exercising the corporate franchise" alternative, which fits the result that a registered upper tier owes no excise tax on its own account. These are reasons supporting the Department's result, not Department statements.

The taxpayer's counter is that section 67-4-2105(a) taxes persons "doing business in this state and having a substantial nexus in this state," so a registered entity without nexus is arguably outside the levy, and section 67-4-2119 would then set a floor under a tax that was never imposed. No court decision located decides the point. The two readings are stated side by side here because the result differs: on the Department's reading the minimum is owed, and on the counter nothing is.

What follows for the chain. A mezzanine LLC or holding limited partnership that registered with the Secretary of State, for example at a lender's request or because it was formed in Tennessee, therefore files each year and pays at least $100 on the Department's reading. The words "at least" matter. The $100 is the floor, and nothing read here settles the franchise tax computation for a registered upper tier. An upper tier that never registered and has no activity of its own has no filing requirement on the manual's position. Registration does not itself create nexus; it triggers the minimum tax on the Department's reading, and an account opened with the Department expects returns until it is closed properly.

What a registered upper tier computes. Its excise base excludes income that an apartment LLC is already taxed on. The statute removes from net earnings any item of income that "is included in the determination of the taxpayer's net earnings or loss," that "is from a pass-through entity that is subject to and files a return for the tax imposed by this part," and that "is allocated to a partner, shareholder, beneficiary or other owner of such pass-through entity" (section 67-4-2006(b)(2)(L)). A matching provision adds back losses (section 67-4-2006(b)(1)(J)). The instructions to Form FAE 170 limit the line 25 adjustment to income from an entity that "is itself subject to the excise tax" and say to attach the Schedule K-1 or a list of the pass-through entity's name, federal employer identification number and Tennessee account number. Two points stay open. First, an apartment LLC with a single member issues no Schedule K-1, so the form mechanics for that owner are not described in the sources read. Second, the apportionment ratio for a registered upper tier that has no receipts of its own is not settled. The franchise tax is the minimum only if the ratio is zero, and the Department could read the missing factor as no right to apportion. For that reason the article states only that the registered upper tier owes at least $100.

What the apartment LLCs owe today

The two taxes. The excise tax is 6.5 percent of net earnings, for persons doing business in the state with substantial nexus (Tenn. Code Ann. section 67-4-2007(a)). The franchise tax is "twenty-five cents (25ยข) per one hundred dollars ($100), or major fraction thereof" of net worth (section 67-4-2106(a)). Net worth is "the difference between a taxpayer's total assets less its total liabilities" computed under generally accepted accounting principles. A taxpayer that does not keep its books under those principles computes net worth under "the accounting method used by the taxpayer for federal tax purposes, so long as the method fairly reflects the taxpayer's net worth" (section 67-4-2106(b)). The minimum franchise tax is $100 (section 67-4-2119).

The property measure is gone. Before the repeal, the franchise tax base could not fall below the value of Tennessee real and tangible property. The former statute provided that the measure of the tax "shall in no case be less than the actual value" of "real or tangible property owned or used in Tennessee," with property valued at cost less accumulated depreciation under generally accepted accounting principles (former section 67-4-2108(a)(1) and (a)(3), 2021 code). Public Chapter 950 (2024) repealed that section effective May 10, 2024, and the Department's legislative summary says the act "eliminates the property measure from the franchise tax calculation" for tax years ending on or after January 1, 2024. A real estate owner with a large building and thin net worth is the profile the repeal helped most. Another article in this library covers the repeal and its refund history; this article uses the current computation.

Apportionment. Apportionment matters only to a taxpayer with activity both inside and outside Tennessee. The instructions to Form FAE 170 say: "If the entity is not entitled to apportion, enter 100%." A single-purpose apartment LLC whose property and tenants are all in the state has nothing to apportion and enters 100 percent. For a taxpayer that does apportion, net earnings for tax years ending on or after December 31, 2025 are apportioned "by multiplying the earnings by the receipts factor only" (section 67-4-2012(a)(5)), subject to an annual election to apply the earlier method in subdivision (a)(2) when it yields a higher ratio and the taxpayer has net earnings (section 67-4-2012(a)(6)). The franchise tax apportionment statute carries a parallel rule for net worth (section 67-4-2111). Receipts from renting real property are sourced to Tennessee "if and to the extent the property is located in this state" (section 67-4-2012(i)(1)(A)). A separate article in this library covers how a lower-tier partnership's factors reach its partners, including the rule in section 67-4-2012(g).

Estimated payments and extensions. A taxpayer with a combined franchise and excise tax liability of $5,000 or more, "after application of all available franchise and excise tax credits," for both the preceding and the current tax year, makes four quarterly estimated payments (section 67-4-2015(b)). Each is due on the fifteenth day of the fourth, sixth and ninth months of the tax year and the first month of the next (section 67-4-2015(c)), which for a calendar-year taxpayer is April 15, June 15, September 15 and January 15. The statute states a minimum for each payment: "the lesser of" 25 percent of the combined tax shown on the return for the preceding year, or 25 percent of 80 percent of the current year's liability, so the installments are stated as minimums. A penalty of 2 percent for each month of underpayment or part of a month applies, "not to exceed a total of twenty-four percent" (section 67-4-2015(d)). The seven-month extension to file is granted if, on or before the original due date and with the request made as required, the taxpayer has paid at least the lesser of 90 percent of the liability for the year or 100 percent of the tax shown due on the preceding year's return (section 67-4-2015(h)(1)(A)).

When the 15th is a weekend day. The Department's help-center article GEN-9 says that "[i]f a due date falls on a Saturday, Sunday or legal holiday, the due date is extended until the next business day," and it speaks of returns and of payments. The statute lets the commissioner extend the due date of a return in the commissioner's discretion and defines "return" to include "any remittance or other tax document" (Tenn. Code Ann. section 67-1-114(a), (c)). An installment whose 15th falls on a Saturday, a Sunday or a legal holiday is therefore calendared for the next business day.

Exemptions are unavailable or unlikely for apartment owners

Two exemptions are written for entities like these, and neither fits an apartment building owned through a chain with limited liability above it. Neither is recommended here.

The obligated member entity exemption rests on an election by the owners to accept personal liability for the entity's debts, made on documentation filed with the Secretary of State. The statute then limits the exemption where limited liability reappears above the entity: "to the extent that any obligated member, or any owner of an obligated member, provides limited liability protection, the obligated member entity shall owe the tax otherwise imposed by this part, and by part 21 of this chapter, on the portion of income and equity attributable to such obligated member," and "ownership includes any form of ownership, whether in whole, in part, direct or indirect" (Tenn. Code Ann. section 67-4-2008(a)(9)(D)). An apartment LLC has one member, the mezzanine LLC, which is itself an LLC, and the holding limited partnership's limited liability sits above that. On those words the portion attributable to the obligated member is all of the income and equity, so the exemption is unavailable in substance for this chain.

The family-owned noncorporate entity exemption requires that substantially all of the entity's activity produce passive investment income and that the entity be family-owned. The statute defines "passive investment income" as gross receipts derived from "royalties, rents from residential property or farm property, dividends, interest, annuities, and sales or exchanges of stock or securities to the extent of any gains therefrom." It defines "residential property" to include "any property leased or rented for residential purposes that includes not more than four (4) residential units" (section 67-4-2008(a)(11)(B)(iii) and (iv)). The words "industrial" and "commercial" do not appear in subdivision (a)(11), so commercial rent is not on the list of passive income. The definition of residential property reaches property with not more than four units, so rent from a larger apartment building may fall outside the list.

Public Chapter 616 (2026), effective July 1, 2026, changes the family test. The Department's legislative summary says the act expands the definition of "family-owned" for purposes of the exemption, so that the test is "at least 95% of the voting rights, capital interest, or profits of the entity are owned by natural persons who have a relationship of first cousin or closer," by trusts established for the benefit of such relatives, or by the estate of a deceased individual who was such a relative while living. The summary does not say whether the change applies by tax year or by date, and the act's text was not read, so which test governs a given year is open.

Recovering tax paid without nexus

The question has two parts: whether anything was owed, and how the overpayment is claimed.

What was owed. An entity that was not registered and had no Tennessee activity of its own owes nothing on the manual's ownership position, so the whole payment was made in error. A registered entity owes at least the $100 minimum on the Department's reading (see the section on registration above), so the error is the excess over $100. On the taxpayer's counter the whole payment was in error.

How the claim is made. A refund of tax paid is claimed within "three (3) years from December 31 of the year in which the payment was made," and the entire disputed amount of tax, penalty and interest must be paid before the claim is filed (Tenn. Code Ann. section 67-1-1802(a)(1)). "A refund requested on a franchise and excise tax return, or amended return, properly filed with the commissioner is deemed to comply with those requirements," so an amended return can serve as the claim by statute. The Department's help-center article GEN-13 describes two other routes: a claim in the online system, TNTAP, under "Claim a Refund," or a paper Claim for Refund form. It also says that for franchise and excise tax an overpayment shown on the return counts as a valid claim for refund, and that an overpayment with no claim is applied to the next year's taxes.

What the claim must contain. The claim "must set forth each ground upon which a refund is claimed, the amount of such refund, the tax period, the tax type, and information reasonably sufficient to apprise the commissioner of the general basis for the claim," and it is made under penalties of perjury. A taxpayer "requesting a refund in the amount of two hundred dollars ($200) or more" completes and submits a written report of debts owed to a claimant (section 67-1-1802(a)(1)(B)(i)). The help-center article says the report is needed for a claim of "more than $200"; the statute says $200 or more, and the statute controls. The commissioner may also issue a credit or refund automatically, without the usual approval process, for estimated tax paid in excess of the actual liability.

When a payment is made. The statute measures the three years from December 31 of the year of payment and says nothing about when a payment is deemed made. For tax paid with a return, the plain reading is that the payment is made when it is paid. For estimated and extension payments, the manual states an administrative rule: "For the purpose of applying the statute of limitations, the Department considers estimated tax payments and extension payments to have been made as of the statutory due date or extended due date" of the return (printed page 116). The statute contains no such sentence, and the manual cites none, so the rule is the Department's practice and not a statutory deeming rule. It covers estimated and extension payments and does not cover a payment made with the return.

After the claim is filed. If the commissioner has not determined the claim within the six-month period following receipt, "the claim shall be deemed to be denied for the purpose of filing suit in chancery court" (section 67-1-1802(b)(2)). A suit challenging the denial or deemed denial must be filed in chancery court "within one (1) year from the date" the claim was filed, and the taxpayer may consent in writing to a later suit date (section 67-1-1802(c)(1)). The one-year period runs from the filing date of the claim, so a deemed denial at six months does not restart it.

A claim period that ends on a weekend. If the three-year period ends on a Saturday or Sunday, no source read settles whether the next-business-day rule reaches a refund claim. GEN-9 and section 67-1-114 speak of returns and payments, and GEN-9 does not mention refund claims. The Department accepted claims under the property measure refund program through Monday, December 2, 2024, because the statutory last day, November 30, fell on a Saturday, but that was a special program under section 67-4-2122 and not the three-year rule. Until a source settles the point, December 31 is the only end date the statute states.

The idea of an initial and final return. No published Department procedure was found for an initial and final return reporting no tax for an entity that was never subject to the tax. The final return box marks something else. The Form FAE 170 instructions say to check it "if all of the assets of the business have been liquidated and distributed," and the manual defines a "true" final return as "the last return filed by an entity that no longer has business or financial activity in the state" (printed page 94). F&E-15 says that "[t]axpayers that no longer have business or financial activity in the state should file the final" return. A checked box "is deemed a request for tax clearance for termination or withdrawal" (manual, printed page 98), the Department "will review the account for release of liability," and "[o]nce all tax liabilities are satisfied, a tax clearance certificate is issued." An out-of-state entity that continues to exist elsewhere but withdraws its Tennessee registration has ended its Tennessee activity and, on those definitions, files a final return. The box is not a way to correct an earlier filing, and it is not a way to stop filing while the entity keeps its Tennessee registration. When the box is not checked, "the department proceeds as though the taxpayer is still operational and expects additional filings." In TNTAP the account is closed by answering yes to "Is this a final return for termination or withdrawal?" (help-center article TNTAP-12). Checking the box invites a review of the account, and an entity that wants out of the system while still registered with the Secretary of State needs the tax clearance route.

Effect of earlier registration. Registration with the Secretary of State triggers the minimum tax on the Department's reading; it does not itself create nexus. An entity that did not register or file for other years remains outside the system for those years.

What changed and what stays open

Law that moved.

  • The franchise tax property measure is repealed. Public Chapter 950 (2024) repealed section 67-4-2108 effective May 10, 2024, and the Department's summary says it applies to tax years ending on or after January 1, 2024. The refund program in section 67-4-2122 covered tax paid on the property measure on a return "filed on or after January 1, 2021" for a tax period that "ended on or after March 31, 2020," on claims filed "between May 15, 2024, and November 30, 2024." The Department accepted claims through Monday, December 2, 2024, because November 30 was a Saturday, and until May 1, 2025 for taxpayers whose primary location address was in one of fourteen counties designated as federal disaster areas. That window is closed. A return for a year ending in 2024 or later that still computes the property measure follows repealed law, so for those returns the issue is an error to correct, not a refund.
  • An election to use the former base. Section 67-4-2123 lets a taxpayer elect annually to use the former minimum base, as it applied to periods ending before December 31, 2023, when the current computation gives a lower base, but the election "must result in a higher tax levied for the tax period" under section 67-4-2106, and the taxpayer waives an internal consistency claim. Whether any apartment owner would benefit was not researched, and the election is not recommended here.
  • Single sales factor. For apportioning taxpayers, receipts were weighted five times over seven for tax years ending on or after December 31, 2023 and before December 31, 2024, and eleven times over thirteen for years ending on or after December 31, 2024 and before December 31, 2025. For years ending on or after December 31, 2025 the receipts factor alone applies, subject to the annual election described above (section 67-4-2012(a)).
  • Family-owned noncorporate entity exemption. Public Chapter 616 (2026), effective July 1, 2026, expands the family test, as described above.
  • Nexus numbering. Substantial nexus is paragraph (47) of section 67-4-2004 in the 2025 code. Department materials that predate the current numbering cite it as paragraph (49).
  • No change to the core rules located. The Department's 2025 legislative summaries list three franchise and excise acts, Public Chapters 343, 455 and 496, and none addresses single-member LLCs, the $100 minimum, estimated payments or refund claim periods. Public Chapter 343 concerns adjustments to net earnings, which is the subject of section 67-4-2006, so whether the reproduction of section 67-4-2006 quoted above reflects it was not checked.

The sources read leave these points open.

  1. Whether an upper tier whose only Tennessee connection is its interest in a lower-tier LLC does business or has substantial nexus. No statute, letter ruling, revenue ruling or court decision located says. The statute lists owned or used capital among the connections. The manual says ownership does not create nexus and answers the capital point only through its discussion of Letter Ruling 11-46. The manual's position does not bind a court.
  2. The computation for a registered upper tier. The form mechanics for an owner that receives no Schedule K-1 from a single-member LLC are not described in the sources read, and neither is the apportionment ratio for a registered upper tier with no receipts of its own. The article says only that the registered upper tier owes at least $100.
  3. Whether an upper tier's own asset management work in Tennessee creates nexus. No source separates asset management at the owner level from the lower tier's business.
  4. A procedure for an initial and final return for an entity that was never subject to the tax. None was found in the sources read.
  5. Whether a registered entity without nexus is within the franchise tax levy. No court decision located decides it.
  6. Whether the next-business-day rule extends a refund claim period that ends on a weekend. GEN-9 and section 67-1-114 speak of returns and payments, and the statutes that govern the computation of time generally were not read.
  7. Interest on an ordinary refund claim, which this article does not cover.
  8. The later history of EmeraChem Power, LLC v. Gerregano. The opinion was read in a reproduction, and no citator was checked.
  9. Texts not read: the session law of Public Chapter 950 and of Public Chapter 616, including whether the family test applies by tax year or by date; the official edition of the Tennessee Code, because the statutes were read in a commercial reproduction of the 2025 code whose own notice says its text may trail the official code; the Department's sourcing rule for service receipts, described here as another article in this library states it; and the manual outside the pages cited.

Worked example

Facts. A holding limited partnership, organized in another state and never registered in Tennessee, owns 100 percent of a mezzanine LLC, also organized elsewhere and never registered in Tennessee. The mezzanine LLC owns 100 percent of each of two Tennessee single-member LLCs, Apartment LLC 1 and Apartment LLC 2. Each owns one apartment building in Tennessee and has no activity anywhere else, and an unrelated firm manages both buildings. No entity has elected to be classified as a corporation. The tax year is calendar 2025. The holding entity is a limited partnership because a general partnership is not a "person" under section 67-4-2004(36), and a general partnership at the top would be examined at its owners. An affiliate of the holding partnership, a management company organized as an LLC in another state, performs services only for the partnership's other properties outside Tennessee and performs none for Apartment LLC 1 or 2.

Each apartment LLC, calendar 2025.

  1. Classification. The single member is not a corporation, so the LLC is its own taxpayer.
  2. Excise tax. Tennessee net earnings of $300,000 times 6.5 percent equals $19,500.
  3. Franchise tax. The balance sheet shows real property at book value, taken as generally accepted accounting principles, of $8,000,000, cash of $200,000 and mortgage debt of $5,200,000. Net worth is $8,200,000 less $5,200,000, which is $3,000,000. The LLC has no right to apportion and enters 100 percent. $3,000,000 divided by $100 is 30,000 units, and 30,000 times $0.25 equals $7,500. Each base is an exact multiple of $100, so the major fraction rule does not arise.
  4. Total per LLC. $19,500 plus $7,500 equals $27,000, and the two LLCs together owe $54,000.
  5. Comparison with the repealed measure. Under the property measure the franchise base would have been the greater of net worth ($3,000,000) or the value of the property at cost less accumulated depreciation, taken here as $8,000,000 with cash excluded. $8,000,000 times 0.25 percent equals $20,000 of franchise tax, against $7,500 now. This is an illustration on the example's premises and not a computation of any actual year.
  6. Estimates. Each LLC's combined liability for 2024 is assumed to have been $25,000, and after credits both years exceed $5,000. Each installment is the lesser of 25 percent of $25,000, which is $6,250, or 25 percent of 80 percent of $27,000, which is $5,400. So $5,400 is due on April 15, June 16, September 15, 2025 and January 15, 2026, or $21,600 in all. June 15, 2025 was a Sunday, so the second installment moves to Monday, June 16 under GEN-9 and section 67-1-114. The balance due with the return is $27,000 less $21,600, which is $5,400. The return is due April 15, 2026, a Wednesday, the 15th day of the fourth month after the period end.

The mezzanine LLC and the holding limited partnership. On the manual's position, neither has a Tennessee filing requirement, because neither registered and neither has Tennessee activity of its own. If both had registered with the Secretary of State, each would file and pay at least the $100 minimum franchise tax on the Department's reading, with no excise tax on its own account. The $100 is a floor and not a computed figure. The mezzanine LLC's separate-entity net worth would include its investment in the two apartment LLCs, about $6,000,000 on the example's balance sheets, and its franchise tax would be the minimum only if its apportionment ratio is zero. The receipts of an apartment LLC that does business in Tennessee and files are left out of its owner's apportionment factors, as the separate article on lower-tier factors explains, and the mezzanine LLC has no receipts of its own. No source read says what ratio then applies, and the Department could treat the entity as having no right to apportion, in which case the tax would be higher than the minimum. The article states no figure for that case. The two apartment LLCs' $54,000 would not change either way, and no part of the apartment LLCs' income is taxed again at the owners above them.

The affiliate's refund. For 2024 the management company filed a Tennessee return and paid $4,000 with the return on April 15, 2025. It treated its affiliation with the Tennessee LLCs as nexus and, having no Tennessee office, entered 100 percent rather than apportioning. Its 2024 net earnings were a loss, so the return showed franchise tax only. It computed franchise tax at 100 percent of a net worth of $1,600,000: $1,600,000 divided by $100 is 16,000, and 16,000 times $0.25 equals $4,000. The company has no Tennessee receipts, property or payroll, and it provides no service to either Tennessee LLC. Had it had nexus and apportioned, all of its apportionment factors would have been zero on those facts, and the franchise tax before the minimum would have been $0, because the Form FAE 170 instructions direct 100 percent only for an entity that is not entitled to apportion.

  • If it is not registered with the Secretary of State and has no Tennessee activity, nothing was owed, and the refund is $4,000.
  • If it is registered with the Secretary of State, the $100 minimum was owed on the Department's reading and the refund is $3,900. The company may keep filing and paying $100 a year, or withdraw with a tax clearance requested by checking the final return box on its last return. On the taxpayer's counter the whole $4,000 was in error.
  • Deadline. A payment made with the return is made when paid, April 15, 2025, so the claim is due within three years of December 31, 2025, which is December 31, 2028. That date is a Sunday, and no source read says the claim may wait for Monday, so the claim should be received by Friday, December 29, 2028. If the company also paid with a 2023 return filed April 15, 2024, that year's period ends December 31, 2027, a Friday, so the earlier year runs out first.
  • Route. The company files an amended 2024 return showing the correct tax and the overpayment, which is the claim by statute, and may also file the claim in TNTAP. It states each ground under penalties of perjury and completes a report of debts because the refund is $200 or more. It keeps proof of its lack of Tennessee presence. If the claim is received December 1, 2026, a Tuesday, the six months end June 1, 2027, and a chancery court suit challenging the denial or deemed denial must be filed by December 1, 2027.
  • The premise fails if the company provides any service to Apartment LLC 1 or 2, such as asset management, accounting or lender reporting. A service receipt is Tennessee's "if and to the extent the service is delivered to a location in this state" (section 67-4-2012(i)(1)(C)), and the Department's rule reads "delivered" by the location of the taxpayer's market for the service and not by where the provider's property or payroll sits (Tenn. Comp. R. & Regs. 1320-06-01-.42(4)(a), as another article in this library describes it). The fee would then be a Tennessee receipt even though the work is done elsewhere.

What the example shows and leaves out. It shows that the lower tier pays on its own and that the owners above it file nothing unless registered. It leaves out interest on a refund, the franchise tax computation for a registered upper tier, and any examination of the affiliate's other years that an amended return might prompt.

Practice notes

Map every tier by owner type and legal form before the first Tennessee return. A noncorporate owner means each LLC below it is its own taxpayer, a corporate owner or a corporate classification election changes that for the LLCs below it, and a general partnership is not a taxpayer and is examined at its owners (Tenn. Code Ann. sections 67-4-2007(d), 67-4-2106(c) and 67-4-2004(36)).

Check each upper tier's registration with the Secretary of State and with the Department. On the Department's reading a registered upper tier files each year and pays at least $100, so decide for each one whether to keep filing or to withdraw properly with a tax clearance (section 67-4-2119; Revenue Ruling 02-16). Record the basis for the position that an unregistered upper tier with no Tennessee activity does not file, including who acts for it in the state, because that position rests on the Department's manual and not on a statute or a court.

Give each upper tier that files in Tennessee the lower tier's Schedule K-1 or a list showing the entity's name, federal employer identification number and Tennessee account number, so that it can support the adjustment on Form FAE 170, Schedule J, line 25. A federal Schedule K-1 alone does not carry the account information, and the mechanics for a single-member LLC that issues no Schedule K-1 are open, so document the method used.

Put the estimated installments and the extension payment on the calendar for each separately filing LLC. Move an installment to the next business day when the 15th is a Saturday, a Sunday or a legal holiday. Pay the extension amount, the lesser of 90 percent of the current year's liability or 100 percent of the prior year's tax shown due, on or before the original due date (section 67-4-2015(h)(1)(A)).

For a payment made without nexus, file the amended return and refund claim before December 31 of the third year after the payment year, and calendar each year's date separately. When December 31 falls on a weekend, file by the last business day before it. State the Department's position and the taxpayer's counter, with the refund each produces, and include the report of debts when the refund is $200 or more (section 67-1-1802).

Check the final return box only on the last return of an entity that has ended its Tennessee business or financial activity, by liquidation or withdrawal. The box is deemed a request for tax clearance, which is the route to closing the account properly. Do not use it to correct an earlier return.

Keep proof of no Tennessee presence for any affiliate that paid, and confirm that the affiliate bills no service to a Tennessee LLC before relying on a no-receipts premise.

G&G State Tax Group advises owners of multi-tier real estate structures on Tennessee franchise and excise tax entity mapping, nexus and registration, and refund claims alongside its state and local tax practice.

This article states the law as of November 11, 2026

Statutes, rates, thresholds, and agency practice change, and a different set of facts can change the answer. Before acting on anything discussed above, contact G&G State Tax Group, or another state and local tax adviser, to confirm what has changed since this was written and how the rules apply to a specific situation.

Contact the firm+1 714.234.5538 · info@gandgsalt.com

This publication is informational in nature and is not, and should not be considered, legal, accounting, tax, or other professional advice for any person or situation. Correct application of tax law depends heavily on the facts and circumstances in each case, and G&G State Tax Group, LLC assumes no liability in connection with the use of this information, and is not obligated to inform any reader of changes in the law or other factors that could affect the information contained herein.